At what point does selling a product that doesn't work fraud?

Mechgraber

Well-known member
I'm guessing there's fine print somewhere or another in an agreement that we all checked off but didn't actually read that doesn't guarantee 100% uptime to the game, or 100% functionality.
 

Kimbere

Well-known member
Asking as I'm not a lawyer, but at what point is selling a non-working product fraud?
IANAL either, but I would think that the first step is that you have to request a refund or credit for non-delivery of services.

If you can prove the product doesn't (i.e. videos of being lag locked repeatedly over a month or so) and the company refuses to give your money back, that would likely be when it creeps into the fraud territory.

The other thing that might constitute fraud is if you found evidence that one or more employees at said company knew the product wouldn't work as advertised but they went ahead and sold it anyway. Getting that sort of evidence would require lawyers and subpoenas for their internal emails, etc. unless they have an employee who goes public (aka whistleblower).
 

Stellsbelles

Well-known member
It is classified as fraud when a person or company sells a product without clarification on said product. If the product doesn't do as stated in print or advertisment. Now if a company or person sells as a work in progress or AS IS, clarification, it wouldn't be fraud.
I'm not a lawyer, but I do work for an MMO company.
As a consumer you have the right to ask for a refund. If you believe that the product is not what was advertised as, and without any clause information on agreements to TOS we all sign when we sub or use almost any digital product or service.
 

Lencrennis

Well-known member
Incorrect. "As-is" does not protect a product from fraud. As-is only functions when there is good faith at play. If the seller knows the product is and will be bad, then that's fraud territory.
 

Fhrek

One Badge of Honor achieved
You have to read the fine print. It's not a fantasy game. It's a fantasy of a game.
See... that is a fine good looking bada** out of the park reply that deserved a 😂 because it is fun as hell, hilarious and well done! But, we can't
 

Gaxpar

Well-known member
I think we are way past that point if this was a brand new car and not brand new servers it would be the biggest collective lawsuit ever .
 

pirotessa

Well-known member
Pretty sure most people who bought the expansion at least expected all of the dm narrations to be complete...at a minimum. And with the copy paste of dino loot did it take them 2 months to put this together? Biggest meh expansion so far.
 

Striga

Well-known member
Incorrect. "As-is" does not protect a product from fraud. As-is only functions when there is good faith at play. If the seller knows the product is and will be bad, then that's fraud territory.
But what if the buyer knows the product is or will be bad and still decides to buy.
 

AbyssalMage

Well-known member
Asking as I'm not a lawyer, but at what point is selling a non-working product fraud?
My understanding is that you have to prove that they knew it was NOT working which you could never prove because they can show thousands of players logged on and remained on for hours.
 

Balvix

Well-known member
I think there is something in the "basic expectations of a product" category to begin an argument.
 

Throbulator

Well-known member
I do fondly remember back when an Australian court ruled against Zenimax back in the days after the dumpster fire that was Fallout 76.
 

Deathdefy

Well-known member
I do fondly remember back when an Australian court ruled against Zenimax back in the days after the dumpster fire that was Fallout 76.
The Australian Consumer Law (ACL) is pretty amazing! I am not a lawyer and the below is not legal advice:

Companies doing business in Australia (including online - though obvs harder to enforce with an international) can't contract their way out of basic guarantees (e.g. via a EULA/ToS agreement). No idea if other countries have equivalent 'you can't contract your way out of basic consumer rights' legislation but we do and it rocks.

Some interesting provisions imo are:
1) guarantees of service/good being 'fit for purpose' (not sure what that looks like for MMOs and availability), and
2) that businesses can't take payment for undeliverable goods/services (s36 of the ACL).
"...There are reasonable grounds, of which the person is aware or ought reasonably to be aware, for believing the person will not be able to supply the good or service in the time specified or, if no time is specified, within a reasonable time."
Reasonableness determined by (the court's interpretation) of what is reasonable in all the circumstances.

I have no idea if there's precedent litigating the, 'they're virtual goods so no consumer law guarantees count', argument - but it'd be on a court to make a call; just asserting you had no obligation and the customer has no recourse because they signed something doesn't work in Aus.
 
Top