PraetorPlato
Well-known member
TL;DR: blocking DR seems extremely wrong, data below.
(pulling this out from post-u59 thread)
Just stepped into hunt on LN on my tank alt and stood there for a few minutes blocking and letting people punch me. I can't dump combat log here because I can't export it, but I'll grab a representative section. Everything seems to check out, other than some very odd damage reduction results—would love if somebody could explain them. 393 PRR, DR 37 while blocking according to character sheet. Combat log says something else! (These numbers are post-being-netted, so ~0 PRR).
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for a total of 119 points of pierce damage after 144 were blocked by damage reduction.
(Combat): Senior Hunter Oka's fire hit you for a total of 149 points of fire damage after 15 were blocked by energy resistance.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Pixie's freezing bolt hit you for a total of 24 points of cold damage after 65 were blocked by energy resistance.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Hound hit you for a total of 17 points of slash damage after 259 were blocked by damage reduction.
The energy resistances are correct, but I don't understand the DR. Theoretically, raid's don't have dungeon scaling, which is known to cause DR display weirdness.
144 and 259 are consistent numbers for DR from archers and hounds respectively.
I then tried without blocking.
The interesting part of the combat log, junk trimmed, starting with standing PRR of 359:
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 88 points of pierce damage
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 75 points of pierce damage
Combat): You are hit by senior hunter oka's hunter's net.
(Combat): A well used net covered in barbs. While trapped within, Physical Resistance Rating and Magical Resistance rating are greatly reduced.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 445 points of pierce damage.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Redcap hit you for 598 points of slash damage.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Hound hit you for 657 points of pierce damage.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 568 points of pierce damage
*skipping a bunch more in that vein, 3 seconds later, hunter's net still on*
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 375 points of pierce damage
(Combat): Wild Hunt Hound hit you for 287 points of slash damage
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 375 points of pierce damage.
I noticed that damage seemed to come down over time, so I decided to try again, but with my character sheet open to watch PRR/MRR. The declining damage over time did not replicate, but I believe my PRR was reduced by 400: because of active effects, it's hard to get an exact value, but my total PRR was about -20 after I got netted. Archer damage values were in the range of 450, melee damage values closer to 600. Before netted, I was taking 80 an arrow.
I then tried elite with blocking to figure out what's going on.
(Combat) Apex Hound Koro hit you for a total of 370 points of pierce damage after 592 were blocked by damage reduction.
(Combat) Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for a total of 210 points of pierce damage after 198 were blocked by damage reduction.
Both of these numbers were consistent and pre-net, so with ~360-370 PRR. Curious if anyone has an idea.
(pulling this out from post-u59 thread)
Just stepped into hunt on LN on my tank alt and stood there for a few minutes blocking and letting people punch me. I can't dump combat log here because I can't export it, but I'll grab a representative section. Everything seems to check out, other than some very odd damage reduction results—would love if somebody could explain them. 393 PRR, DR 37 while blocking according to character sheet. Combat log says something else! (These numbers are post-being-netted, so ~0 PRR).
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for a total of 119 points of pierce damage after 144 were blocked by damage reduction.
(Combat): Senior Hunter Oka's fire hit you for a total of 149 points of fire damage after 15 were blocked by energy resistance.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Pixie's freezing bolt hit you for a total of 24 points of cold damage after 65 were blocked by energy resistance.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Hound hit you for a total of 17 points of slash damage after 259 were blocked by damage reduction.
The energy resistances are correct, but I don't understand the DR. Theoretically, raid's don't have dungeon scaling, which is known to cause DR display weirdness.
144 and 259 are consistent numbers for DR from archers and hounds respectively.
I then tried without blocking.
The interesting part of the combat log, junk trimmed, starting with standing PRR of 359:
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 88 points of pierce damage
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 75 points of pierce damage
Combat): You are hit by senior hunter oka's hunter's net.
(Combat): A well used net covered in barbs. While trapped within, Physical Resistance Rating and Magical Resistance rating are greatly reduced.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 445 points of pierce damage.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Redcap hit you for 598 points of slash damage.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Hound hit you for 657 points of pierce damage.
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 568 points of pierce damage
*skipping a bunch more in that vein, 3 seconds later, hunter's net still on*
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 375 points of pierce damage
(Combat): Wild Hunt Hound hit you for 287 points of slash damage
(Combat): Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for 375 points of pierce damage.
I noticed that damage seemed to come down over time, so I decided to try again, but with my character sheet open to watch PRR/MRR. The declining damage over time did not replicate, but I believe my PRR was reduced by 400: because of active effects, it's hard to get an exact value, but my total PRR was about -20 after I got netted. Archer damage values were in the range of 450, melee damage values closer to 600. Before netted, I was taking 80 an arrow.
I then tried elite with blocking to figure out what's going on.
(Combat) Apex Hound Koro hit you for a total of 370 points of pierce damage after 592 were blocked by damage reduction.
(Combat) Wild Hunt Ranger hit you for a total of 210 points of pierce damage after 198 were blocked by damage reduction.
Both of these numbers were consistent and pre-net, so with ~360-370 PRR. Curious if anyone has an idea.
