A few thoughts after playing around and tinkering with things:
ENHANCEMENT SPLIT:
For enhancements, you'll typically want 41 in one tree with 31 in a secondary one. Your capstone/41 point tree is
probably the one you'll want to go tier 5 in, though strictly speaking that's not set in stone. You
can pick up tier 5 in one tree and still spend 41 points in another...but without grabbing tier 5s in that tree you often have to spend points on junk just to unlock the capstone. And with plenty of goodies in universal trees, going 38 or 39 points in 1 tree and 41 in another means you're probably missing out on something tasty (haste boost or quick strike, in particular).
So you sort of have 6 choices:
A. 41 KOTC 31 Vanguard
B. 41 KOTC 31 Sacred Defender
C. 41 Vanguard 31 KOTC
D. 41 Vanguard 31 Sacred Defender
E. 41 Sacred Defender 31 KOTC
F. 41 Sacred Defender 31 Vanguard
If going fighter variant, then just replace KOTC with Kensai, and Sacred Defender with Stalwart Defender. KOTC/kensai and VG are higher DPS trees than SD, while SD is the tanky tree. If you want "pure DPS" go A or C, but realistically you're not going to be sniffing what million crit bow users or 6 hits per animation monks are putting out anyway.
You're using a shield bro. We can all see it. You're not fooling anyone.
So I think just from a flavor or "in the spirit of the build" perspective, there are sort of two questions:
1. KOTC or Vanguard?
2. SD vs whatever you picked, which gets 41 and which gets 31?
KOTC has a ton of quality of life stuff, like higher amp, greater restos, immunity to neg levels, lots of cleaves, free knight's training, faster regening smites, good aligned DR bypass...and if you are fighting undead or fiends then the 75 melee power from ascendency makes it higher damage than vanguard.
Vanguard gets better CC, marginally higher AC, situationally higher defenses via battle guard, higher attack speeds and a lot more shield smacks, though with the arbitrary 1s cooldown going above ~60-70% has very diminishing returns.
As for 41 or 31 SD, I think if you're going with 41 SD you're sort of just declaring that you're a full-on tank, which is something else entirely.
So it's really down to B. 41 KOTC 31 Sacred Defender or D. 41 Vanguard 31 Sacred Defender
In terms of raw DPS vanguard is slightly ahead from my testing but there are a lot of perks KOTC brings, and there are an
awful lot of undead or fiends at endgame where KOTC pulls ahead.
However, there are some issues.
1. If you don't invest in KOTC at all, no imbue for you, but considering it's the first core this isn't a huge deal, at least from an action points perspective (more on that below, though).
2. Assuming you are spending 41+31 points, you have 8 points left over, and possibly 3 more from universal tomes. You can get harper quick strike (7 points) OR haste boost (7 points). But...you can't get both. Personally I went with quick strike as an almost permanent 25% doublestrike is kinda nuts, but not having a haste boost does sting a bit.
3. Grabbing a trance gets tricky for D (and F). You can grab an int trance in Harper I guess. Doesn't give attack but it's something.
4. You
could maybe go 41 vanguard/21SD/7 KOTC (trance/imbue)/7 vistani (haste boost)/7 harper (quick strike) though there's a big difference between 21 and 31 in SD, the 5th core alone is great and so is tier 4. Or, 41 SD/21 vanguard/7/7/7 but that's an odd mix of tanky then thinly spreading points to get DPS.
EPIC DESTINIES:
With enhancements, you have a main tree, a secondary tree and then a smattering of points to grab what you like. With EDs, you get 3 trees and with the level cap being 36 you can fill most of them out almost entirely.
Viable Trees:
Unyielding Sentinel (mediocre epic strikes, good mantle, great epic moment, very good tier 5s...renewal, more/better/AOE Lay on Hands, better defenses and doublestrike...hard to imagine not using this for this type of build and it's a strong candidate for tier 5)
Fury of the Wild (good epic strikes [still], laughable mantle, OK epic moment, mediocre tier 5s for this build...but primal heals, lots of attack and doublestrike)
Divine Crusader (trash epic strike, OK mantle, situational epic moment, decent tier 5s...gets bastard sword as a favored weapon, some other goodies, 75% fort for relentless, some saves you don't need, etc. How Dare You Strike Me nerf was really totally unneeded and shows how utterly out of touch the devs are with this type of build, but that's a thread for another day.)
Exalted Angel (OK epic strike, good mantle, trash epic moment, bad tier 5s...shout out to Grunndi for this one, the mantle plus renewal makes a lot of sense, also are enough defensive options that you don't feel like you're wasting a tree, plus mass cure mod is pretty amazing.)
Legendary Dreadnought (gross epic strike, OK mantle, excellent epic moment, good tier 5s...nice smattering of other abilities as well...nice for fighter kensai option due to synergy with action boosts.)
US is my pick for tier 5, but LD or DC are also viable. Do not go tier 5 FotW or EA!
2nd tree, Fury is still probably the best epic strike tree, and brings enough to the table otherwise as well.
3rd tree is sort of where you flavor the dish to taste, DC is OK even with nerfs, EA gives a lot of survivability, LD good DPS.
US/FotW/DC is where I am currently.
LD/US/Fotw also sounds good especially with the epic moment. If you are going to go LD, you're probably best off going all the way to T5.
US/FotW/EA for the self/party heals, especially for dwarves.
DC/US/FotW for going all in on shield/favored weapon stuff (less useful for fighters).
They really need to open up the option to take a 4th tree. You can take 6 enhancement trees and a racial one too, at this point it just feels restrictive only allowing 3 destinies.
Note 1: If you are using a bastard sword, you are
very much coerced into DC unless you're PDK, and if you're PDK you'd have to use a lesser heart to get rid of that fighter level because paladin capstones are pretty strong. Or just go fighter and don't worry about favored weapons at all. If you're Duergar, I'd imagine you'd just use an axe. Ever seen a dwarf with a bastard sword? Exactly. Seems wrong even picturing it. This is especially true if you are KOTC because a lot of the benefits involve using a favored weapon. Even for vanguard though, the
KOTC imbue won't work with a non-favored weapon...and that's a good chunk of damage. You also can't really rely on favored weapon curse, because it's pretty rare and you'll probably have multiple weapons (DPS, CC, DR breaker)
Note 2: For Dwarf/Duergar,
you need 11 points in the racial tree till you unlock Dwarven Axes as a favored weapon! That means that for first lifers you will NEED a +3 racial tome because 41+31+11=83 points. You also won't be able to get harper 25% doublestrike or haste boost. It's silly (your God doesn't recognize that weapon in your hand till you'd been around the block, I guess?) but hey, they designed the tree, and doubled down with Duergar. Just be aware of it.
WEAPONRY:
With the updates to other weapons, and the feat tax for bastard sword for anyone not running near racial completionist Aasimar, Dwarven Waraxe, Warhammer and Morningstar are quite attractive options. Bastard sword
does have Ignition which is hard to beat in terms of crowd control, but as Grunndi mentioned Audion with Salt is about as good. On the other hand, legendary Thirteen is one of only two metalline/aligned universal DR breakers that is level 30+ (other is a rare dagger,
Legendary Poniard of Pain) so especially if leaning away from KOTC and it's automatic good aligned weaponry, bastard swords are still very much viable. With less QC dot damage, you don't want to not be breaking DR especially if raid tanking.
The Butcher's Mouth from the new raid is quite good.
Echo of Heartcleaver too.
Pestle, the Crucible of Bones and
Demise, the Beginning of the Fall have held up pretty well also.
ARMORY:
Large shields are IN, baby! Tower shields cap you at ~2-6% dodge. With KOTC, can get 13% dodge in heavy with a large, or 16% in vanguard. Better than a tower shield even with 5% less HP, and saves most people a feat. Medium armor I'm less sold on, can get to 20% dodge but probably not a huge difference compared to heavy.
A note on AC: at the moment, it's essentially impossible for this kind of build (or any but a pure tank, really) to hit any kind of AC that substantially mitigates damage at endgame, especially the last couple of expansions and after the past life changes. You'll notice 300 AC is better than 100 but not by a huge amount. I've maintained
some investment in AC (15% set augs, hardened in T4 US, reaper armor boost, etc) but I strongly advise against dumping a whole bunch of investment into it in terms of filigrees or augments or whatever else. It's just a stupidly broken system that has gotten out of their control (by their own design) that they need to fix.
Get your PRR/MRR/temp HP/absorbs/dodge as high as you can, toss in deflect arrows/spell absorb for good measure, then CC stuff and kill it before it kills you.
Of course, these can't
all be "Mechgraber's Endgame Paladin". I'm just laying out some options and possibilities.
Switched from KOTC version and right now I'm running the 41 Vanguard/31 SD and 29 Fury/38 US/24 DC. Tanked r10 baba and r5 LVOD earlier with good healing and self healed some lower skull raids, so it's holding up well. Have seen 570 PRR/407 MRR fully buffed and battle guarded up, though self buffed and standing around in reaper is about 100 fewer each. HP just shy of 7k which is plenty. Amp down from the 468% of KOTC, but 408% still has healers happy. Can still solo plenty of r10s, though latest stuff might be trickier than before, which I'm totally OK with, r10s shouldn't be easy to solo!
Doublestrike is a fairly sustained 174% (quick strike up ~80% of the time, and 13 reaper boosts per shrine) and from what I can tell it's around 40k or so DPS-certainly nothing close to top DPS builds but for a sturdy hybrid beefcake not too bad.