If you were to design a DDO raid, what mechanics would it have or not have?

Konsumer

Well-known member
A lot of discussion around raids and I'm curious what people would want to see?

Players would have to navigate a heavily and deadly trap laden course to get to the boss fight. Facing mobs along the way who are immune to that particular type of trap. Like the fire eles in Tempest spine at the fire trap there. Once they get to the boss fight area a small door opens in a huge room where dozens of mobs rush in from all sides. A seemingly endless amount that keeps coming. You must not allow a single mob to get through the small door. Meaning, maintaining CC, instakills, and AOE is crucial. If any mob makes it through the door, they will press a button on a panel inside the next room which will make the actual boss immune to physical damage. Causing a fail.
Inside the next room where the small door leads is the real boss. An immature Tarrasque that the Red Wizards of Thay were preparing to unleash on the continent. It's 100% immune to all forms of magic and has a seriously high DR to everything except metaline. Of course it's a huge bag of HP but it is subject to sneak attacks and debuffs.
 

Ungermax

Master Artificer
Something with lowering ceilings. Imagine some players are trapped in small rooms while others do a puzzle and each mistake on the puzzle lowers the ceiling in the small rooms meaning half the party could be dead at the start of the boss fight or something
 

Dulkhan

Well-known member
What I want to see
A longer Raid, in the way of Tempest Spine, but with a twist lets say we have to invade a castle and you have a timer to do so, so the main party is the front line, but then you have to create a sub party to go on the sides to help the main party advance but also there could be optionals to make the end fight easier , for example having to head to a room and disable the security system, another one with puzzles maybe you need to convince or intimidate someone from the castle to help you out, at a certain point when you reach the end you realize that you need to block the reinforcements to come and you have to create a stop and kill party in a small entrance, like in a 100 movie situation but smaller. ( enemies could be suceptible to magic to make space for casters in the raid in this area) and maybe another group could keep a reliq safe that make the boss vulnerable. while the main party dps the **** out of the boss I just want something that require more coordination in the group specially at higer difficulties. you can get extra chest if you do it before time runs out or if you do all of certain optionals.
If I could I would add an optional near the end of either the boss hp or timer, in which 2 ppl on the party could go to a different room to stop a new threat to **** it all up ( story wise) and when you this happen the timer change to let say a couple of minutes in which you need to kill the boss and the optional so your best dps needs to go to the optional to stop it.
I could go into more details of enough ppl like the idea. there is so much potential in ddo for raids that I feel is being wasted in this one room raid.
Hell I had an Idea of a raid for Isle of dread that begging with the boss fight but then you need to leave the islan as the volcano erupt and we would need to scape through the explorer zone but changed with optionals like rescueing ppl, dinosaurs and feries...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eme

Seppi Pearlsmith

Gnomepletionist
It would be rather unique: an arena with a big HP bag monster, waves of mobs and lots of lots of dots!
And a long cut scene before the single chest spawns.
 

Uppsy

Well-known member
Would love a raid where we storm somewhere, none of this 1 room big hp boss combat thing like recent (Threats/Lamordia). I love things like VoN/Titan/TS/ToD/Strahd, where we storm a big place and work together to get through it THEN have a boss at the end or with little lieutenants sprinkled within.
To do this I feel we need to turn away from the whole "We need to wrap the story with the main villain up in X amount of chains, then have a raid with something powerful we see within these chains".
A great example of how it should be done is the Strahd raid, where the 3 chains are great story and preparations for fighting the big bad boss, which I feel the newer stuff sorely lacks, for example the raid in Myth Drannor has no tie at all to the villain Droic Orgul, same with Relentless and the Relentless killer, because Dr Mordenheim has already been dealt with.
1 raid which is a 1 room boss which I am excluding is bad is Abbot, I feel his raid is different enough to merit a round of applause due to the diversity of the puzzles, and MoD is a personal favorite because of Vol but here we are.
 

Underflow

Know-Nothing Know-It-All
Instakills for failing dps checks or some other mundane check.
so like the final stretch of Fire over Morgrave?

I don't remember if the Vrocks can be IKed, but honestly, a lot of the mechanics in that raid are quite interesting.
 

PaleFox

Well-known member
I do think that Skeletons in the closet is very close to "the perfect" raid, well for me it is at least.
3 phases that need some cooperation and navigation, cool story attached and super nice loot.
All downsides are mostly in phase 3, and to take it from a drag to a star:
- Just one line per ghost instead of what we now have.
- Skull spawns doing some percentage of damage instead of what we have now.
- Jump skulls being a tad bigger and closer to each other, prob needs one more skull per route.
 

Bjond

Well-known member
so like the final stretch of Fire over Morgrave?

I don't remember if the Vrocks can be IKed, but honestly, a lot of the mechanics in that raid are quite interesting.
Vrocks have DW, but the Dretches can be IK'd. My monk regularly taps them with dim-mak.

FOM has one feature I don't like: new mechs at higher levels. I like being able to train a raid on ALL the mechs at low difficulties. That way, when you crank it up, they know what to do. Too often, when new mechs are introduced later, the raid not only can't handle it, but doesn't want to learn to handle it because "well, we already learned it, dun want to learn it again/differently".

For instance, jumps and dretch rings do nothing sub-elite, which ingrains some bad habits that kill people when upping difficulty. Would be nice if those features still had effects worthy of being avoided; eg. add a KD to his landing or a short paralyze to the dretch rings. Enough that people learn to deal with them instead of ignoring them completely on hard.
 

Syrrah

Well-known member
The next raid pits us against the Demogorgon, who needs to be killed by Demon Lords and not players, so we already know there will be a puzzle aspect to it:

I assume the raid will start with a violent trek through caves with the intention to summon one or more Demon Lords, then lure them to Demogorgon (likely by means of forced party splitting) and finally a stage where we need to fend of trash from the Demon Lords while they fight Demogorgon. Likely with a short phase at the end were we need to kill the surviving Demon Lords outselves.

If done right, it avoids the while "kill a guy with 60 billion HP" trope, which is a very good thing.
It can be done with light puzzle and party-splitting elements, which are also a good thing.
Because we're not supposed to fight the boss ourselves, it also opens unique possibilities to make casters relevant and makes the raid less reliant on a tank.

I'm carefully optimistic.
 

The_Apocalypse

The Chosen One
As to mechanics, I've always been a fan of collapsing floors, secret doors, overlapping floors, runes with ability checks (yes, The Chamber of Raiyum is one of my favorite quests). I also like the whole "Boss spawns in random location" thing.
 

Willsave20

Indie Game Developer
A lot of discussion around raids and I'm curious what people would want to see?
I think that Strahd is by far the best raid in the game. There are opportunities for every role in a group to shine. Most of the new modern raids are just meatsacks of HP with different phases that you deal damage to. Project Nemesis is also a cool raid in that it has a mechanic other than just beating down high HP mobs. Having to not only power, move, and activate a laser but also position mobs in the right place to be alt-f4'd is a fun mechanic. It'd be interesting to see more of those puzzle/strategy mechanics put back into raids
 

Phaedra

Well-known member
I think that Strahd is by far the best raid in the game. There are opportunities for every role in a group to shine. Most of the new modern raids are just meatsacks of HP with different phases that you deal damage to. Project Nemesis is also a cool raid in that it has a mechanic other than just beating down high HP mobs. Having to not only power, move, and activate a laser but also position mobs in the right place to be alt-f4'd is a fun mechanic. It'd be interesting to see more of those puzzle/strategy mechanics put back into raids
Let' run Titan at level while you tell me all about how fun precisely positioning a mob is in DDO.
 

Bjond

Well-known member
Take all the rare items from elsewhere in the game and put them in breakables.
LOL -- now that would be oh so very "DDO".

As a newbie grouping for the first time I noticed everyone doing this one really weird thing: breaking things all over.

I didn't understand, I just thought "WOW, these people sure are angry."
 

Hobgoblin

Less Nerfy Nerfy more fixy fixy
the main thing i want is choices.

ie like in fom - you can if you want just bum rush the boss and ignore trash - or you can have trash killers that kill the vrocks.

my idea would be something like mirror - where the boss flips a switch and you can ignore it and mobs pile on through or can have someone flip it back to shut the door. either way works but its up to the party of how to do it
 

The_Apocalypse

The Chosen One
As a newbie grouping for the first time I noticed everyone doing this one really weird thing: breaking things all over.

I didn't understand, I just thought "WOW, these people sure are angry."
Breakables sometimes drop nice loot. I've seen large bags and collapsed portable holes come out of barrels.
 
Top