So after playing a 5.5E PnP campaign for about a year . . . I have to say that 5th edition is absolute garbage.
Don't get me wrong, I'm having fun because I've got a great group, DM, and campaign. But this would be better in a game that wasn't such a slog.
Combat encounters take FOREVER. Damage is spikey as hell compared to earlier editions, and there's no semblance of class/monster balance. It's worse than DDO.
If getting back into PnP do yourselves a favor and play the older editions.
My most favourite memories are AD&D but I often played with just a DM or one other player and the DM, so got to play more than one character - so the classes which just do nothing early on, or just do nothing other than be a meat sack are smoothed out by also playing characters which can do stuff.
But 3.5e would be my favourite if playing a single character because all classes could do so much more. Though I will say, 5e probably is the most rounded and broad for abilities and playing literally anything you want and being able to make it work. But when I think about it, its not really the D&D I grew up playing.
Also, I have 43 years of D&D. What do I win?
I still have a bunch of 1st ed modules somewhere which are apparently worth a lot of money. But I cant imagine there is a huge market for them. Particularly living in a low pop. country.