Any progress on this? I am interested in PVP, but I don't really like the rule restrictions, especially the level stuff.
I never really liked 'balance' in anything, I always think should be balanced by being unbalanced, because that's closer to real life, e.g. a tiger will maul your ass, why should you have 50/50 chance against a tiger? Instead make a weapon so your chances against tiger become 99/1.
In DDO's case, you can just use jeweled cloak or others to go against mages. The whole point is to figure out a strategy against the dominating one (wizards) as that's typically more fun I feel.