U72 Early Look 2: Monk Revamp

Status
Not open for further replies.

Neo

The One
I was not doing some DPS test in the video. I was testing the finisher CD which is not clearly shown. It is very clear I am deliberate about moving out of melee range while building the finisher.


It's very hard to have an educated discussion with someone who has clearly never used the attacks in game.

The builders and the finishers just modify your attack in progress they don't stop you from attacking normally. You can hold down left click and
use your keybinds to press the builders and the finishers and your normal attacks will continue as if you weren't pressing the buttons at all. The buttons will just add the 10% dmg on the builders and then the 30% dmg + autocrit on the FDF finisher.

Buy vet status. Make a level 7 dark monk.

Make your hot bar this.

1. Fire strike teir I 2. Dark builder 3. Fire strike teir II 4. Finishing move. 5. Earth strike Teir I 6. Fists of iron 7. Earth strike teir II 8. Finishing move

Record yourself dpsing a cannon with auto attack on. Do it two times. Once with pressing 1-8 and once without and let me know how different they feel.
 
Last edited:

5 Other People

all the voices in my head are my own
I do understand what your doing & appreciate the break down.

To me, this is a playstyle that you like & that's enough for me.

I won't brag about hours spent in game or achievements, let's just say I've played the monk for years, though not since the first major nerf hit and was burned so hard I never looked back at monk. There are many ways to play a monk.

If we can get more finishers available it'd motivate me to play more monk.
 

Tilomere

Well-known member
I think one of the biggest boosts to bringing back healing ki monk melee healing utlity is capping renewal and FoTW healing to CL20 like other epic caster abilities, and in the case of renewal also bringing its mana cost up to 25 to match reconstruct SLA as a melee healing option, and in the case of rage healing also limit rage regen to be at the same rate that LoH regenerates. That opens up space for melee class healing to be more meaningful.

Monk as a self-healing melee is a hard sell while visage lord has so much healing and doesn't come with a 50 MRR cap.
 

Uska

Drum knight
Being able to use wraps in one hand and a longsword in the other? Dude that would be so cool looking - the melee animation is half the reason I play monk. I can’t imagine what that would even look like. Is that even possible?
I don’t see that happening
 

Uska

Drum knight
On Friday’s at Four, Jan 17, 2025 at 20:44, Severlin spoke about the upcoming changes for the Monk Class.



I don’t know where even to start to address this.
It is clear after that discussion SSG has already made up you mind and are not actually looking for feedback rather hoping to get players to like your changes. I am going to be clear, I will not like these changes no matter how you try to sugar coat them.

Let start with the first question, who is asking for changes to the monk system. Severlin states “back and forth with players”, who specifically is promoting these changes, what players are the Dev Team going back and forth with. As the Players’ Council is listed separately it means there is some group of players asking for this change. I was not involved in any discussion, there are no threads on the forums. From where I am sitting the demand doesn’t exist from the player base in general. Yes there are few threads asking for updates, but no one has suggested getting rid of the combo system. Did I miss some threads, are they hidden from me? These changes appear to be coming from within SSG, not without. If the development team is trying to make the changes that is fine. When you suggest that player’s rather than the development team is without providing any detail it is not a good look.

“The combos hitting at higher damage while play testing” Who did you have doing the play testing, the development team, QA, the players’ Council. It certainly was not the players in general, none of the 100 plus players who have chimed in both early preview threads. If you have these changes lined up for play testing why not allow a bigger cross section of players to try out the increased DPS vs. the new updated system?

That also doesn’t address the fact that the combos aren’t about DPS, the combos are for generating other benefits for the monk and other members of the party.

Additionally lets cut to the chase, even I an individual who pugs constantly I am only in a party less than 50% of the time when playing my monk. Who do you think is killing half the mobs half the time? I mean it would have to be me wouldn’t it.

As a monk player you should be constantly building up combos, starting before any encounter, I mean at least of 1/3 of my combat encounters start with a combo. I realize that maybe an argument for a cooldown system, the problem is I use 9 different combos currently, depending on what I am engaged with, who I am playing with and finally what I want to accomplish. The new monk enhancement system, if I build it who you think it should be built I have a four maybe, however I am guessing that probably 3. That is a huge loss of versatility in the class. Let me be clear you are taking away the versatility of monk, gutting the class by taking away the other builders/finisher combos.

I have listened to the argument put forth by Steelstar suggesting that the increasing the damage “no cost builders/finisher combos are too powerful for the cost. [no feats, enhancement]” During the Fridays at Four Severlin said “even at higher damage the combos were not satisfying.” Which is it, is it not satisfying or too powerful, it cannot be both.

Nothing that has been presented makes me feel good about these changes. Rather the opposite is true, the development team has made me feel like our opinions as players who play monk does not matter at all. That all the Dev Team wants is to flat line DPS to make the game easier to balance.

Considering that Monk is the third lowest played primary class, only Alchemist and Favored Soul, are lower, what do you think will happen. The 3 to 4 percent of players, according to ddoaudit, that play monk are going to give up on Monk and move to other classes. Do you think 20 percent of the people playing Fighter, Barbarian, and Paladin are going to flip over to Monk? How about 10 percent of the other classes? I am guessing the number of players who play Monks will drop to be inline with Alchemist and Favored Soul, about 2 percent.

Where do you think people playing Monk are going to go? How many players are you willing to lose if you make these changes. I enjoy this game, I am not going to quit, however I won’t be playing monk, guess rogue is in my main's future.

I am going to be honest, I am not a whale, rather a tubby dolphin. Last year I didn’t purchase Necromancer Patron at all, I always have purchased the Superior/Ultimate packs, but this time after the missteps in 2024, I decided to not cough up the cash. I think you are making it clear to me that I will not be purchasing the ultimate (or any) of the expansion pack this year, no patron packs. It is a self defeating prophecy of destruction.
If they ruin monk I’ll probably just quit it’s the only class I really like and Implay shinato
 

Wini

Well-known member
Eager to know more dev information about the monk changes, I hope we can get a glimpse soon
 
Last edited:

woq

Well-known member
From the official discord:
Steelstar1.png

Steelstar_2.png

Steelstar3.png

Steelstar_4.png

Steelstar_5.png

I reckon an official update on the forums will wait until they have significant actions they've taken to actually show and get feedback on before we hear more.
 

Rohnen

New member
Hello all, I haven't read all the posts yet, but so far I haven't seen anything about Ki gain from ranged attacks. It has always seemed like a bug/oversite that there was no on-hit ki gain from ranged attacks. There seems to be an intent for shuriken build and there are thematic feats to allow bow builds, yet if you go this route, you are ki starved. only able to use abilities that have a low enough ki cast that the passive regeneration to account for.
Further, it also seemed odd that the ki strikes/combo builders/finishing moves could not be used with ranged attacks.

Ramblings:
It always feels wrong when there are granted, special feats, or abilities for a given class to give it that unique flavor only to have that unique flavor lost unless you follow the railroaded path. Choosing the class should allow you to have fun with experimenting with how the generic feats/abilities will interact and create something fun and interesting, not choosing the class AND only choosing specific weapons/paths.
Back when the weapon type actually meant something, (like slashing weapons had Vorpal, another had Banish, and another Smite) there was something more to builds or classes that had innate aptitudes for those types made more sense. But since the weapon types mean nothing now, except which Improved Crit feat you need to take, it makes less sense to lock abilities to weapon types. I'd be all for bringing back weapon type uniqueness though, it added reason and meaning other than the amount of damage dice.
 

J1NG

I can do things others can't...
Supposedly there is "intent" by the Devs to permit Ki generation via ranged weaponry in this overhaul. However, this has not been confirmed to be working, and thus remains an "intent" by the Dev.

So for now, we can hope that it does work when the preview happens. But also expect to be disappointed also, because the Devs have previously done similar changes (with intent) but the code didn't work as they thought it did, and thus no matter how much the Devs "intent" was, it was never going to happen without more work elsewhere (which they won't go back to).

J1NG
 

Shall

Well-known member
If they can't get ki gain on ranged weapons to work, maybe they could at least add a ranged ability somewhere that just reuses the GMOF orchid blossom effect of granting you ki on use without costing ki. I'm not sure where in the tree would be a good place for it though. Maybe in one of the early ninja cores, if not added to the very first core since ki gain should be easily available due to it being a major class mechanic (possibly with the ki gain on use increased with later cores). Or maybe as a multiselector with the melee only dark strike ability, although that could cause a problem with how it interacts with the poison exploit upgrade if using it often enough to maintain your ki pool keeps you from building up a decent amount of poison stacks before consuming them with poison exploit. In any event I would like a ranged attack shadow flurry alternative that activates poison exploit (and as many have stated already, the most recent proposed shadow flurry should not have an hp cost).

Edit Now that I think about it, adding it to shadow flurry would be a bad idea since it would force ranged players into the dark path.
 
Last edited:

Shall

Well-known member
And after changes to Flash Bang it would force ranged toons into light path if no changes to flurry be made. 8)

Yeah, like I said, there should be a ranged dark option so ranged monks have an option to activate poison exploit and actually give them a choice in path, maybe an attack that reduces target's movement speed or something? Or maybe a ranged aoe attack since most other ranged trees get at least one, except for mechanic, but that's probably just because that tree hasn't been updated in a while. At first I was going to suggest changing ki bolt from a ki spender to a ki granter as kind of a lesser orchid blossom for heroics, but I figured it would end up being a net negative due to the ki bolt animation interrupting the attack animation.
 

Mindos

CHAOTIC EVIL
From the official discord:
Steelstar1.png


Steelstar3.png


Steelstar_5.png

I reckon an official update on the forums will wait until they have significant actions they've taken to actually show and get feedback on before we hear more.
I wrote out something but I deleted it. That's it, that's all the passion I have anymore.
 

Eme

Well-known member
I wrote out something but I deleted it. That's it, that's all the passion I have anymore.
same for me on page 1 while halfway through another detailed breakdown. I've not had the desire to play even once since this was announced. I'm wishing they change their minds, but from the devs past history I have no hope anymore.
 
Last edited:

LurkingVeteran

Well-known member
Did not read everything, but some comments that might not have been mentioned:

1) The rework of Ninja Spy towards ranged weapons in general actually opens up for playing a diet version of Monkcher again. I'm not sure how it would rank up there with other bow builds but with the support of another ranged tree it might be pretty fun. The main problem as I see it is that the modern bow style of stacking Archer's Focus meshes poorly with the monkcher movement speed.

2) The other two monk trees are still keyed to melee only. There is I think one piece of RP in Shintao but all the abilities and the other stuff is melee/MP. Henshin is similar. Not sure if it is a conscious decision to not give monk two ranged trees, but there is anyway racial AA and universal HW.

3) If the Vistani centering enhancement was fixed to apply to throwing knives, you could do a pretty cool monk knife thrower (could possibly even use MP).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top