Mechgraber
Well-known member
The d20 system is great, and brings a ton of value to the game. It's iconic and has held up fairly well.
But when people started hitting 100AC, then 200AC, now 1000AC+, it became increasingly obvious that the small 1-20 window just wasn't going to hold up. To-hit and AC had to be reworked so that there was a broader range of what was viable, and you didn't have to hit specific numbers for specific content. The concept of having 80AC=completely murdered and 99AC=nearly invulnerable was a time bomb with increased power creep. At a certain point, the math just didn't math.
Saving throws, in many ways, have now gotten there. Trickster builds can hit 200+ DCs, dragonlord first life builds can hit 140+ DCs fairly easily...but traditional first life casters often struggle to get 80-90 DCs. Yes, I know they can get more, but if you only have a few filigree slots and aren't min-maxed, a lot of casual players hitting level 34 for the first time will be in that 80-90 DC range, and they probably have exactly a 5% success rate in the latest content...even on elite or r1. That feels bad, nevermind going into r7-10 and having your damage arbitrarily be lower than other classes.
To be clear, I don't know the best way to implement this, and there are clearly some massive downfalls to making saves and checks work the same as armor class across the board. The no-fail intimi tank would feel completely different with 90% success rate, let alone 70-80%. Trapping might also be a bit of a cluster. It also feels a bit punitive to the uber-completionist-reaper-geared-best-curse builds because now 1 extra DC doesn't really feel like all that much. In general, players failing saves feels a lot worse than monsters succeeding, so it's possible that this system might only have to work for enemy checks, not players. Players can still enjoy no-fail (or 95% of the time, at least) saves and checks while monsters get a new scaling similar to how AC works.
Regardless, it's very clear that things can't continue on the way they are. Some people are going to be hitting 300 DCs soon...are we going to see mobs scaled to that? I think we're already on the way there. Lamordia suggests that monster saves are going up to the point where many casters in particular are useless wastes of space. The gap between the casual and the hardcore player is not a gap: it is a gulf, and the d20 system is a big part of that.
"this game is fun, but how do I actually contribute?"
"oh it's easy, here's a build, just get completionist and grind out 210,000 sentient XP and this raid gear and that curse out of several dozen and 75 reaper shards to curse your ring, have fun, see you in a few years, then be ready to change it when they nerf this build and the meta shifts!"
I expect some pushback from elite players on this, who have grinded their way to the top of the pile and probably think things are working juuuuust fine, but there's a large part of the player base that has felt something being off for a while now. It's the d20, and trying to work everything around that.
But when people started hitting 100AC, then 200AC, now 1000AC+, it became increasingly obvious that the small 1-20 window just wasn't going to hold up. To-hit and AC had to be reworked so that there was a broader range of what was viable, and you didn't have to hit specific numbers for specific content. The concept of having 80AC=completely murdered and 99AC=nearly invulnerable was a time bomb with increased power creep. At a certain point, the math just didn't math.
Saving throws, in many ways, have now gotten there. Trickster builds can hit 200+ DCs, dragonlord first life builds can hit 140+ DCs fairly easily...but traditional first life casters often struggle to get 80-90 DCs. Yes, I know they can get more, but if you only have a few filigree slots and aren't min-maxed, a lot of casual players hitting level 34 for the first time will be in that 80-90 DC range, and they probably have exactly a 5% success rate in the latest content...even on elite or r1. That feels bad, nevermind going into r7-10 and having your damage arbitrarily be lower than other classes.
To be clear, I don't know the best way to implement this, and there are clearly some massive downfalls to making saves and checks work the same as armor class across the board. The no-fail intimi tank would feel completely different with 90% success rate, let alone 70-80%. Trapping might also be a bit of a cluster. It also feels a bit punitive to the uber-completionist-reaper-geared-best-curse builds because now 1 extra DC doesn't really feel like all that much. In general, players failing saves feels a lot worse than monsters succeeding, so it's possible that this system might only have to work for enemy checks, not players. Players can still enjoy no-fail (or 95% of the time, at least) saves and checks while monsters get a new scaling similar to how AC works.
Regardless, it's very clear that things can't continue on the way they are. Some people are going to be hitting 300 DCs soon...are we going to see mobs scaled to that? I think we're already on the way there. Lamordia suggests that monster saves are going up to the point where many casters in particular are useless wastes of space. The gap between the casual and the hardcore player is not a gap: it is a gulf, and the d20 system is a big part of that.
"this game is fun, but how do I actually contribute?"
"oh it's easy, here's a build, just get completionist and grind out 210,000 sentient XP and this raid gear and that curse out of several dozen and 75 reaper shards to curse your ring, have fun, see you in a few years, then be ready to change it when they nerf this build and the meta shifts!"
I expect some pushback from elite players on this, who have grinded their way to the top of the pile and probably think things are working juuuuust fine, but there's a large part of the player base that has felt something being off for a while now. It's the d20, and trying to work everything around that.