Spell DCs/saves...it's time, devs.

Mechgraber

Well-known member
The d20 system is great, and brings a ton of value to the game. It's iconic and has held up fairly well.

But when people started hitting 100AC, then 200AC, now 1000AC+, it became increasingly obvious that the small 1-20 window just wasn't going to hold up. To-hit and AC had to be reworked so that there was a broader range of what was viable, and you didn't have to hit specific numbers for specific content. The concept of having 80AC=completely murdered and 99AC=nearly invulnerable was a time bomb with increased power creep. At a certain point, the math just didn't math.

Saving throws, in many ways, have now gotten there. Trickster builds can hit 200+ DCs, dragonlord first life builds can hit 140+ DCs fairly easily...but traditional first life casters often struggle to get 80-90 DCs. Yes, I know they can get more, but if you only have a few filigree slots and aren't min-maxed, a lot of casual players hitting level 34 for the first time will be in that 80-90 DC range, and they probably have exactly a 5% success rate in the latest content...even on elite or r1. That feels bad, nevermind going into r7-10 and having your damage arbitrarily be lower than other classes.

To be clear, I don't know the best way to implement this, and there are clearly some massive downfalls to making saves and checks work the same as armor class across the board. The no-fail intimi tank would feel completely different with 90% success rate, let alone 70-80%. Trapping might also be a bit of a cluster. It also feels a bit punitive to the uber-completionist-reaper-geared-best-curse builds because now 1 extra DC doesn't really feel like all that much. In general, players failing saves feels a lot worse than monsters succeeding, so it's possible that this system might only have to work for enemy checks, not players. Players can still enjoy no-fail (or 95% of the time, at least) saves and checks while monsters get a new scaling similar to how AC works.

Regardless, it's very clear that things can't continue on the way they are. Some people are going to be hitting 300 DCs soon...are we going to see mobs scaled to that? I think we're already on the way there. Lamordia suggests that monster saves are going up to the point where many casters in particular are useless wastes of space. The gap between the casual and the hardcore player is not a gap: it is a gulf, and the d20 system is a big part of that.

"this game is fun, but how do I actually contribute?"

"oh it's easy, here's a build, just get completionist and grind out 210,000 sentient XP and this raid gear and that curse out of several dozen and 75 reaper shards to curse your ring, have fun, see you in a few years, then be ready to change it when they nerf this build and the meta shifts!"


I expect some pushback from elite players on this, who have grinded their way to the top of the pile and probably think things are working juuuuust fine, but there's a large part of the player base that has felt something being off for a while now. It's the d20, and trying to work everything around that.
 

Aelastiar

Well-known member
I think skill based dc checks for cc/ik should have never been implemented in the first place. Its too late now, so maybe they could start by increasing all spell school dc bonuses on gear by 50%.

But instead they'll just add another unique paltry dc bonus affix that's competes with the rest of your gear, so you can do the same thing that martial dps can do, minus the dps.
 

The Narc2

Well-known member
Its too late to get away from the winning model of cashing in on the players that are fully invested, they have been the big spenders and will continue to be the big spenders. it is best for the games survival to focus on these players and then continue to cash in on the ones chasing to catch up, they just need to continue to make some of the grind an easier catch up for the mid spenders. making past lives xp rates lower was a good start for that.
 

cocopufff

Well-known member
People used to be able to make the argument that casters were allowed to be worse at DPS because they were better at CC. But it feels like with new archetypes (Dragon Lord and Arcane Trickster) having actively better-scaling more accessible DCs in addition to more damage, the argument falls flat. I mean, it's crazy to me that Dragon Lords get a free +20 to their tactical feats, just for existing.

Torc stated that DC relief is their first goal with caster changes. So at least the devs are aware of this. (I can dig up the post for anyone curious.)
 
Last edited:

l_remmie

Well-known member
I've said it before, ssg needs to make use of non-existing dice. It's a computer game use the benefits.

Mob has 73 reflex, roll a d73 and compare it against your DC. Even a first liver with 50DC will have 50/73 chance to succeed.

It will destroy the gulf btween the haves and have nots.
It won't fix spellDC vs dragonlord tactics. That needs inflating DC gear.

The one thing this needs is readjusting saves for most mobs in the game. So it will never ever happen.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
Heavens, no! The last thing we need is a system like AC, which I would call anything but good! What we need is a return to rationality instead of delving deeper into pure madness!

1. Lower the saves of NPCs in MD+ content. They are far too high, and in Lamordia they are absolutely insane! Lower them.

• Don't repeat the mistake you made with the epification of Necro 4 more than a decade ago. Back then, DCs were also absurdly high, and DC casters were dying. Turbine solution was to introduce items that jumped from +7 to +11 stats and, on top of that, normalize the introduction of Insightful stats. No! It was a mistake that led to uncontrolled stat inflation for years and ultimately to stat squish. Do the right thing: Lower the stats of NPCs that are too high!

• All this talk about standardizing everything, and yet new content still has much higher stats than old content. Stop making saving throws and damage hits harder and harder in new content versus old! Even in heroics, there's a noticeable difference in difficulty between new and old content of the same level.

2. Skill-based saving throws are absurd and break the DC system. Skills are for skill tests, no for spell checks! Using Intimidate to draw aggro—correct. Using Intimidate on an instantkill that's equivalent to and better than a level 9 spell—wrong! The skill-based spells of the Arcane Trickster: wrong! *It's not balanced*

2. And related to the above: we should all play by the same rules. How do you expect to balance anything, devs, when you have classes playing with skill-based DCs (50 points or more difference compared to the caster DC system!), with tactics-based DCs (much easier to obtain and equip, although the final result isn't that drastically different!), and with the traditional spell DC system? Devs: it's impossible! We should all play by the same rules! We should all be able to achieve a very similar final DC score and require a similar investment effort!


* I remind you, devs, that tactics had a different system because initially they were dedicated to tests that weren't based on saving throws. But you've progressively changed all, or almost all, tactics to conventional saving throws. One has to question the rationale of this system. If they're going to be conventional saving throws, shouldn't the tactics DC acquisition system be unified with that of spells? If they're not going to be, create a rational mechanic for martial tactics instead to default to saving throws!

It can't be that caster feats give +1 to spell DC while martial feats give +4/+6. It can't be that caster enhancements give a paltry +1 to certain schools while martial enhancements give +3 or more. It can't be that caster items give +5 and have a million channels while tactical items give +12 and have far fewer channels. If it's all ultimately versus a saving throw, then the DC acquisition system should be similar.

* Regarding skill-based DCs for spells, there's nothing more to say: they're absurd and a mistake. The system isn't prepared for this discrepancy.

4. The gear for casters is absurd. I'm sorry, but it's in a fatal state. If anything needs a major overhaul, it's itemization, not the DC system. Stop separating spell DCs into a thousand channels. Merge them and make it more compact, like melee tactics. Stop making some channels absurdly difficult to obtain. Stop dividing so much by schools; there's not room for everything. And the same goes for damage: too many channels for spell damage, too much division by elements. Stop making us invest all our filigrees in spell DCs; create sets that simultaneously boost both DCs and spell damage. Stop the madness.

5. Casters and hybrids shouldn't have to sacrifice absolutely everything to achieve a functional DC. Balance NPC saves with the character DCs to achieve a rational system. The DC gained from equipment and feats should be rational: it should require effort, but it shouldn't be borderline impossible, requiring you to invest absolutely everything in it. Casters and hybrids also need to invest in damage and defenses. It can't be that DCs require such a huge investment. It's disproportionate. It's unfair. It's a discrepancy that is unbalancing these classes/builds.


As someone who has played countless casters, both first-life (including hardcore without tomes) and completionist, I have no problem with DCs on a first-life caster with appropriate gear on heroics (and appropriate gear is easy to obtain in heroics, even under hardcore conditions; it doesn't require insane gear). In epics there aren't major issues either, although having filigrees starts to matter a lot here. But then legendaries arrive, the combination of brutal saves inflation on NPCs and the absolute insane gearing makes characters with low past lives & reaper points, or even characters with PLs and Reaper Points but unoptimized gear, useless. Stop, devs. The problem with spell DCs doesn't lie on the system, the problem lies at legendary levels, and a major culprit is itemization. Itemization for spell DC is currently very bad. Really, really bad.

Spell damage has too a similar bad itemization problem.
 
Last edited:

Love

Well-known member
Give nukers spellcraft to DC's
I think a fair skill to base DCs on would be concentration, since every caster uses it. Basing it on spellcraft would give INT-based classes like wizards and alchemists an advantage. Thematically it just fits: greater focus equals more powerful spells.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
I think a fair skill to base DCs on would be concentration, since every caster uses it. Basing it on spellcraft would give INT-based classes like wizards and alchemists an advantage. Thematically it just fits: greater focus equals more powerful spells.
No, skills for spell DCs are a really bad idea. The system isn't designed for them. What needs to be done is to remove the current skill-based spell DCs and instead fix the real problems with the spell DC system. See my previous post for details.

The DC system works better than those without extensive experience playing casters realize. The problem lies in an excessive inflation of saves at legendary levels (obvious solution: lower them a bit), and in an absolutely flawed itemization system (solution: make it rational).

There's no need to reinvent the wheel and create new problems.
 

voenixa121

Well-known member
Since we don't have touch spells or cantrips in DDO we need some better system than we have now with spell DCs. Just upping DCs or lowering saves will always lead to new problems, since the same system is used for damage, debuff, cc and instant kills. All of these thing are vastly different in their usefulness and difficult to balance, which is most likely why we had this kind of save inflation on enemies.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
Since we don't have touch spells or cantrips in DDO we need some better system than we have now with spell DCs. Just upping DCs or lowering saves will always lead to new problems, since the same system is used for damage, debuff, cc and instant kills. All of these thing are vastly different in their usefulness and difficult to balance, which is most likely why we had this kind of save inflation on enemies.
Instantkills are absolutely overrated. They don't work on a huge number of trash NPCs, and on any of the bosses. Asking for an absurd investment in them makes no sense in the current game context.

Spell debuffs should be easier to apply, yes. But more importantly, they should have some useful effect. The biggest problem with spell debuffs right now is that they're useless and don't work on bosses. A review of boss immunity is needed, and high DCs for debuffs should be avoided. Spell debuffs with outdated effects (most of them!) should be updated to current standards.

CC is the most useful, but nowadays martials have very good crowd control, and again, it doesn't work on bosses either. There's no need to make it impossibly difficult.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
I think skill based dc checks for cc/ik should have never been implemented in the first place. Its too late now, so maybe they could start by increasing all spell school dc bonuses on gear by 50%.

But instead they'll just add another unique paltry dc bonus affix that's competes with the rest of your gear, so you can do the same thing that martial dps can do, minus the dps.
it's not too late It's never too late to undo an obvious (huge) mistake.
 

Love

Well-known member
No, skills for spell DCs are a really bad idea. The system isn't designed for them. What needs to be done is to remove the current skill-based spell DCs and instead fix the real problems with the spell DC system. See my previous post for details.

The DC system works better than those without extensive experience playing casters realize. The problem lies in an excessive inflation of saves at legendary levels (obvious solution: lower them a bit), and in an absolutely flawed itemization system (solution: make it rational).

There's no need to reinvent the wheel and create new problems.
No, sorry. I'm not reading an AI-generated wall of text.

Giving the way they have set up the latest archetype with skills to DC's, why should other casters be left behind.
I responded to another comment saying i think if DC's should scale on skills, that concentration would make more sense than spellcraft.

In the current meta, melee classes are better CC, DPS and instakillers. Something needs to change, and I doubt it's going to be the newly released classes.
 
Last edited:

Lazuli

Well-known member
No, sorry. I'm not reading an AI-generated wall of text.

Giving the way they have set up the latest archetype with skills to DC's, why should other casters be left behind.
I responded to another comment saying i think if DC's should scale on skills, that concentration would make more sense than spellcraft.

In the current meta, melee classes are better CC, DPS and instakillers. Something needs to change, and I doubt it's going to be the newly released classes.
I never use AI for my posts, and if you'd read them, you'd have seen that they have nothing to do with AI-generated content.

In fact, I'm too old to get used to using those technologies. I have a brain, and I know how to write my own texts, thank you very much.

I'm not a native English speaker, so my posts may have some grammatical errors (they probably do), but they're perfectly readable and human-written.

And if you had bothered to read the post, you would have seen that I agree that there is a problem and a discrepancy with other DC acquisition systems (tactics and skill-based). But the solution absolutely does not lie in switching everything to skill-DCs.
 

Necrodancer

Ancient beyond measure
No, sorry. I'm not reading an AI-generated wall of text.

Giving the way they have set up the latest archetype with skills to DC's, why should other casters be left behind.
I responded to another comment saying i think if DC's should scale on skills, that concentration would make more sense than spellcraft.

In the current meta, melee classes are better CC, DPS and instakillers. Something needs to change, and I doubt it's going to be the newly released classes.

Then how do you know it's AI? Me and Laz feel the same about many aspects of the game and I can clearly and easily read the frustration and disappointment with the current state of casters. It's a lot of things but not AI.

Instantkills are absolutely overrated. They don't work on a huge number of trash NPCs, and on any of the bosses. Asking for an absurd investment in them makes no sense in the current game context.

Spell debuffs should be easier to apply, yes. But more importantly, they should have some useful effect. The biggest problem with spell debuffs right now is that they're useless and don't work on bosses. A review of boss immunity is needed, and high DCs for debuffs should be avoided. Spell debuffs with outdated effects (most of them!) should be updated to current standards.

CC is the most useful, but nowadays martials have very good crowd control, and again, it doesn't work on bosses either. There's no need to make it impossibly difficult.

Yup. IK already got gutted with heavy nerfs during these years. Just to list the heavy offenders:

- Orange named epic monsters are immune to IK as if they were red named

- Spells such as wail of banshee and circle of death got reworked to specifically limit the amount of stuff they could kill.

What's next? Anything above R4 becomes immune to IK?

One of the things they could do for debuffs would be to let spells of the "dispel magic" line apply a decent MRR debuff. Hell, make Mordenkainen disjunction give a flat 100% bonus damage to next spell on top of the debuff and now you finally have a reason to take it in your spell book and actually help with raid boss damage.
 
Last edited:

Lazuli

Well-known member
Just because a post is long and well-structured for readability doesn't mean it's AI-generated. I make a great effort to write legibly in English and even proofread my posts several times to correct any grammatical errors. I'm aware that my English is far from perfect, but I try my best to write as well as I can. And it's a real effort; it takes me three times as long as writing in my native language. I know my texts have some grammatical errors, but if someone accuses me of using AI, they haven't even bothered to read them.

I never use, nor have I ever used, AI to generate a single one of my posts.

And some of us were taught in school thirty and even forty years ago, when teachers taught us to write texts in an organized way instead of using technologies that write for you xD.
 

Love

Well-known member
I never use AI for my posts, and if you'd read them, you'd have seen that they have nothing to do with AI-generated content.

I never use, nor have I ever used, AI to generate a single one of my posts.
I did not realise that one comment would be considered this offensive.

I don't disagree with most of your points. All I said is that if DCs should scale with a skill, concentration would be a better fit than spellcraft. It's not that deep. Whether you like skill-scaling or not, concentration makes more sense than spellcraft. That is all I responded to another commenter.
This subject is obviously very important to you, but that doesn't mean others can't have an opinion.
 

Fizzix

Well-known member
Just because a post is long and well-structured for readability doesn't mean it's AI-generated. I make a great effort to write legibly in English and even proofread my posts several times to correct any grammatical errors. I'm aware that my English is far from perfect, but I try my best to write as well as I can. And it's a real effort; it takes me three times as long as writing in my native language. I know my texts have some grammatical errors, but if someone accuses me of using AI, they haven't even bothered to read them.

I never use, nor have I ever used, AI to generate a single one of my posts.

And some of us were taught in school thirty and even forty years ago, when teachers taught us to write texts in an organized way instead of using technologies that write for you xD.

This is too funny. A long thorough post is thought to be ai because it: had line breaks and no spelling errors.

regardless, yes the DC system for spells is beyond bad.

I dont even chase it, never have. Not because I dont play casters, they're my favorite class, the way its implemented is just dumb.

the a 1-20 variable window that keeps inflating the min with every pack and release defies logic...

It means Casters need to be carried in every expansion till they get all their gear to have what a 50% of it working at all?
 

Mechgraber

Well-known member

I'd agree that skill-based DCs just open the door for silliness. I don't think they thought things through.

Tactics across the board aren't broken though, it's really only dragon lord and to a lesser extent the basic fighter class. Try hitting super high DCs on a paladin or ranger and you'll find it's probably not even worth building for. You'll generally hit 80 or 90 without a clear path to the 120+ that seems needed, then kinda just go another route. Barbs maybe, I'm not as familiar. It's really that they give fighters 4 cheap feats with +8/6/4/2 to all tactics DCs, and then the dragon lord tree gives another maybe +10, plus the trance...yea it gets silly quickly.

As for casters, I'd agree that there are big changes needed here, gearing is an absolute nightmare and the fact that their solution is adding another bonus type is borderline insulting...or at least out of touch. Also 100% agree that heroic and epic are just fine, it's mostly legendary, particularly the most recent content that has issues....big ones.

I suppose where we can agree overall is that the current system clearly isn't balanced and needs changing. If they were willing to walk back many of the changes to DCs that are clearly "off" like MD lamordia mob saves, intim-instakilling, dragonlord roar, trickster, etc...sure. But seeing as they just released the latter and in some ways it's the most egregious...

I just don't really see them doing that. That's the thing. After Dragon Lord was released, pretty much everyone I talked to was sure the roar would be nerfed in a month or two. We were all just waiting for it, as it was the silliest thing ever. They never did. I think it would be more balanced if they did, and even nicer if they had the foresight to not make such clearly silly decisions in the first place, I just not sure if they'll admit it was all unbalanced and make the needed "rollbacks" as it were. So a different solution might be needed.
 
Top