5th Edition versus 2nd

Teh_Troll

Master of Baiting
So after playing a 5.5E PnP campaign for about a year . . . I have to say that 5th edition is absolute garbage.

Don't get me wrong, I'm having fun because I've got a great group, DM, and campaign. But this would be better in a game that wasn't such a slog.

Combat encounters take FOREVER. Damage is spikey as hell compared to earlier editions, and there's no semblance of class/monster balance. It's worse than DDO.

If getting back into PnP do yourselves a favor and play the older editions.
 

kmoustakas

Scourge of Xaos
So after playing a 5.5E PnP campaign for about a year . . . I have to say that 5th edition is absolute garbage.

Don't get me wrong, I'm having fun because I've got a great group, DM, and campaign. But this would be better in a game that wasn't such a slog.

Combat encounters take FOREVER. Damage is spikey as hell compared to earlier editions, and there's no semblance of class/monster balance. It's worse than DDO.

If getting back into PnP do yourselves a favor and play the older editions.
5e kind of requires you to know what you are doing, it's not like 1st or 2nd that you just go 'I attack' and that's it or 3rd edition that needs a calculator. But if you know what you are doing you can do 10 things on your turn and if you don't know what you're doing you need half an hour to just say "I don't know what I'm doing"

In my humble 34 years of experience with d&d, 5e is for gamers, 1st-2nd edition is for theater kids, 4th edition is for board games/war games and 3rd is for computer games.
 

Owlbear

Well-known member
So after playing a 5.5E PnP campaign for about a year . . . I have to say that 5th edition is absolute garbage.

Don't get me wrong, I'm having fun because I've got a great group, DM, and campaign. But this would be better in a game that wasn't such a slog.

Combat encounters take FOREVER. Damage is spikey as hell compared to earlier editions, and there's no semblance of class/monster balance. It's worse than DDO.

If getting back into PnP do yourselves a favor and play the older editions.
I've played a lot of 5e and I really like how approachable 5e is for new players. It's great to start learning dnd because it's all so basic. Combat isn't usually a drag that takes forever and you also have a DM that is there to balance the combat. If you don't like the time combat takes in your campaign tell the DM and he can do something about that. Or maybe you just have too many players in your group? The sweet spot for me is 4 players. Talking about encounters that take forever... try playing 3.5 where you actually have to do a lot of math and keeping note of all the active buffs because not every spell was concentration yet. Encounters took so much longer! 😂 They really streamlined the encounters a lot with 5e.
 

Mokune

Well-known member
I started with Basic set in '81. Later I got Expert and Companion sets. Got all the AD&D 1st edition books Xmas of '82. Played some 2.0 in college. Last pnp ed. I played was 3.5 when it was new and then only for a few months before diving head-first into music production. Have not played any pnp since. Did some Asheron's Call and WoW each for about a year. Been at DDO since 9/09

I did buy the 1st Edition Pathfinder books a few years back for my apocalypse library. Was really impressed by the artwork and mechanics. I also bought the hard cover 3.5 Expanded Psionics handbook for funsies.
 

Igognito

Well-known member
Each edition has its pros and cons.
I would argue that 5e introduced a cool system for spell casting and magical items.
But 3.5 (& Pathfinder 1) have the best skill system and build flexibility. In the other hand 2nd edition had so much RP color that you wouldn't care about mechanics.

4th edition doesnt even worth to mention. And 1st edition is covered by 2nd 😅
 

Jaspar

Well-known member
So after playing a 5.5E PnP campaign for about a year . . . I have to say that 5th edition is absolute garbage.

Don't get me wrong, I'm having fun because I've got a great group, DM, and campaign. But this would be better in a game that wasn't such a slog.

Combat encounters take FOREVER. Damage is spikey as hell compared to earlier editions, and there's no semblance of class/monster balance. It's worse than DDO.

If getting back into PnP do yourselves a favor and play the older editions.

My most favourite memories are AD&D but I often played with just a DM or one other player and the DM, so got to play more than one character - so the classes which just do nothing early on, or just do nothing other than be a meat sack are smoothed out by also playing characters which can do stuff.

But 3.5e would be my favourite if playing a single character because all classes could do so much more. Though I will say, 5e probably is the most rounded and broad for abilities and playing literally anything you want and being able to make it work. But when I think about it, its not really the D&D I grew up playing.

Also, I have 43 years of D&D. What do I win?

I still have a bunch of 1st ed modules somewhere which are apparently worth a lot of money. But I cant imagine there is a huge market for them. Particularly living in a low pop. country.
 

kmoustakas

Scourge of Xaos
My most favourite memories are AD&D but I often played with just a DM or one other player and the DM, so got to play more than one character - so the classes which just do nothing early on, or just do nothing other than be a meat sack are smoothed out by also playing characters which can do stuff.

But 3.5e would be my favourite if playing a single character because all classes could do so much more. Though I will say, 5e probably is the most rounded and broad for abilities and playing literally anything you want and being able to make it work. But when I think about it, its not really the D&D I grew up playing.

Also, I have 43 years of D&D. What do I win?

I still have a bunch of 1st ed modules somewhere which are apparently worth a lot of money. But I cant imagine there is a huge market for them. Particularly living in a low pop. country.
You win a badge of honour! 43 years damn I'm 45 years old
 

Jaspar

Well-known member
You win a badge of honour! 43 years damn I'm 45 years old

My older brother somehow heard about it and got mum to buy the DMG and PH. Then we added more books and more modules over the next few years.

I still have all of them though Unearthed Arcana was so cheaply made it fell apart within a few days.
 
Top