Shaking up the meta...

Flatliner

New member
I hated the way it was worded in the article. It makes me feel like the game might as well start selling battle passes. "This year, bows get double shooting speed and metalline is important again!"

I am glad to hear that there are a lot of people excited for the upcoming patch. I'm just not one of them. I will be one of the people leaving after this patch hits. The game has done fine without me before, though, and I have no doubt it will continue doing fine without me again.
 

Falkor

Well-known member
The notion of 'meta' in DDO is silly. The concept of 'meta' stems from competitive gaming. There are no 'red aggro decks' in this game.

DDO isn't competitive. There is no meta. There is having fun, or not having fun, or some range in between.

There are some outlier builds that do more DPS than other builds. Pushing DPS is how some people find enjoyment in the game. That isn't meta, its just 'meta' builds favored by some people who prioritize DPS over everything else. Current top builds will remain near the top, though perhaps one or two will eek out an edge.

For people who look for other ways to find enjoyment in this game, there are builds that suit them. Their 'meta' won't change. Or maybe it will, b/c some stuff will be easier thru heroics, cantrips are cool, and gaming with friends means more to them than chasing #s.

The changes don't bother me one way or another. Most builds will remain in the realm of 'more than good enough'.
 

Sturmbb

Well-known member
I'll be honest, i have mixed opinions on this balance pass. The one thing that i am quite amazed at, is that one of the strongest builds in the game is actually getting buffed and made stronger.

The biggest people i feel sorry for are the players who's build have been nerfed quite heavily and the builds they were using were not even in the top builds of the game.

I am often curious how they go about testing builds and working out what needs to be nerfed and buffed.
 

Kyrr

Well-known member
The notion of 'meta' in DDO is silly. The concept of 'meta' stems from competitive gaming. There are no 'red aggro decks' in this game.

DDO isn't competitive. There is no meta. There is having fun, or not having fun, or some range in between.

There are some outlier builds that do more DPS than other builds. Pushing DPS is how some people find enjoyment in the game. That isn't meta, its just 'meta' builds favored by some people who prioritize DPS over everything else. Current top builds will remain near the top, though perhaps one or two will eek out an edge.

For people who look for other ways to find enjoyment in this game, there are builds that suit them. Their 'meta' won't change. Or maybe it will, b/c some stuff will be easier thru heroics, cantrips are cool, and gaming with friends means more to them than chasing #s.

The changes don't bother me one way or another. Most builds will remain in the realm of 'more than good enough'.
Actually, meta isn't solely just for competitive gaming. It used to describe the best scenario or strategy. In this case, it refers to builds or play styles, the ones that define questing, raiding or of the otherwise.

Ranged was meta, now it's probably Melee.

Crossbows, Repeaters and Shurikens were meta because they provided the most damage per second reliably. Now it will probably be a monk meta.
 

Bjond

Well-known member
Crossbows, Repeaters and Shurikens were meta because they provided the most damage per second reliably.
I'm actually hoping Shuriken and Throwing end up roughly equal and at least close to top (if not actually top), because I'd love to swap out of Shuriken and over to Simple. Shuriken builds are much too locked-in on EDs for my taste due to not generating ki on shuriken hits.

'Course, from what I've seen so far, the only simple that might compete is T.Axe, which is hard-locked to Duegar and so far looks like it requires Alchemist as a base -- a class I really hate.

We'll see how it all turns out when it hits live.
 

axemania

Well-known member
I think the problem is that the existing meta is way too funneled. There are a handful of specific builds that are dramatically overperforming the baseline average, and the goal seems to be to make the builds that are way above the average weaker by targeting specific abilities (NHB/EF being the primary target for ranged, for example) while overall trying to buff *most* builds that aren't in a good spot (most other ranged builds and casters). Whether the pass actually accomplishes that is unclear- I didn't have a chance to test on Lama this time around but from what I'm seeing it looks like it *mostly* does at least move in that direction except maybe the B/P/S DR change.

There are some specific nerfs that will impact top performing builds, but I'm also taking some of the panic as fixated on a single thing, instead of looking holistically- for example, some spells will be weaker after the update but most are going to be at least as useful if not more with the MCL change and cantrips should in theory make SP management easier. There are some direct nerfs to builds that probably don't need it- the spell crit typing change being one that will hurt but only if you're very developed on gear and playing at cap.

Overall, though, I think the idea is more to diversify the builds than to force people to farm new gear. Unless you actively discard any gear you pull that doesn't fit your immediate needs, you probably already have the gear to use if you've been farming gear for your current playstyle (unless you've been, say, throwing out all bows or something) but the established meta builds will no longer be. But it's already looking like some DoT casting builds and non-NHB/EF/shuri ranged builds may become a lot more competitive, which should enable more options for people to build. Cantrips will probably put to bed the rest that the best way to level a caster from 1>3 is to use a greatsword (and Master's Touch if you can switch it out easily) and make some more SP intensive playstyles more feasible without spending a fortune on SP pots. Alchemist is probably a massive winner here too, with much better support for both their thrown weapon builds and cantrips making their caster builds less miserable to play and relieving their SP management issues... though with my memory of alchemist I think they'll still be pretty mediocre to play compared to other casters.

However, it shows that some of the changes are pretty direct responses to ongoing problems with the meta where some builds are just fundamentally struggling to compete. Overall, I think it's generally more healthy for DDO if a broad variety of builds can be "good" (in a meta sense). There are some specific changes that I think are bad ideas but I've already ranted about them at length elsewhere, so I'll spare the rambling about it here, but there are plenty of builds that should at least be more interesting to play. I'll give the update the benefit of the doubt and see if there are builds I found less than totally fun in the past that will become more interesting with the new update, and if so, I'd count that a win. Sure, some end game/meta builds will feel some pain but I'm much more excited for the heroic implications for playing alts or running racial lives, even if my inquisitive alts might feel a pinch (oh no, anyway...)
I do like the cantrip change because it will make SP management much easier, give CC casters something to do in between castings of evards/ottos/mass hold, and make those first couple levels less of an actively miserable slog as a caster build (though I still think it'll be a pain to solo the first couple levels as a divine caster, the problem is less "access to a basic zap" and more that your class as a whole takes a while to come online compared to melees getting good damage and HP at those early levels).

Still gonna TR out of this alchemist life ASAP and not go back to the class for a while. I'm only level 10 and i'm not really enjoying it. Though it'll probably get better once I get into groups, if I'm ever on at the right time for people on Cormyr's levelling groups.

Excited for the ranged updates personally. Bow ranger has been objectively inferior to artificer for a while and that really frustrates me as a bow ranger fan who's spent a lot of time building towards being a bow ranger.
 

SquireZed

Well-known member
Still gonna TR out of this alchemist life ASAP and not go back to the class for a while. I'm only level 10 and i'm not really enjoying it. Though it'll probably get better once I get into groups, if I'm ever on at the right time for people on Cormyr's levelling groups.
I actually think Alchemist is going to see the biggest buff from cantrips/the caster pass. Alchemist, from what I remember, was pure misery because of SP management, access to weak weapon trees, terrible spell MCLs (which is also getting buffed, which will be very nice for low level with the caster level bonus from Bombardier), and a rather cluttered spell list that required you to spend most of your preps on damage spells (the ones that are now becoming cantrips being a prime example). I don't know if it will be good, but it's going to be a lot less bad.

I am interested in the bow buffs, too, though I think I'm going to TR into a caster on my main to try out cantrips, just need to decide which one.
 

Sturmbb

Well-known member
I actually think Alchemist is going to see the biggest buff from cantrips/the caster pass. Alchemist, from what I remember, was pure misery because of SP management, access to weak weapon trees, terrible spell MCLs (which is also getting buffed, which will be very nice for low level with the caster level bonus from Bombardier), and a rather cluttered spell list that required you to spend most of your preps on damage spells (the ones that are now becoming cantrips being a prime example). I don't know if it will be good, but it's going to be a lot less bad.

I am interested in the bow buffs, too, though I think I'm going to TR into a caster on my main to try out cantrips, just need to decide which one.
The biggest problem i had with alchemiest was that about 30% of my vials wouldnt hit. whether that is healing or damage dealing. They'd either hit the dungeon ceiling or just not land at all. The casting animation also felt slow and cumbersome.

If i was going to play alchemist again, i would prolly play as a melee and just use the casting for buffs and take extended.

Its a shame, as i had really high hopes for this class, but i just couldnt work past the horrible casting mechanics :(
 

Buddha5440

"There are some who call me...Tim"
There is no such thing as balance. Where something may be balanced at one difficulty, it will be weak/broken/OP in others.
Agreed...

It seems like a lot of people seem to think "balance" is the same as equality. Balance in an RPG is what requires you to have different builds in a party. Some that are superior in some things while lacking in others. Having things like "second wind" on a fighter which can heal for as much as "lay on hands" which has been a staple since Paladins came into existence, is not "balance"...It's an easy button.
 

Coffey

Well-known member
The biggest problem i had with alchemiest was that about 30% of my vials wouldnt hit. whether that is healing or damage dealing. They'd either hit the dungeon ceiling or just not land at all. The casting animation also felt slow and cumbersome.

If i was going to play alchemist again, i would prolly play as a melee and just use the casting for buffs and take extended.

Its a shame, as i had really high hopes for this class, but i just couldnt work past the horrible casting mechanics :(
The same disappointment for me with the dark hunters curative admixtures.
 

Blaster

Well-known member
I wouldn't say it's so much "shaking up" or "re-balancing" as opposed to "homogenizing" the game.

I could go on and on about how this dev team doesn't work with surgical precision or with elegance, but rather with blunt force and gracelessness.

Either way I make adjustments and move on.
 
heh... as a gaijansan u get used too livng outsde the metas. meta shak up? more like wake up. i welcom th chalnege these changes bring. u wnt see me criieng on forums. ill be too buzy lootnig and killind demons and kajuis *** the best of them. c u in reper 4 >:D
 

torkz

Well-known member
There is no such thing as balance. Where something may be balanced at one difficulty, it will be weak/broken/OP in others.
Lazy thinking here. While perfect balance may not be possible across all difficulties, SSG could do a lot better than they have with this update.

There is no reason why caster DPS needs to be so atrociously bad compared to top builds. There are plenty of knobs they could turn if they wanted to do it. And if they overshot the mark, they could turn the knob a little in the other direction.

For example, add 3% universal spell crit damage to each caster epic destiny core (non-stacking across destinies). That would add about 12% to all end game caster DPS. Too much? Dial it back to 2% per core, and see how that goes.

I'm an engineer, not a coder, but it doesn't seem like that something like that would be hard to put in or hard to tweak from update to update.
 

torkz

Well-known member
The notion of 'meta' in DDO is silly. The concept of 'meta' stems from competitive gaming. There are no 'red aggro decks' in this game.

DDO isn't competitive. There is no meta. There is having fun, or not having fun, or some range in between.

There are some outlier builds that do more DPS than other builds. Pushing DPS is how some people find enjoyment in the game. That isn't meta, its just 'meta' builds favored by some people who prioritize DPS over everything else. Current top builds will remain near the top, though perhaps one or two will eek out an edge.

For people who look for other ways to find enjoyment in this game, there are builds that suit them. Their 'meta' won't change. Or maybe it will, b/c some stuff will be easier thru heroics, cantrips are cool, and gaming with friends means more to them than chasing #s.

The changes don't bother me one way or another. Most builds will remain in the realm of 'more than good enough'.
I suspect you mostly play solo, which is fine, but it might make you unable to see why having many styles do comparable DPS is important.

You say that the game is not competitive, which is not strictly true. We all compete against the environment. Some of us play in groups and want to push the difficulty levels. If I prefer to play caster and my friends prefer martial DPS, the maximum difficulty is different for us. My build tops out at a lower level than theirs.

You might argue that I should just be carried by them...but that's no fun for me. Or they should go on a difficulty my build can do effectively...but that's no fun for them. Or that we should play separately...but that's no fun for any of us if the point is to play together.

Or maybe I should just play a build I don't enjoy, but again, that's no fun...or they should play builds they don't enjoy...

You get the point.

Bottom line, the game is better if the disparities are not so pronounced.
 

Sarlona Raiding

Well-known member
My concern is the timing.

If they want to shock the system each year it should be before the xpac instead of after. It's terrible to farm gear and then your build destroyed due to a meta shuffle.

Also I can see where this leads to people delaying buying the xpac.

So the timing will be

1) Racial TRS for those participating in the treadmill
2) New Xpac and gear
3) New raid
4) Meta shakeup forcing us to change at least some builds

There are things I get way more excited about than this, like almost anything. If people are on the fence about paying cash or using points for the new xpac - I can see where they would just wait until the dust settles and use ddo points instead of opening their wallet. I could be wrong of course.
 
My concern is the timing.

If they want to shock the system each year it should be before the xpac instead of after. It's terrible to farm gear and then your build destroyed due to a meta shuffle.

Also I can see where this leads to people delaying buying the xpac.

So the timing will be

1) Racial TRS for those participating in the treadmill
2) New Xpac and gear
3) New raid
4) Meta shakeup forcing us to change at least some builds

There are things I get way more excited about than this, like almost anything. If people are on the fence about paying cash or using points for the new xpac - I can see where they would just wait until the dust settles and use ddo points instead of opening their wallet. I could be wrong of course.
i argee. sSG should rlly consult us bforee mking such big chnges.
 

Willow

Well-known member
I don't mind the shuffle/mixing things up from time to time but having to pay to pull augments and stuff to regear is going to get old quick. The way things are now it seems like that is the reason they are doing it, for the $$$$$$$. We should be able to swap that stuff around for free.
 

axemania

Well-known member
I actually think Alchemist is going to see the biggest buff from cantrips/the caster pass. Alchemist, from what I remember, was pure misery because of SP management, access to weak weapon trees, terrible spell MCLs (which is also getting buffed, which will be very nice for low level with the caster level bonus from Bombardier), and a rather cluttered spell list that required you to spend most of your preps on damage spells (the ones that are now becoming cantrips being a prime example). I don't know if it will be good, but it's going to be a lot less bad.

I am interested in the bow buffs, too, though I think I'm going to TR into a caster on my main to try out cantrips, just need to decide which one.
My issue is mostly flimsiness personally--but then I am levelling by soloing R1s. Flimsiness and limited access to AOE SLAs (as opposed to blightcaster which at level 10 was rofl faceroll city).
 

SquireZed

Well-known member
My issue is mostly flimsiness personally--but then I am levelling by soloing R1s. Flimsiness and limited access to AOE SLAs (as opposed to blightcaster which at level 10 was rofl faceroll city).
I think the single target SLAs are going to switch to cones in the update, so that should help with AoE relief. Flimsiness will probably get worse in heroics with the martial EPL changes, though.
 
Top