Cost of expansions are beyond unreasonable

Realism51

Active member
Was looking forward to the expansion and considering getting something more than the base, but then I saw the cost.
How is it that the developers really think a game that is over 20 years old, warrants a $130 price tag for a fan bundle expansion, or $80 for soupy yay version.
Looking at past expansions, foir the most part those seem less in cost.
Even when I bought MOTU way back in the day, it was base $45 and ultimate being $80. I bought the ultimate and it came with so much, including like $30 of TP points.
I enjoy the game, but $130 is an outrageous amount to ask for a new expansion.
At what point does the new devs realize majority of people are unwilling to pay that much for something that gives so little
 

Cyran

Well-known member
This been the price for new full expansions since Mists of Ravenloft all the way back in 2017. Saltmarsh and Vecna Unleashed was a bit cheaper since they considered mini-expansions but otherwise this been the price for expansions at launch (Mists,Sharn,Feywild,Isle of dread, Drannor and Chill).

I do wish they included a bit more stuff in the ultimate package to increase it value but lowering the price was never going to happen.
 

Nod

I don't work for SSG- I pay their bills.
What FirstofAllGods said ^ if you want it, buy the base. If you want the tome (only useful thing in there) save up DDO points from favor and wait for them to put it on sale.

They greatly reduced the value of the stupid teleporter with the Chill of Lamordia expansion, bc if you use it but have not done the entrance quest, it ports you to house J. What f'n good is that? xD
 
Last edited:

kmoustakas

Scourge of Xaos
Was looking forward to the expansion and considering getting something more than the base, but then I saw the cost.
How is it that the developers really think a game that is over 20 years old, warrants a $130 price tag for a fan bundle expansion, or $80 for soupy yay version.
Looking at past expansions, foir the most part those seem less in cost.
Even when I bought MOTU way back in the day, it was base $45 and ultimate being $80. I bought the ultimate and it came with so much, including like $30 of TP points.
I enjoy the game, but $130 is an outrageous amount to ask for a new expansion.
At what point does the new devs realize majority of people are unwilling to pay that much for something that gives so little
I got shadowfail the first time it was 2,49$
 

norriskwondo

Well-known member
Was looking forward to the expansion and considering getting something more than the base, but then I saw the cost.
How is it that the developers really think a game that is over 20 years old, warrants a $130 price tag for a fan bundle expansion, or $80 for soupy yay version.
Looking at past expansions, foir the most part those seem less in cost.
Even when I bought MOTU way back in the day, it was base $45 and ultimate being $80. I bought the ultimate and it came with so much, including like $30 of TP points.
I enjoy the game, but $130 is an outrageous amount to ask for a new expansion.
At what point does the new devs realize majority of people are unwilling to pay that much for something that gives so little
I only agree with you on this one premise, they are atill using the rare loot system to acquire gear we paid actual money to acquire with effort, which will never happen. Otherwise, with the playable content, and the extra's and if the rare loot was absent, I honestly believe the expansion prices are reasonably priced. After all, it's a free to play game, no one has to purchase them to play. But if no one purchases stuff from the game, we won't have a the game to play. Personally, I love this game, and I don't have a problem supporting the things I love.
 

kmoustakas

Scourge of Xaos
Of course this one costs more. Have any of you gone to the grocery store since covid. Everything is 3x's more and you get less of it. The inflation on this game is nothing compared to say the cost of eggs and other main staples of food we need to survive.
I guess if you wait a few years the eggs will be cheaper too? Though I think they rot after a couple of months :p
 

Supot

Well-known member
It is for the whales. The fact that its a 20 yr old game with a small number of players, its kind of a miracle the game is still going strong and still updated regularly.

For most people, this game is not just a game but a lifestyle, and can't be compared to the price they pay for a single player game that will be played once for 100 hours. People who play DDO play 100+ hours a month.

That being said, I don't buy the Ultimates or the Collector's editions. Above my price range. The only time I did so was MOTU. Only thing in it for me is the +1 Universal Enhancement Tome, which I'll just wait til the sale. I don't care for the other stuff.
 

kmoustakas

Scourge of Xaos
It is for the whales. The fact that its a 20 yr old game with a small number of players, its kind of a miracle the game is still going strong and still updated regularly.

For most people, this game is not just a game but a lifestyle, and can't be compared to the price they pay for a single player game that will be played once for 100 hours. People who play DDO play 100+ hours a month.

That being said, I don't buy the Ultimates or the Collector's editions. Above my price range. The only time I did so was MOTU. Only thing in it for me is the +1 Universal Enhancement Tome, which I'll just wait til the sale. I don't care for the other stuff.
It's a well documented fact that if you spend thousands upon thousands of hours doing the same thing, it becomes your personality. For most people that's work, for us it's MMOs (which is basically PAY to WORK haha). It's no longer a game.
 

Greyhawk5

Was Amorais
I would likely have bought the ultimate editions for these expansions when they came out but the price point is so high, its dreadful value for money.

I no longer have any room for the cosmetics, I have a ton of mounts and there's already close to 1000 quests in the game so its just not worth it.

Even the absolute base edition is similar to the price of a full game on steam.
 

SquireZed

Well-known member
I think the ultimate expansions are not entirely unreasonable if you play multiple characters heavily- the various per character tomes are probably worth it if you actually seriously play multiple characters and would want to put tomes on them. But that assumes you care about tomes and play multiple characters.

The value proposition for single character players is not particularly great, nor is it worth it if you only play alts casually and don't care about having them maxed out. The exception is if you're in love with the cosmetics, really need the account/character storage because your bank is full and you don't have a cheaper way to get it, or want the hireling from the expansion. Unless you have some combination of the above, the value is probably pretty limited.

I actually think the worst value breakpoint is between the standard and the collectors' edition. Beyond the cosmetics, it's just a bit of storage, the heroic hireling, and a character slot. Heroic hirelings are, in my opinion, more valuable than legendary hirelings just because they tend to die a bit slower. However, if you don't use hirelings that's essentially a point value of 1620 with some cosmetics thrown in. All of that is account level stuff, so the value is one and done compared to something like tomes. I also don't think character slots are worth that much, but if you're an altaholic they may be so I'm going to be nice and count it at full value.

On the other hand, +1 Universal Enhancement Tomes run 3495 points a pop, and having one on each character increases that value (though to be fair I wouldn't count it as a full 3495 on each because I would never by a tome for that price on an alt). The iconic is also 1395 points. Character storage is 595 points. The bag is... bound to character so I'm not going to count it because I'm petty. And another character slot, of course, for 625. That brings us to 6120 before any value you add for alts using the tomes as well.

That makes it a roughly $50 difference for a 6120 point value, as opposed to a $40 difference for a roughly 1620 point value (not counting cosmetics and hirelings). If I actually tome'd up all my alts I play somewhat regularly, I would be spending around 10485 at the inflated AP tome price for the new expansion's tome, and that's not counting the alts I play just to test builds or occasionally run something when my main or other alts are at the wrong level. Both are probably still not "worth" the cost in points to buy features piecemeal, especially on sale.

I think the base expansion is worth it- $40 for 4590 points worth of value is reasonable, more or less, and while expansion's adventure packs do go on sale I would generally say I don't mind paying full price given how much I've actually liked the recent content in DDO (for the most part, ignoring rare loot and specific annoying quests). However, 1620 points is a terrible deal for $40 and 7730 points worth of stuff for $90 isn't great either and all of that is before sales discounting those numbers- though the account storage, character storage, and character slots *are* exclusive to the bundle so they can't really go on sale if you don't have any more options to buy outside the expansion. But if the cosmetics and hirelings exclusive to the expansion (or you can't get more storage and slots from the store without buying an expansion), well, I think you can make the argument that the expansion is worth it, and I certainly can't fault you personally. I'm a sucker for Flumphs, and once they had me hooked the sunk cost falacy demands I waste more money.

No one said I was smart. I can do the math to some degree of accuracy (I look forward to finding out I counted something wrong) but not the critical thinking.

Of course all of this assumes that you believe that the price in points is reasonable, or that you're buying points inefficiently, to justify the comparative prices. If you don't think any of the items in the expansion are worth the prices they'll be listed at in the store, then I think you're safe to skip the expansion entirely as you are with any expansion. But value is relative, so reasonable and unreasonable probably devolve into speculation at some point.
 
Last edited:

Driaza

Asker of Questions
It is for the whales. The fact that its a 20 yr old game with a small number of players, its kind of a miracle the game is still going strong and still updated regularly.

For most people, this game is not just a game but a lifestyle, and can't be compared to the price they pay for a single player game that will be played once for 100 hours. People who play DDO play 100+ hours a month.

That being said, I don't buy the Ultimates or the Collector's editions. Above my price range. The only time I did so was MOTU. Only thing in it for me is the +1 Universal Enhancement Tome, which I'll just wait til the sale. I don't care for the other stuff.
Yup kinda

If you have been playing this game mostly for the last 20 years and probably have 10,000 -30,000 hours played. (2 hours per day plus 4 hours on weekends puts you close to 20k over 20 years) then $130 aint much really for an expansion that comes out what once a year or 2?

And if you have been playing for that long you are anywhere from mid thirties to early sixties

So even a conservative $200 per month still aint that much. Thats not whale money either

DDO is not a retail game - the lights are kept on by middle aged men (most likely) who have this as their main passtime

The real whales help ofcourse

But for those of you who are newer and/ or not in a good place financially at the moment then its basically free to play and aquire DDO points and get just about everything you need
 

CherryBomb

Well-known member
Just think about the effect that the upcoming GTA VI might have on industry pricing. If they price that at $100 or more for the base game then all other game developers will see it as a green light to increase prices (for both base entry and DLC).

Long gone are the days when the premier games cost $35 for the complete package with bonuses.

You should also remember that DDO is FREE TO PLAY. huh?????
 

Driaza

Asker of Questions
Just think about the effect that the upcoming GTA VI might have on industry pricing. If they price that at $100 or more for the base game then all other game developers will see it as a green light to increase prices (for both base entry and DLC).

Long gone are the days when the premier games cost $35 for the complete package with bonuses.

You should also remember that DDO is FREE TO PLAY. huh?????
Yup

The other game i have played consistently over the decades has been Europa Universalis IV

That also had paid expansions

you cannot have a 1 and done payment for a game like DDO and expect updates etc

I dont think the subscription / VIP model can cover expansions

VIP i think literally keep lights on
Store sales get you updates
Expansions well pay for expansions
 

TrinityTurtle

Forum Turtle
It is for the whales. The fact that its a 20 yr old game with a small number of players, its kind of a miracle the game is still going strong and still updated regularly.

For most people, this game is not just a game but a lifestyle, and can't be compared to the price they pay for a single player game that will be played once for 100 hours. People who play DDO play 100+ hours a month.

That being said, I don't buy the Ultimates or the Collector's editions. Above my price range. The only time I did so was MOTU. Only thing in it for me is the +1 Universal Enhancement Tome, which I'll just wait til the sale. I don't care for the other stuff.
This, but I dont' reallyt hink of msyelf as a whale. For me the math is simple. The money I spend on DDo gets me more hours of entertainment than something else. If i go to a movie now, it's $20 for 90 minutes of entertainment and a half hour of can we stop the ads now please? So that's $80 a month if Codex and I go see one moie a week. We spend more than 90 minutes a week on ddo.
When it isnt' fun anymore to play and the people we like are gone. And it doesn't cost me $80 a month. A yearly sub of $100 plus one expansion at $140 (that was with tax, not a typo) is $20 a month. I'ts not that expensive when I break it down.
Sadly, it's also cheaper than buying a new tabletop D&D book a month. Yes, I'm still mad at tehm wanting $50 a book or more for books that don't last like the older editions. My first ed boons are in better shape than my 3rd thrugh 5th.
 

Phoenicis

Savage's Husband
Was looking forward to the expansion and considering getting something more than the base, but then I saw the cost.
How is it that the developers really think a game that is over 20 years old, warrants a $130 price tag for a fan bundle expansion, or $80 for soupy yay version.
Looking at past expansions, foir the most part those seem less in cost.
Even when I bought MOTU way back in the day, it was base $45 and ultimate being $80. I bought the ultimate and it came with so much, including like $30 of TP points.
I enjoy the game, but $130 is an outrageous amount to ask for a new expansion.
At what point does the new devs realize majority of people are unwilling to pay that much for something that gives so little
The four people I saw last night with the new mount, pets and cosmetics would seem to disagree with you.
 

mikarddo

Well-known member
I agree the price tag is high - and very likely too high for many people.

But - the game is niche with a small playerbase and they have to earn enough money somehow. If the game had 10x or 50x the players the expansions and everything else could easily be cheaper.

Also - many of the players are (not young) adults that have disposeable money to spend. Not rich but just common people with cash to spend somehow - who will be comparing to dinner and a money for 2-4 people and then $130 isnt that much.

I am not defending the price tag - but I do understand it and I have often been willing to pay it - simply because it has been worth it to me to keep DDO going and $130 is not that much in my budget (mind, I am not rich).
 

Eltronin

Kobolds don't matter. *Except in Crystal Cove.
Was looking forward to the expansion and considering getting something more than the base, but then I saw the cost.
How is it that the developers really think a game that is over 20 years old, warrants a $130 price tag for a fan bundle expansion, or $80 for soupy yay version.
Looking at past expansions, foir the most part those seem less in cost.
Even when I bought MOTU way back in the day, it was base $45 and ultimate being $80. I bought the ultimate and it came with so much, including like $30 of TP points.
I enjoy the game, but $130 is an outrageous amount to ask for a new expansion.
At what point does the new devs realize majority of people are unwilling to pay that much for something that gives so little
Don't buy it. Really simple.
 
Top