I Just Lost 60 AC !

Bulwark

Member
Raise your skulls bro. It isn’t too easy for everyone and most of us don’t want to slog through Harbor quests taking forever after we have done it hundreds of times.
it really is bro game is too easy, reaper was hard now it ain't people doing r10 raids like it's nothing, r10 quests easier than it was back when curse of strahd came out
 

Contessor

Well-known member
I thought I read that the "to hit" of monsters was going down to compensate by about 30-40 ish at end game. If that is true, then this might be more acceptable, but still not even break even. But this is not what I am experiencing at all. It either is not enough, or those changes just never made it to live or are planned for later.

I hope the devs understand that balance is not about changing something now that might balance with something in a future update. Balance is literally these changes were made to counter X changes that are either currently in place or that will coincide with other changes being implemented within the same update. That is how things need to be done to achieve proper balance. We know history shows changes are made to anticipate something else down the road that never happens.

My PJ wearing monk had 250 AC ad yeah he is loaded with dodge, but that was another 5% miss chance in r10. Now his AC is around 170 and I have seen no misses at all, only Dodge. I know it is monk and they do have access to alot of dodge, but monks balance way more stats to get good defenses as well. Survivability on a class that cannot equip armor and equip a shield and even to build a bit for AC does require a considerable amount of investment to begin with. PJs really took a big hit on AC, probably the most impactful. To the point that my extra two augment slots abnd my sun slot are much better off spent elsewhere. That hardly seems like balance to me. There should be some benefit realized whenver you invest resources. The to hit and AC system is just broke and has been for a long time. This change really did nothing but expose those flaws, and likely create more balance rework to the devs.

Should monsters miss on a roll of a natural 1? I know it seems a bit one sided if players do not, however monsters and players are not balanced. This change seems like it would benefit most of the lower end AC builds at least.
 
Last edited:

Spook

Ghostly Troll
I thought I read that the "to hit" of monsters was going down to compensate by about 30-40 ish at end game. If that is true, then this might be more acceptable, but still not even break even. But this is not what I am experiencing at all. It either is not enough, or those changes just never made it to live or are planned for later.
No this was disingenuous from the devs. There was a calculation "bug" but only in the high end content. The AC problems started way before level 35.
 
no? what i'm saying you unlock those epic past lives once you hit 21 and above same with heroic past lives really simple same with iconics they're part of heroics since yea know start at level 15 which his a heroic level lol really not a hard of concept to understand and grasp though i guess some you have to explain things a little more for the more "simple minded"
Hehehe… Just because the word “epic” is in the name should not imply that it should be disabled until reaching epic levels. It is a past life benefit just like heroic and iconic. And if there is an argument to be made about disabling until epic, then there is an equal argument about applying it ONLY during epic. It’s a path to avoid either way.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
The to hit and AC system is just broke and has been for a long time. This change really did nothing but expose those flaws, and likely create more balance rework to the devs.
yes, AC system has been broken since its inception. Devs switched to this system because power creep had made the gap between specialist AC builds and the rest so wide that monster design became problematic (either monsters were designed solely to hit tanks, or there were characters who never got hit), but the new system hasn't really worked well either.
 

Bulwark

Member
Hehehe… Just because the word “epic” is in the name should not imply that it should be disabled until reaching epic levels. It is a past life benefit just like heroic and iconic. And if there is an argument to be made about disabling until epic, then there is an equal argument about applying it ONLY during epic. It’s a path to avoid either way.
it's called power creep? you don't get everything all at once you unlock them as you level, so you're at your full power at cap which imo makes the most sense rather than at level 1, also you're making 0 sense cause i don't think you understand what i'm saying, i really don't wanna type it again so i'm gonna ask you to reread what i wrote very slowly since you obviously didn't understand the first time
 
it's called power creep? you don't get everything all at once you unlock them as you level, so you're at your full power at cap which imo makes the most sense rather than at level 1, also you're making 0 sense cause i don't think you understand what i'm saying, i really don't wanna type it again so i'm gonna ask you to reread what i wrote very slowly since you obviously didn't understand the first time
A past life benefit should be immediately available at the start of the next life - not 1/3, 1/2, or 3/4 of the way through the next life.

The phrase “power creep” is meaningless. The point of a game like this is to become more powerful.
 

erethizon1

Well-known member
A past life benefit should be immediately available at the start of the next life - not 1/3, 1/2, or 3/4 of the way through the next life.

The phrase “power creep” is meaningless. The point of a game like this is to become more powerful.
Agreed. The entire point of playing DDO is to accumulate power on a single character and what makes it so much better than other games is the ability to use this accumulated power when starting a new life. Power that kicks in at level cap (or close to it) is no different than any other game.
 

Buddha5440

"There are some who call me...Tim"
You realize there's a middle-ground between "Way too much AC at level 1" and "basically no change until you get insane AC numbers"? They could've just capped the amount of AC granted at different level ranges, like they do with Tomes.
People would still complain just as vehemently.

Also, AC is pretty much irrelevant until you're over 250 or so. People that build tanks will get through this with no issues. People that want a high, but not really effective, AC will not but those builds never really relied on AC.
 
Last edited:

Draknowin

Well-known member
People would still complain just as vehemently.

Also, AC is pretty much irrelevant until you're over 250 or so. People that build tanks will get through this with no issues. People that want a high, but not really effective, AC will not but those builds never really relied on AC.
Yeah, and AC being pretty much irrelevant is a problem too. It's the basic form of 'not getting hit', and instead it's become 'oh, it doesn't really matter unless you specialize in it'.
 

Buddha5440

"There are some who call me...Tim"
Yeah, and AC being pretty much irrelevant is a problem too. It's the basic form of 'not getting hit', and instead it's become 'oh, it doesn't really matter unless you specialize in it'.
So how does losing some matter? You made my point.
 

Driaza

Asker of Questions
For me its the principal of the thing

Past lives were earned over years of play for some of us

They should not be touched without extensive testing and feedback. I do notice the drop of AC at all levels of play.

But its not so much the fact that i get hit more now its the fact that Epic Past lives were altered as a miscellaneous change

I mean come on - do a whole pass. take 6 months to look at it and figure it out

But to change something like this just as a misc change is wrong and a slap in the face of paying customers - some with almost 2 decades under their belt

Who WANTED this? Who ASKED for this? WHY was this done?
 

The Being

Well-known member
Arcane sphere might be safe from future nerfs with the 15% absorptions to only some damage types, but what about

+36 PRR
+36 hp(level1)/228hp(level 40)

Do those look in balance with +15% AC +15 MRR/MRR Cap? Can you be certain devs think they are balanced? Do you want to spend time engaging with one of the major gameplay loops of DDO if you're not? What about racial past lives or epic completionist bonuses? That's a lot of enhancement points to spend at level 1 or 20...

---

I actually think devs should add more sources of flat AC to the game in gear, that way the percentage bonus could still have value, and spread it around to more than the main AC stat of light/medium/heavy armor while at it.
They should have done that before or at same time as changing the past life however, and perhaps then they wouldn't have needed to add MRR/MRR Cap to it, and maybe people with proper investment in AC would not have been nerfed.

If +58 AC is what heavy armor has at cap, then surely there should be a +29 Insightful bonus to Armor as well, right? But we've got a +6 insightful (+7 on one item). +16 natural armor. +12 deflection. Boosting these other channels would be particularly important for cloth wearers who cannot get meaningful value out of the armor slot.
 

Ryiah

Well-known member
r1-r10 makes 0 difference for AC
That's simply not the case. I know the difference between having all of the Martial EPLs and not having them because one of my completionists is almost fully complete and the other two are varying degrees of incomplete with one of them practically fresh off the vine. I can see the difference in the number of hits between almost no Martial EPLs and full Martial EPLs.

Who WANTED this? Who ASKED for this? WHY was this done?
I'm not aware of a single game that balances itself solely off of requests from the players. As a game developer myself we typically have some form of analytics in place that is constantly watching to see what people are building and notices common trends. If something becomes a constant to the point that no one considers anything else that makes the investigation list and that leads to things like Inquisitive getting nerfed.

For the Martial EPLs you could run a significant portion of the Heroic content completely naked and have almost no incoming damage even standing in place and letting everything surround you. I know because I did that for years with every character including casters. I would gather up a large group, let them surround me, and Fireball. Until level 10 I was naked, and then I put on crafted gear and did the same to level 20. No issues at all.
 
Last edited:
Top