U80 Preview 2 - DC Boost Initiative

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kalapurka

Member
Doing you a solid one and not bother going into too many details. It's best if I don't comment on the entire post.

+11 to a single spell school DC is level 34.

+11 to a single martial technique is level 20 (purchasable from Randall Lyiric in Evening Star)

Do you even bother to fact check yourself or you knew it and typed that with a straight face?

Your entire post feels like you are stating obvious thing for the sake of writing something. Don't just write you agree with players who are giving you excellent feedback if you're going to ignore them anyway. Dom made an excellent point but your answer is...what is your answer exactly??



IN English please? You are agreeing so you're going to do something about it or whatever? You are just writing to show you are taking feedback or something?
Brutal, sometimes you need to cut trough toxic positivity.
 

EinarMal

Well-known member
I mean... No, not really.

In the addressed post it was stated that a lvl 34 spell focus mastery items would increase from 5/3/2 to 8/4/2, with single schools being +12/6/3.
...Combat Mastery goes to +12/6/3 at lvl 34, while Vertigo goes to +17 (and theoratically 8/4 for insightful/quality if they were a thing).

I would still also look into increasing the amount Spell Focus feats give. I don't know how much +1 per feat will cut it these days.
Agree it's not doing much at all, just essentially for show, "see we listen to players DC is fixed now for casters to enjoy!"

Today, you are probably at 6/3/2 + 2GH if you care about DC, for the main schools you use. So +13 from gear being adjusted.

With this change, you will probably try to fit in the MD ring for necro/enchant/illusion let's say, which should be +11, but you will probably be stuck without any increase in insightful or quality by school, as I can't fit any of that stuff in even if it existed.

So that is 11/4/2 IF you can get gear from just the last couple of expansions = +17

So all of this work basically boils down to you getting +4-5 DC at most; if you do nothing, you are +1. But they now forced players to re-gear only on the very latest expansion or maybe one prior.

So yeah, a ton of work to basically do nothing. For this to have been even remotely successful for anyone that actually understands the game +10 increase would have been the bare minimum to align it more with tactics.

So, a complete fail in my opinion, one could say, well, at least they did something. The issue with that is that once they do something like this, they will say they fixed caster DC, and they will not look at it again for 5 years.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
Agree it's not doing much at all, just essentially for show, "see we listen to players DC is fixed now for casters to enjoy!"
In reality, they are doing something: they are complicating caster gear even more, and there is no place to put all that division in schools. They are doing exactly the opposite what is necessary. It will be ok this update because we can continue more or less with the same numbers, and it will begin to sink in successive years.

I don't blame Tonquin, he doesn't make the decisions. But it has been a poor approach. I also know that the devs were unaware of the bloated gear problem even though we have told them many times in these forums (but since they don't read them! Now that Tonquin is back, at least before I read them, let's see if we see improvements). And since they didn't read them, they weren't prepared to make a profound change to the gear now. That's quite a bit of work.

But as band aid this is a bad band aid. Very bad. The caster equipment urgently needs to be simplified. If at least they were kind enough to group several schools and several elements for each enchantement it will be more manageable. Right now creating a caster tetris gear is a nightmare, and they are doing it worse. But what's the point of continuing to give feedback, spending so much time and effort reasoning in a foreign language that I don't know well so that they don't listen.

And this coupled with a nerf to the caster dps in the form of a proc nerf. It doesn't make sense. The worst archetypes nerfed again. If they want to change the procs they should do it when they improve the spell dps, not before. People are going to come into the game, see that their casters are even worse, and how do the devs think they're going to react? There are people who say that these forums are toxic, but they should see how players actually talk about them in the game when no one can ban them. There is a chasm between devs and players right now. The devs should try to close it, not enlarge it.

Poor Tonquin. The players love him, but in the end he is a dev, and he is going to swallow the anger that exists against the other devs. Don't blame him. It's not his fault the rest of the team is so so so wrong. He cannot make the changes alone.

Years ago, we told the devs that the nerfs to the casters were excessive, that they were going to ruin casters, that they should not do nerfs at the same time as buffing the martials, that their nerfs were also impacting the weak casters at the same time as the strong casters. They didn't listen to us, and we have been in an unsustainably weak position for years. Casters are rejected in raids because they are useless there. The casters are totally outclassed in r10. There are many casual/new/medium players who have even a hard time reaching workable DC on elite because to be proficient with a caster you need to equip much more than with a martial one.

If the devs don't understand the source of so much frustration, they will never be able to fix the problem, and people will continue to get more and more frustrated and angrier. It's a vicious circle.
 
Last edited:

vik

Well-known member
Making some assumptions for level 33 scaling and going for DC gear focusing necro, enchant, evo, and conjuration:
Tonquin said 12/6/3 single schools at level 34, 8/4/2 for mastery at level 34
Assuming 11/5/2 single school at level 33, 7/3/2 for mastery at level 33:

Legendary Climber's Remembrance, which is level 34 rare loot, to get the 4 ins spell focus.
Essence Crafted necro goggles: 12/6/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +7
Legendary Gem Many Facets crafted with enchantment spell focus: 12/4/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +5
Legendary Band Manifest Magic for evo and conjuration at level 33: 11/4/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +4

Legendary Darstil's Gloves, which is level 33, to get the 3 ins spell focus:
Essence Crafted necro goggles: 12/6/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +7
Legendary Gem Many Facets crafted with enchantment spell focus: 12/3/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +4
Legendary Band Manifest Magic for evo and conjuration at level 33: 11/3/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +3

A more generic layout might look like:
Legendary Darstil's Gloves, ins spell focus +3
Legendary Band Mental Magic for necro and enchant at level 33: 11/3/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +3
Legendary Band Manifest Magic for evo and conjuration at level 33: 11/3/2 vs 6/3/2+2gh = +3
 
Last edited:

Lazuli

Well-known member
Every Cannith Essence crafted piece you use won't have sun/moon slots or any other set stats. The only decent one is the GoMF but its complementary item will be outclassed with this update, yet we'll still need to slot it because its set has no representation in the sun/gem system.

This is a terrible situation for casters.

They're basically telling us: buy the new xpack, or change your caster to martial.
 

vik

Well-known member
Agreed, so I modified the post above to show a more generic layout. Thought it might help to see potential modifications to DCs with our current gear.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
I'm not going to modify my gear. With Lamordia, I changed all my casters gear because procs are the way they sold us on improving spell DPS, even though I told them in Lammania that it wasn't the right way. And now, less than a year later, they're making that investment of time, effort, and money useless.

No, I'm not falling for that same trap anymore. It's not just about swapping one item for another. It's about changing your entire layout because changing one item throws off a lot of your stats. And then, on top of that, you lose DPS because adding new DC suffixes means giving up DPS suffixes, since we don't have any more slots than before. Uhh... no.

If the change were a proper one, I'd grind my teeth and go through the enormous effort of re-gearing. Here, all I see is losing DPS for DC. No. These days, DC casters are useless. No.

If they make my casters useless, I'll move to another game, and that's it.
 
Last edited:

Necrodancer

Ancient beyond measure
In reality, they are doing something: they are complicating caster gear even more, and there is no place to put all that division in schools. They are doing exactly the opposite what is necessary. It will be ok this update because we can continue more or less with the same numbers, and it will begin to sink in successive years.

I don't blame Tonquin, he doesn't make the decisions. But it has been a poor approach. I also know that the devs were unaware of the bloated gear problem even though we have told them many times in these forums (but since they don't read them! Now that Tonquin is back, at least before I read them, let's see if we see improvements). And since they didn't read them, they weren't prepared to make a profound change to the gear now. That's quite a bit of work.

But as band aid this is a bad band aid. Very bad. The caster equipment urgently needs to be simplified. If at least they were kind enough to group several schools and several elements for each enchantement it will be more manageable. Right now creating a caster tetris gear is a nightmare, and they are doing it worse. But what's the point of continuing to give feedback, spending so much time and effort reasoning in a foreign language that I don't know well so that they don't listen.

And this coupled with a nerf to the caster dps in the form of a proc nerf. It doesn't make sense. The worst archetypes nerfed again. If they want to change the procs they should do it when they improve the spell dps, not before. People are going to come into the game, see that their casters are even worse, and how do the devs think they're going to react? There are people who say that these forums are toxic, but they should see how players actually talk about them in the game when no one can ban them. There is a chasm between devs and players right now. The devs should try to close it, not enlarge it.

Poor Tonquin. The players love him, but in the end he is a dev, and he is going to swallow the anger that exists against the other devs. Don't blame him. It's not his fault the rest of the team is so so so wrong. He cannot make the changes alone.

Years ago, we told the devs that the nerfs to the casters were excessive, that they were going to ruin casters, that they should not do nerfs at the same time as buffing the martials, that their nerfs were also impacting the weak casters at the same time as the strong casters. They didn't listen to us, and we have been in an unsustainably weak position for years. Casters are rejected in raids because they are useless there. The casters are totally outclassed in r10. There are many casual/new/medium players who have even a hard time reaching workable DC on elite because to be proficient with a caster you need to equip much more than with a martial one.

If the devs don't understand the source of so much frustration, they will never be able to fix the problem, and people will continue to get more and more frustrated and angrier. It's a vicious circle.

First time I disagree with you. I'm firmly convinced devs are VERY well aware of how much casters sucks and they've known it for a long time.

Keep in mind they have tools to gather data and know exactly how many players there are and what classes are being played and at what level range. Sorry but considering how many of casters utilities/powers and abilities have been moved to melee and ranged without getting anything in return and being rendered almost completely obsolete, well....It's not something that happens in an update or two and by accident.

I'm calling it publicly, devs are deliberately shunning casters. If it's out of sheer hatred for the classes or unwillingness to do some drastic changes and work hard, that is another matter.
 

Lazuli

Well-known member
First time I disagree with you. I'm firmly convinced devs are VERY well aware of how much casters sucks and they've known it for a long time.

Keep in mind they have tools to gather data and know exactly how many players there are and what classes are being played and at what level range. Sorry but considering how much of casters utilities and abilities have been moved to melee and ranged without getting anything in return and being rendered almost completely obsolete, well....It's not something that happens in an update or two and by accident.

I'm calling it publicly, devs are deliberately shunning casters. If it's out of sheer hatred for the classes or unwillingness to do some drastic changes and work hard, that is another matter.
Having tools to collect data and using them is a very different matter. For a long time, the developers have demonstrated their ignorance of the game's reality.

Should they be informed? Yes, it's their job. Have they shown that they aren't? Also yes.

Or have they feigned ignorance because they don't care about the casters? Perhaps, but I don't see the point in angering half the game's population; it's only costing them money.

Yes, it's infuriating how many caster spells and abilities have been given to martial classes, while casters have only received nerfs and been forgotten. It's outrageous. The caster role has been completely destroyed, and in return, we get inefficient DPS, bloated gear that's much more expensive than martial gear, and now a DC increase that's basically cosmetic. Oh well. They know what they're doing.

I'm not going to get angry anymore. If necessary, there are other games. My patience has held out for years and years, but it has reached its limit.
 

DBZ

Well-known member
Every Cannith Essence crafted piece you use won't have sun/moon slots or any other set stats. The only decent one is the GoMF but its complementary item will be outclassed with this update, yet we'll still need to slot it because its set has no representation in the sun/gem system.

This is a terrible situation for casters.

They're basically telling us: buy the new xpack, or change your caster to martial.
That writings been on the wall since the epic strike pass 3 years ago now and they only get worse while on the other side of things
 

Aristis

Well-known member
Thanks for the adjustments. I will still continue not playing my favorite classes as long as the core issues are not properly addressed.

This mainly includes Archmage, Caster Favoured Soul, and Swashbuckler. I love hybrid an universalist classes because they offer flexibility and the ability to fulfill multiple roles. That has always been the appeal for me.

Instead of versatile all-rounders, you can now only build poor specialists with them. The Swashbuckler basically cannot do anything anymore except die in raids when trying to fulfill its DPS role or it gets reduced to a 3 level splash just for the Swashbuckler toggles because going deep into the tree simply is not worth it. In practice, a pure Swashbuckler is a universalist hybrid that ends up doing neither DPS, survivability nor casting well enough to matter. Spellsinger and Stormsinger are good so. The Favoured Soul is still somewhat okay but it is no longer a real hybrid. Either you go full casting and end up as a worse Cleric or you go melee DPS and there is not much more to say about that. "Real" Casting essentially plays no meaningful role in that setup anymore. Spells like Greater Command or Cometfall might as well be removed from the game because Divine casters do not really use them in any meaningful way anymore.

I get the feeling that more and more emphasis is being placed on statistics, asking questions like why a class is played less or what needs to be done to make it more appealing or more frequently chosen instead of focusing on the soul and identity of the class itself. As a result more and more variants and archetypes were introduced such as the Stormsinger or the Dragonlord.

And now to the Archmage

Full stop. Not much more needs to be said.

The Barbarian is another good example for me. I used to love playing it because it genuinely felt like adrenaline. Fights were close risky and exciting. With the Constitution bonus from Rage you could just barely carry soul stones back to the shrine only to drop dead right after. That had character.

Today however the Barbarian just gets pampered. It plays like a pure endurance monster. The adrenaline the risk and the original identity of the class are gone.

My impression is that the soul of classes is increasingly being lost. And it does not help when balance decisions are primarily driven by statistics for example when a Bard is played less or dies more often and this directly leads to design changes like the Stormsinger. I see the same pattern with the Dragonlord and even the iconic Fighter Duergar.

Classes should not be balanced purely around usage and death statistics. What matters more is what makes them unique what their identity is and what players originally loved about them.

Sorry for the chatty post I am just pissed.

And yes, it does have something to do with the DC boost, because three of my favorite classes are affected by it, and I’m simply using this as a way to highlight a more general underlying issue.

Note: what is not being played will also not appear in death statistics.
 
Last edited:

VinoeWhines

Well-known member
@Tonquin

If I were to completely revamp DC's...
  • While Lazuli would like to consolidate the schools, I'd go one further and have ALL DC's be based off of Highest of Concentration or Spellcraft rather than individual schools. Effectively this would be just like the ATR's skill based casting, which would scale up significantly better than having to gear up for each individual school. With the added benefit that this would be far easier for newer players to manage at all levels of play.
  • Revamp all Heroic spells to better scale into Epics, also while breathing new life into spells that don't currently have a purpose in the game. Which if you think about it, its more than half of the Wizards spell book is totally useless. Either because the game mechanics no longer support it, the base damage is too low, or doesn't scale with the player. (some are outright laughable, they're that bad)
  • Either remove the R7 Nerf's entirely or have them apply to all classes equally.
  • Remove caster spells from non-caster SLA's, so casters can regain their relevance. That is unless its SSG's goal to fully replace casters with Dragonlords...
  • Allow for non-boss death immunities to be temporarily stripped or dispelled. Otherwise whats the point of DC casting if half the mobs are completely immune and can not be de-buffed or stripped.
  • Make DC casting somewhat relevant in Raids and Boss fights by adding Boss vulnerabilities to DC based spells and de-buffs.
The DCs based off of skills could maybe be something like how Monks would sit and Meditate to regain Ki.



Concentration
ConcentrationYesConstitutionPassiveInner FocusAllows you a chance to continue casting a spell after being damaged or otherwise interrupted. Allows monks to retain Ki. At over (50?) Concentration. For every second you stand still you gain +2 to All Spell DCs up to 5 times. Last for 10 seconds after or removed upon getting hit.


Spellcraft
SpellcraftYesIntelligencePassiveSpellsightAdds 1 point of Spell Power per point of skill with following damage types: Acid, Cold, Electric, Fire, Force and Light. Add .25(?) in Spell Penetration per 2 points spent.


other skills:
Perform and such can be also factored in for other Class Casting.

How about the devs half the removal of the R7+ Nerf with this pass and see how that can push more relevancy when in upper Reapers.
I would change the GH augments to +2 to All DCs until maybe the new raid comes out and there is a chance for gear to drop that as of now on Live there is no way to make up the +2 DC if players are using level 28-30 gear still and are benefiting from the +2 GH augments now and wont if it gets removed.
 

Aristis

Well-known member
Why can’t we simply add a debuff to all spells in the spellbook that reduces enemy saving throws against the corresponding school or for more diversity (even better) to all other schools? For example, by 1 or 2 (max 10). That way, hybrid builds would need to cast more frequently, and specialization would be rewarded. It would also potentially make mana management more interesting again. If the d20 system has gotten out of hand, this could, in my opinion, help address the problem.
 
Last edited:

Smokewolf

Frequently banned member.
Why can’t we simply add a debuff to all spells in the spellbook that reduces enemy saving throws against the corresponding school when the enemy fails its save? For example, by 1 (max 10). That way, hybrid builds would need to cast more frequently, and specialization would be rewarded. It would also potentially make mana management more interesting again. If the d20 system has gotten out of hand, this could, in my opinion, help address the problem.
Debuffs are only relevant t other spell casters, and mean have little benefit for physical DPS. At least the way debuffs currently work, their kinda useless in most end game situations and mobs jut die to fast.
 

Aristis

Well-known member
Debuffs are only relevant t other spell casters, and mean have little benefit for physical DPS. At least the way debuffs currently work, their kinda useless in most end game situations and mobs jut die to fast.
true. But we need some benefit from failing saves. D20 ist getting our of hands.
 

justin credible

Well-known member
Why can’t we simply add a debuff to all spells in the spellbook that reduces enemy saving throws against the corresponding school when the enemy fails its save by -1 or for more diversity (even better) to all other schools by -1? For example, by 1 (max 10). That way, hybrid builds would need to cast more frequently, and specialization would be rewarded. It would also potentially make mana management more interesting again. If the d20 system has gotten out of hand, this could, in my opinion, help address the problem.
so like if a pale master trys to kill a mob with finger of death, that one mob has a penalty of -1 to saves against necromancy spells, so the wizard just waits another 8 seconds for the cooldown to expire and try again
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top