Official Legal Complaint: Breach of EU Consumer Protection Laws and Unfair Pricing

Vlander

Well Abused Member
On point 1:
Article 4(1)(b)
Pursuant to this provision, the ban on applying different conditions of sale of electronically supplied services does not apply if the main feature of the services is the provision of access to and use of copyright-protected works, including selling them in an intangible form.

Meaning they can legally sell the game for a different price or different currency based on your country of residence. However, they cannot block you from purchasing it from another country for a cheaper price, such as with the use of a VPN or even accessing a country specific website.

On point 2:
You are 100% correct and that is a violation of EU law. The VAT and all other taxes are required to be presented in the price the very first time the price is shown.
The store has a way to select regions for payment. I'm sure if he selected the correct region the prices would change accordingly.
 

KylerrTheMajty

Well-known member
The store has a way to select regions for payment. I'm sure if he selected the correct region the prices would change accordingly.
no , store have way to select currencies but when you go farther it will lock on currenicies that ssg want your region to pay
 

The Narc2

Well-known member
I wrote to them regarding previous expansions and they switched the currency to euros for me, but unfortunately, this year they are unwilling to help. When I started asking why there hadn't been an issue in previous years (i bought Vecna, Myth Drannor and Lamordia this way) but there was one now, I received this reply:


Greetings,

Thank you for the inquiry. As previously stated on your prior ticket, our system required Poland to utilize USD as a payment currency. There is no mitigating this. Customer Support is not able to assist in bypassing this for you.

The creation of multiple tickets regarding the same issue is considered malicious abuse of support covered by DDO's Code of Conduct.

Further requests regarding this issue may now go unanswered. Further warnings may lead to further actions taken against your account.

Thank you,
These are my favourite responses the ones were they threaten to punish you for chasing a correct and appropriate result.


Understand OP this is common practice in all games where they try to lock you into long term investment(time or money) in a game, and is likely the reason the MMO industry is dying a slow death.

Be aware and be selective of the type of games you endorse and play moving forward.
 

Phaedra

Well-known member
Dear Support and Legal Team,
I am writing to formally lodge a legal complaint regarding the pricing structure applied to my account on the DDO Market. I am a resident of Poland, an EU member state.
Your customer service recently informed me that Poland is hardcoded to USD pricing. This practice directly violates EU Consumer Protection Laws, specifically:

  1. EU Geoblocking Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2018/302): Traders cannot block or limit access to their online interfaces based on nationality or place of residence, nor apply different conditions of payment.
  2. EU Price Indication Directive (Directive 98/6/EC & Omnibus Directive): Any price quoted to an EU consumer MUST include all applicable taxes (VAT) from the very first presentation. Charging a baseline USD price and slapping an unexpected 23% VAT at checkout is a prohibited, misleading commercial practice.
Because your system forces a USD model with added tax instead of the standard, tax-inclusive EUR model available to neighboring EU countries (like Germany), I am being forced to pay roughly $160 USD instead of €120 EUR. This is severe price discrimination based on my location within the EU internal market.
Since Daybreak Game Company is owned by Enad Global 7 AB, a company publically traded and operating within the EU (Sweden), you are fully bound by these legislations. I request that my account billing country be corrected to the EU/EUR region immediately so I can purchase the expansion at the lawful price.
If this issue is not resolved, I will be forced to escalate this matter to the European Consumer Centre (ECC-Net) and the Polish Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK) for a formal investigation into systemic EU law violations by your platform.

Sincerely,
Kyler
I don't know EU law, but I supect that a forum post doesn't count as legal notice.
Also if the EULA stands up in court, you're probably obligated to bring suit in Massachusetts.
 

droid327

Hardcore casual soloist
Will they though?
Yes they will, since it's physically based in iirc Amsterdam

That's really the only leverage the EU would have. SSG knows most Euro players would continue to play on US servers and buy stuff with USD pricing, they wouldn't lose the entire market. And there's no way SSG has the desire, or even the capability, to maintain compliance with the myriad and Byzantine rules the EU tries to enforce on online business

As usual, EU overregulations don't create the desired outcome, they just incentivize companies to go around the EU
 

Titus Ovid

Mover and Shaker
I wrote to them regarding previous expansions and they switched the currency to euros for me, but unfortunately, this year they are unwilling to help. When I started asking why there hadn't been an issue in previous years (i bought Vecna, Myth Drannor and Lamordia this way) but there was one now, I received this reply:


Greetings,

Thank you for the inquiry. As previously stated on your prior ticket, our system required Poland to utilize USD as a payment currency. There is no mitigating this. Customer Support is not able to assist in bypassing this for you.

The creation of multiple tickets regarding the same issue is considered malicious abuse of support covered by DDO's Code of Conduct.

Further requests regarding this issue may now go unanswered. Further warnings may lead to further actions taken against your account.

Thank you,

Wow classic. What a sucky response. Disgusting.
I cheer for you, Kylerr. Good luck to you.

Titus
 

Lagin

Well-known member
SSG is so worried they arent even bothering to remove OPs post.
Because here in the US the first thing a lawyer asks "have you made any social media posts threatening a law suit" is almost an automatic denial of filing the suit. This thread is the fatal blow to the OP's goal. While it is not illegal to publicly say you're going to sue, once you step into a court room then it becomes a legal issue.
 

Rusty_helmet

Teh_troll’s Fluffer
Dear Support and Legal Team,
I am writing to formally lodge a legal complaint regarding the pricing structure applied to my account on the DDO Market. I am a resident of Poland, an EU member state.
Your customer service recently informed me that Poland is hardcoded to USD pricing. This practice directly violates EU Consumer Protection Laws, specifically:

  1. EU Geoblocking Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2018/302): Traders cannot block or limit access to their online interfaces based on nationality or place of residence, nor apply different conditions of payment.
  2. EU Price Indication Directive (Directive 98/6/EC & Omnibus Directive): Any price quoted to an EU consumer MUST include all applicable taxes (VAT) from the very first presentation. Charging a baseline USD price and slapping an unexpected 23% VAT at checkout is a prohibited, misleading commercial practice.
Because your system forces a USD model with added tax instead of the standard, tax-inclusive EUR model available to neighboring EU countries (like Germany), I am being forced to pay roughly $160 USD instead of €120 EUR. This is severe price discrimination based on my location within the EU internal market.
Since Daybreak Game Company is owned by Enad Global 7 AB, a company publically traded and operating within the EU (Sweden), you are fully bound by these legislations. I request that my account billing country be corrected to the EU/EUR region immediately so I can purchase the expansion at the lawful price.
If this issue is not resolved, I will be forced to escalate this matter to the European Consumer Centre (ECC-Net) and the Polish Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK) for a formal investigation into systemic EU law violations by your platform.

Sincerely,
Kyler
This needs a laugh emoji. This is not how you file a legal complaint.

Good luck!
 

LokiFrost

The Icelandic Loki
I have this issue in Iceland with certain things. I am fortunate enough to have two residences and two sets of credit cards (US/EU).

I use a VPN to buy anything while I am living in the US (50% ISL and 50% in US).

Powodzenia. Good luck friend.
 

PaleFox

Well-known member
For my Polish Friends, please use this template (like all of you as a single case won't put you that high upon the list.)

Subject: Formal Complaint: Breach of EU Geoblocking Regulation (Regulation 2018/302) and Price Display Requirements

To whom it may concern,

I am writing to you as a consumer residing within the European Union (EU) regarding my account and billing preferences for Dungeons & Dragons Online (DDO), operated by Standing Stone Games LLC and published by Daybreak Game Company LLC.
I am currently being forced to settle my payments and view prices in a non-local currency (USD), while being denied the option to pay in Euros (EUR) or under the local terms applicable to the European Single Market.

I would like to draw your attention to EU Regulation 2018/302 (The Geoblocking Regulation). Under this binding European framework, traders targeting the EU market are strictly prohibited from discriminating against EU consumers based on their nationality, place of residence, or place of establishment regarding access to prices, sales, or payment conditions. Furthermore, EU consumer laws dictate that prices directed at EU consumers must be transparently displayed including local VAT and available in the official currency of their eurozone jurisdiction.

Given that your company actively operates infrastructure within the EU (including servers hosted in Amsterdam) and explicitly directs services to European citizens, you are legally obligated to respect EU consumer rights. Forcing EU residents to pay in USD, which introduces mandatory currency conversion fees and fluctuating exchange rates, constitutes an unlawful trade barrier and non-compliance with the European Single Market rules.

My Request:
  1. Please provide me with an option to settle my ongoing transactions, subscriptions, or point purchases in Euros (EUR) without discriminatory markups.
  2. If your billing architecture currently lacks this legally required functionality for EU citizens, I request that this ticket be escalated to your legal and compliance department.
Should this matter not be addressed or resolved within a reasonable timeframe, I will be forced to escalate this cross-border dispute. I will file an official complaint through the European Consumer Centre (ECC) network, and signal this structural violation to the European Competition and Consumer Authorities (such as the ACM in the Netherlands, UOKiK in Poland and Konsumentverket in Sweden, where your parent company Enad Global 7 AB is registered) for enforcement and market sanctions.

I look forward to your swift response and cooperation.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]
[Your DDO Account Name / Username]
[Country of residence: Poland/Etc]

You can send it to:
  • MCF Legal Technology Solutions Limited (o.v.v. GDPR & Legal Representative for Daybreak Game Company LLC)
  • Daybreak Game Company LLC (o.v.v. Legal Department / Privacy Officer)
  • Enad Global 7 AB (EG7)
You should be able to find exact addresses of these online, if not I can provide them for you.
As some one who has worked with the type of government agencies closely, they do not take these things lightly.
However, a single complaint (read: if OP is the only adventurer from Poland) is considered an outlier.

Sadly, customer support isn't the route to take nor can you (or we really) expect them to fix this issue.
It would have flatterend them if they also said something along those lines and that they would forward the complaint and request to the corresponding departments.
But I guess that at the end of their routing scheme for categorizing tickets, where all non fitting tickets land there is just a grey bin with a "unable to assist" type of message.
 
Top