Uh oh. Someone's elitism is leaking again.
He makes a valid point.
R10 is NOT designed for someone who is a first lifer. There are some classes that may get away with doing R10 and people who are exceptional players.
I joined High Lords of Malkier Voodu's guild on Sarlona, many years back. I made a first life character, Iconic PDK 3 figther 17 FVS Healer.
My first life I was healing their raids, and then doing R8, and R10 quests.
Healers can be an exception if you are good at not getting hit, moving around, looking and avoiding, and healing.
Even as a first lifer, and being an experience player from this game and many other MMO's, R10 is still a place I shouldnt had been but I was grouped with people who knew in advance the condition of my character.
So is it really fair to the rest of the party, if you cant do your part? Like the OP said, sure those who are powerful can manage to carry those people who lack past lives and gear. But is it really fair?
People who consistently do R10 are not great in number. Some may say it as Elitism, but it can go both ways. I wouldnt even want to impose on people if I knew I couldnt do my fair share.. in anything , a game or real life.
Maybe the person joining didnt know, and the most diplomatic thing to do is for the leader of the group to talk with that person AFTER the run is over and say, hey look, I enjoyed having the opportunity to play with you, but we are a group of people who move fast through R10 content, and we can do that because we have the gear and past lives to allow us to do that.
Explain to the person how being geared and past lives contribute greatly to the success of R10s.
Maybe even offer to help with level some of their lives, or run lower reapers on some alt toon you may have.
We all play to have fun, if its not fun, then we are not going to play.