Lamannia U76 - Balance Pass

Status
Not open for further replies.

Raedier

The Druid
My biggest peeve about THF is the missing off-hand stats:
  • doesn't have 2x effects (LGS/etc)
  • doesn't have 4x aug slots
  • doesn't count as 2x items for set bonuses
If it could match the DPS of a TWF melee today, I still would not use it because of the above issues. If those were fixed, I'd consider using it even if the sustained was a bit lower because the burst is a bit higher.

To be fair.... BiS gear doesnt use set bonuses these days and the augment slots are generally used for adamantine/feareater in both weapons on TWF, SWF on the other hand gets 2 free slots ofc since they don't need DR bypass for their off hand.

I agree THF could use a buff, but it should be in the form of better active attacks, adrenaline should be a staple for THF but it's being overshadowed by QC, and it will still be even after the u76 changes.
A better Sunder animation would be awesome, this would affect Legendary rally too (they use the same animation)

Some suggestions to make melee epic strikes more epic:
- Consecration : use the Mighty slam animation to slam the ground around you for a guaranteed critical hit (in addition to it's current effects)
- Dire charge : Can't believe this bugged mess is still in the game, make it like wings and let the user charge through a whole pack stunning all of them.
- Shadowstrike : automatically attempts to assasinate the first enemy it hits, could put this in T5 since it's so lackluster.
- Driftig Lotus : Change it back to doing 3 hits.
- Adrenaline : reduce cooldown back to 8 seconds, nothing op here, just allows for smoother double charging.... that was fun.
 

Ying

5000+ hours played
Ranged in particular needs the breaks on. It's miles easier to survive (which applies to casters too).

I'd happily switch back to melee if they had a clear DPS advantage over ranged, which they currently don't, and casters, which they currently do.
What ranged build and in what context do you think is doing more damage than melee? Cause that's a pretty broad statement that doesn't match my gameplay experience. Ranged is favored in raids because of anti-melee mechanics like tail swiping or whirlwinding mobs. So if you want to shift the meta, get the devs to change those anti-melee raid mechanics. Melee remain the kings of speedrunning R10 quests.
 

Ying

5000+ hours played
Dex with Longsword/Warhammer/Battleaxe/Khopesh
That's not the buff you think it is. Strength remains the highest damage stat potential for melee. Tempest still has problems, like T5+capstone costing 44 AP. The capstone is a joke compared to what it used to be and is not appealing compared to other options. There's still very little reason for Tempest to be a melee's primary tree these days. Anyone who used to play Tempest found themselves shifting to Dragon Lord.
 

Elfishski

Well-known member
That's not the buff you think it is. Strength remains the highest damage stat potential for melee. Tempest still has problems, like T5+capstone costing 44 AP. The capstone is a joke compared to what it used to be and is not appealing compared to other options. There's still very little reason for Tempest to be a melee's primary tree these days. Anyone who used to play Tempest found themselves shifting to Dragon Lord.
Every build thread the response to every build for making it better is be Dragon Lord multiclass and use that tree - the problem here is surely Dragon Lord rather than everything else?
 

Ying

5000+ hours played
Every build thread the response to every build for making it better is be Dragon Lord multiclass and use that tree - the problem here is surely Dragon Lord rather than everything else?
Nerfing Dragon Lord won't make Tempest any more viable to play. The problem is Tempest. The capstone used to be the huge payoff making it worthwhile to stay pure Ranger but that was gutted. Ranger past level 11 doesn't really offer anything appealing for melee. Dance of Death is great for clearing R10s, and A Thousand Cuts is awesome for bursting a boss. Evasive Dance is lame when Shadowdancer gives it to you for free. Tempest's problem is it hasn't aged well. It was designed when enhancements were first introduced and has only seen nerfs. Newer enhancement trees have tackled mechanics of the game in a more optimal way than Tempest currently offers.
 

Necrodancer

Ancient beyond measure
That's not the buff you think it is. Strength remains the highest damage stat potential for melee. Tempest still has problems, like T5+capstone costing 44 AP. The capstone is a joke compared to what it used to be and is not appealing compared to other options. There's still very little reason for Tempest to be a melee's primary tree these days. Anyone who used to play Tempest found themselves shifting to Dragon Lord.

Correct.

Every build thread the response to every build for making it better is be Dragon Lord multiclass and use that tree - the problem here is surely Dragon Lord rather than everything else?

Improved correct. Do you understand now why I support a ground zero overhaul? I know it's NEVER going to happen but the balance is so over the place you cannot touch a single thing without leaving something else in the gutter and it's even worse when you release classes or universal trees so titanically overpowered that they become the golden standard and cornerstone of every build. Now to fix tempest they'll need to give them something so good even dragonlords would say "wow, that's dope". decently built Dl and inquisitives already make R10 look like a cakewalk, do I need to elaborate further on why they were mistakes?
 

Elfishski

Well-known member
Nerfing Dragon Lord won't make Tempest any more viable to play. The problem is Tempest. The capstone used to be the huge payoff making it worthwhile to stay pure Ranger but that was gutted. Ranger past level 11 doesn't really offer anything appealing for melee. Dance of Death is great for clearing R10s, and A Thousand Cuts is awesome for bursting a boss. Evasive Dance is lame when Shadowdancer gives it to you for free. Tempest's problem is it hasn't aged well. It was designed when enhancements were first introduced and has only seen nerfs. Newer enhancement trees have tackled mechanics of the game in a more optimal way than Tempest currently offers.
Well #1 "Dance of Death is great for clearing R10s, and A Thousand Cuts is awesome for bursting a boss." what more do you need? It just has less awesome sustained r10 raid boss DPS which I know is all some people care about because everything else is trivial to them, but it's not the majority of the game.

I agree though that mechanically it's awkward and clunky, and basically the entire power of tempest is in T5 and everything else is meh, which isn't fun until level 12 and the capstone doesn't deeply inspire. There was a really good suggestions thread for Tempest a little while back (https://forums.ddo.com/index.php?threads/ranger-tempest-enhancement-tree-rework.20876/ ) that definitely needed some numerical balance but the mechanical ideas for active strikethrough attacks early in the tree and other changes looked like a much more fun levelling and playing experience.

It is indeed a separate issue that Dragon Lord makes everything else look worse by comparison.
 

Teh_Troll

Master of Baiting
What ranged build and in what context do you think is doing more damage than melee? Cause that's a pretty broad statement that doesn't match my gameplay experience. Ranged is favored in raids because of anti-melee mechanics like tail swiping or whirlwinding mobs. So if you want to shift the meta, get the devs to change those anti-melee raid mechanics. Melee remain the kings of speedrunning R10 quests.
Look at the last raid . . . do you think SSG is cable of creating a raid that ISN'T full of anti-melee mechanics?
 

Teh_Troll

Master of Baiting
That's not the buff you think it is. Strength remains the highest damage stat potential for melee. Tempest still has problems, like T5+capstone costing 44 AP. The capstone is a joke compared to what it used to be and is not appealing compared to other options. There's still very little reason for Tempest to be a melee's primary tree these days. Anyone who used to play Tempest found themselves shifting to Dragon Lord.
You are a wise man.

Overall they need to buff the bejesus out of capstones, the Tempest absolutely needs it's 25% off-hand DS back.
 

Ying

5000+ hours played
Look at the last raid . . . do you think SSG is cable of creating a raid that ISN'T full of anti-melee mechanics?
I hear ya. I prefer playing melee over every other style. But I'm also tired of dying to BS anti-melee mechanics.

Well #1 "Dance of Death is great for clearing R10s, and A Thousand Cuts is awesome for bursting a boss." what more do you need?
1. Crowd control. Snare, Spike Growth and Entangle spells have always been a joke because it's impossible for Ranger to have effective DCs. Tempest isn't the right place to fix that, but Deepwood Stalker is.
2. STR or DEX Trance without having to go Horizon Walker or Dragon Lord.
3. Movement speed. Longstrider could provide inherent movespeed that stacks with Striding based on every Ranger level you have, or every Tempest/DWS core you have. Thematically, that's about as close as we're ever gonna get to favored terrain in DDO. Sprint Boost sucks because you have to take it in lieu of Haste Boost, and if you're using Sprint Boost you can't Haste Boost. Sprint Boost needs to be on a separate cooldown from DPS boosts, and be a separate enhancement from Haste Boost.
 

Elfishski

Well-known member
1. Crowd control. Snare, Spike Growth and Entangle spells have always been a joke because it's impossible for Ranger to have effective DCs. Tempest isn't the right place to fix that, but Deepwood Stalker is.
2. STR or DEX Trance without having to go Horizon Walker or Dragon Lord.
3. Movement speed. Longstrider could provide inherent movespeed that stacks with Striding based on every Ranger level you have, or every Tempest/DWS core you have. Thematically, that's about as close as we're ever gonna get to favored terrain in DDO. Sprint Boost sucks because you have to take it in lieu of Haste Boost, and if you're using Sprint Boost you can't Haste Boost. Sprint Boost needs to be on a separate cooldown from DPS boosts, and be a separate enhancement from Haste Boost.
I'm a big believer that not all classes/trees need to have everything, but yes, something to massively boost DCs of those ranger spells or even make them not have a save with a heavy investment in DWS would be really neat.

Main stat trances and haste boost both being "mandatory" such that anything without either of them feels Terrible is also a thing that should be looked at in a balance pass (which they seem to be addressing just by making both of them options for every tree they release/update but that's... a bandaid), but that's maybe a bigger balance pass next time...
 

Ying

5000+ hours played
I'm a big believer that not all classes/trees need to have everything, but yes, something to massively boost DCs of those ranger spells or even make them not have a save with a heavy investment in DWS would be really neat.
Lack of useful spells is one of the core issues with Ranger. There are so many spells that quickly become obsolete, and it's disappointing they've never been revisited. Apparently devs still have PTSD from Alchemist spell implementation. Without functional and desirable spells, you might as well go Barbarian.

Main stat trances and haste boost both being "mandatory" such that anything without either of them feels Terrible is also a thing that should be looked at in a balance pass
Personally, I think Trances are the dumbest mechanic in the game. I'm not advocating for their removal, but I wouldn't miss them if they got removed after refactoring the DC system. But I also have no expectation the DC system will ever get an overhaul. It's super lame that the majority first life builds cannot get functional DCs.
 

zandoe

Well-known member
If couple of builds are always OP the solution is not to nerf those it is to make all other builds atleast somewhat playable. It is of course not a easy task so this balance pass is a good try, starting point, at the right direction.
 

Teh_Troll

Master of Baiting
I get what you're saying, but the floor needs to improve for lots of builds. I pugged R1 Relentless the other day, an agonizing 37 min completion. There were at least five players in that raid that had no clue how to do damage.
I've wondered what use 10,000 character combinations is when all but 12 of them are crap.

Much of that floor is knowledge.

That's the nature of DDO and some of it is player skill. I can solo some R7s on my girlfriend's toon, she can't.
 

Ying

5000+ hours played
I've wondered what use 10,000 character combinations is when all but 12 of them are crap.

Much of that floor is knowledge.

That's the nature of DDO and some of it is player skill. I can solo some R7s on my girlfriend's toon, she can't.
You aren't wrong. DDO also has no feedback mechanisms like a threat or damage meter, so inexperienced players have no idea their flavor build is not contributing in a meaningful way. And raid leaders have no way to know how effective an unknown player is. Then players get bent out of shape that we're elitest because we don't play with new players. It's like the only winning move is not to play.
 

LetsGetDangerous

Well-known member
Lack of useful spells is one of the core issues with Ranger. There are so many spells that quickly become obsolete, and it's disappointing they've never been revisited. Apparently devs still have PTSD from Alchemist spell implementation. Without functional and desirable spells, you might as well go Barbarian.


Personally, I think Trances are the dumbest mechanic in the game. I'm not advocating for their removal, but I wouldn't miss them if they got removed after refactoring the DC system. But I also have no expectation the DC system will ever get an overhaul. It's super lame that the majority first life builds cannot get functional DCs.
I feel the problem with DCs is that either they are too low to make everything trivial or too high to make those abilities useless. It is all or nothing.

DC casting should allow for failed checks to be rewarded by lowering the saves. Of course some effects (i.e death) should have this nerfed a bit. That way DC casters/ability users can be relevant even if a few initial attempts are not successful.
 

Elfishski

Well-known member
You aren't wrong. DDO also has no feedback mechanisms like a threat or damage meter, so inexperienced players have no idea their flavor build is not contributing in a meaningful way. And raid leaders have no way to know how effective an unknown player is. Then players get bent out of shape that we're elitest because we don't play with new players. It's like the only winning move is not to play.
The literal 100-1000x difference in DPS and survivability between the best and worst builds isn't great for grouping, but fixing it is way beyond a modest balance pass.

It isn't necessarily that people can't make a good DPS character, it's that it's a lot of hassle that you don't want to bother with on an alt, or a character that you're going to TR again shortly after doing a few raids. Nobody needs to feel bad about that.
- Raid leaders can communicate in the LFM if they want people who can do some heavy lifting for a challenging difficulty or they're all covered and taking any warm body for company. Same as running R10s. Rather than not playing there's no shame in running a lower difficulty instead if the group isn't up to it.
 

Jack Jarvis Esquire

Well-known member
What ranged build and in what context do you think is doing more damage than melee? Cause that's a pretty broad statement that doesn't match my gameplay experience. Ranged is favored in raids because of anti-melee mechanics like tail swiping or whirlwinding mobs. So if you want to shift the meta, get the devs to change those anti-melee raid mechanics. Melee remain the kings of speedrunning R10 quests.

First off, you're right to criticise the general nature of my post, that's fair comment. There really isn't the time or the space or the attention span on my part to go into every detail here. It's a general observation based on my play experience over several months (as ranged), accepted.

That said, to clarify, I'm not saying ranged does more damage than melee IME, far from it. I'm saying I've not seen a significant drop off in damage in the ranged builds I've played (initially inq for a short while now shuri thrower) compared to the many melee builds I've played over the years, latest being barbs of different hues. So I'm saying I've found there isn't much appreciable difference between ranged and melee IME.

There is however a significant improvement in survivability, and so that equation heavily favours ranged as things stand.

Context is at cap high R group play and mainly LH raids. The odd low R solo stuff too I guess, but that's very infrequent. So not high R raids or solo, but I'd argue that's not very representative of general ( there's that word again!) play anyway. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top