"Energy Criticals"(Epic Past Life feat) issue...

Sarlona Raiding

Well-known member
So those insightful lore pieces are +13% crit. You can augment for +5% insightful lore, leaving an 8% difference. Which is only 3% more than what cold crits can get to. Considering that those pieces are from sharn, and level 29, you are already sacrificing a lot to use them compared to a dino bone orb or stick. The upcoming level cap increase would be the perfect time to make any changes to energy criticals. That or they need to introduce more insightful lore items to help those damage types stay afloat.

At this point I am just looking at two bonus types: Insightful Lore and Energy Criticals.

A long while back the devs stated these insightful lore items were intended to close the gap with energy criticals. Not sure why some spell types were left out entirely. For force it was likely due to shiradi casting and so many forum posts hating on shiradi when it used to be good and even well after it stopped being good.

I haven't tested, but should test whether insightful radianace lore and universial inisghtful lore stack. They really shouldn't but in some cases universal and specific damage types do stack.

Cold/Fire/Electric/Acid: 9% Energy Criticals + 5% Universal Insightful Lore = 14%.
Radiance/Negative: 13% Insightful Radiance Lore =13%
Force/Sonic/Positive: 5% Universal Insightful Lore = 5%
 

DBZ

Well-known member
We have 2 elemental EDs with no Helpless Damage and imbue dice that can't be used

1 hybrid ED with sneak dice also impossible to use with a Hard Cap and a Flat damage nerf on top
 

rabidfox

The People's Champion
I haven't tested, but should test whether insightful radianace lore and universial inisghtful lore stack. They really shouldn't but in some cases universal and specific damage types do stack.

Cold/Fire/Electric/Acid: 9% Energy Criticals + 5% Universal Insightful Lore = 14%.
Radiance/Negative: 13% Insightful Radiance Lore =13%
Force/Sonic/Positive: 5% Universal Insightful Lore = 5%
Someone on discord was confused by only getting 8% from their fury orb the other day until it was pointed out that Insightful Spell Lore V from Pomura's augment (etc.) doesn't stack with insightful radiance lore; so you've got the right numbers.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
Simply put, Dev's hate casters and ranged.
Or they don't understand them. Some of the assumptions that the devs have made about the functioning of IPS and the casting speed of casters seem to point in this direction.

It is one thing to know the numbers, and another to have practical experience. I'm afraid that the devs lack practical experience playing and that makes them get a few things wrong.
 

FaceDancer

Olde Wurm
Force, Negative, Positive, and Light are some of the forces (I would argue sonic as well) that seem to affect many critters in the game. I'm wondering if them missing from this feat was intentional by the devs to balance this?
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
Force, Negative, Positive, and Light are some of the forces (I would argue sonic as well) that seem to affect many critters in the game. I'm wondering if them missing from this feat was intentional by the devs to balance this?
Maybe it was a valid argument before introducing immunity bypass, but at this point? Bypasses are much more effective than these elements, which need more love.

Negative has many immunities. And deathward is a thing.
 

Smokewolf

Frequently banned member.
Or they don't understand them. Some of the assumptions that the devs have made about the functioning of IPS and the casting speed of casters seem to point in this direction.

It is one thing to know the numbers, and another to have practical experience. I'm afraid that the devs lack practical experience playing and that makes them get a few things wrong.
Your being overly optimistic in thinking the Dev's are simply incompetent. While I maintain that classes that primarily "range", under perform by design.
 

Sarlona Raiding

Well-known member
Simply put, Dev's hate casters and ranged.

I don't think they hate casters and ranged. People that solely play melee have been the squeeky wheels on the forums, and although some of the points raised were valid, there is also a serious "grass is greener on the other side" bias from players that only play one build type.

With that said, I definitely think melee is stronger overall, but casters and ranged still have some advantages that would be impossible to adjust for. For example my swashbuckler breezed through grim and barrett R8 barely taking any damage. Then I got to the end fight and died 3 times because my will save is trash and my MRR is only 130 in light armor. I had to have my caster alt raise me 3 times to get through it.

On the other hand my caster is much more likely to die leading up to the end fight, but does better in the end fight with higher mrr and the ability to fight away from the boss while moving around to avoid the divine wrath. It could also be I am missing a tell from the boss and can avoid the divine wrath on my melee, but it's hard to see with the all the effects and fighting the bushes.

At the moment I prefer melee for raiding. I prefer melee for R10 DPS. I prefer melee for about 90% of solo content, but the other 10% I really prefer to be on a caster. Casters are good support characters for R10s and raids. They appear more effective than they are due to high kill count, but in reality groups would have no problem killing things without a caster.

And the same people that always complain about melees being too weak will look at the kill count and fume despite performing much better overall.
 
Last edited:

Ying

5000+ hours played
Change energy criticals to effect all spells and change Arcane Alacrity to work on SLAs.
Or just add a divine epic past life feat for radiance, devotion, and nullification spell criticals. The design space for more epic past lives is there for Primal and Divine which only have 4 epic lives, while Arcane and Martial already have 5 epic past lives.
 

erethizon1

Well-known member
Or just add a divine epic past life feat for radiance, devotion, and nullification spell criticals. The design space for more epic past lives is there for Primal and Divine which only have 4 epic lives, while Arcane and Martial already have 5 epic past lives.
That would help a little, but the fundamental problem is that there is no way for my Warlock to get Acid and Force at the same time, the way a Sorc can get their two elements at the same time. Force really needs to be added to the arcane energy criticals we already have.
 

DBZ

Well-known member
You want ice acid force or fire acid force tetris aint fun

You can gear it warlocks problem is no crits in there trees and no stripping n garbage dcs with cap going up not worth it

A chrono sets not too bad max dcs and insightful quality spell powers with a profane set bonus too

On an alch not a sorc fire 1600, acid 1400, force almost 1300 multiplier 170 fire, 120 acid, 110 force

And you can fit a helpless set in too Sands or Sonic

Maybe MD won't suck 5050
 
Last edited:

rabidfox

The People's Champion
Or just add a divine epic past life feat for radiance, devotion, and nullification spell criticals. The design space for more epic past lives is there for Primal and Divine which only have 4 epic lives, while Arcane and Martial already have 5 epic past lives.
There's plenty of ways they could go for the same end result; doesn't matter to me which way we get there.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
That would help a little, but the fundamental problem is that there is no way for my Warlock to get Acid and Force at the same time, the way a Sorc can get their two elements at the same time. Force really needs to be added to the arcane energy criticals we already have.
Considering that Achmage promotes impulse and elementals, force makes sense in the arcane PL imo.

Not all should be designed for sorc imo.
 

Sarlona Raiding

Well-known member
Energy Criticals should affect sonic, no? Plus if you're a bard you can get +15% Exceptional Sonic lore from the Elyd Charm necklace, so it might be risky for them to add extra insighful lore for that.
It's just another inconsistency in the game - not sure why that is typed as exceptional vs. insightful, but obviously it's a best-in-class item for sonic casters. I am not sure if that stacks with exceptional universal lore either.
 
Top