U82 Preview 1 - Enhancement Changes (and one new Feat!)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Diaari

Well-known member
The Resolute Blade: +1 Competence Bonus to Critical Threat Range while Single Weapon Fighting. Rank 2: +1 Competence Bonus to Critical Multiplier while Single Weapon Fighting.

Any chance of getting competence HP added to this as well? I was just looking at the new changes to see if there was any interesting combination of swashbuckling alchemist with T5 or capstone Harper Agent. Not everything needs to be Vistani Knife Fighter, but this just doesn't seem competitive.
 

Lotoc

Well-known member
Dragon Lord:
  • Dragon's Roar now uses a significantly shorter cone.
  • Dragon's Roar no longer affects creatures who are unaffected by Greater Shout; this includes Undead, Elementals, Oozes, etc.
    • Notes: Players feel that Dragon's Roar has singlehandedly obsoleted some forms of casters; it needs to change. This allows it to still be a powerful tool for Dragon Lord Fighters, just at closer range and not quite as universal in all content.
main point of feedback I'd give here is with the cone being around Touch range it is really horrible using anything frontal only with touch range (try actually using the single target inflicts on a cleric)
Dragon's Roar with the reduced range would be entirely healthy if it were a circular aoe around the character rather than a cone.
 

Blacksun

Well-known member
  • Morningstar and Warhammer are now considered hand-and-a-half weapons, benefiting from Strikethrough and the Two Handed Fighting feats in the same ways Bastard Sword and Dwarven Waraxe do.

Can Morningstar look bigger to match the change?
 

Epicsoul

Lava Divers Assistant to the Regional Manager
Melee Weapons:
  • Morningstar and Warhammer are now considered hand-and-a-half weapons, benefiting from Strikethrough and the Two Handed Fighting feats in the same ways Bastard Sword and Dwarven Waraxe do.
  • Notes: We're on the fence about Warhammers with this one, but want to see it play out in this preview before making a final decision. This isn't an enhancement or feat changes, it's here as it's relevant to Battle Engineer especially.
@SteelStar - If the team decides to change Warhammers to hand 1/2 weapons, would you consider adding a "+5% Strikethrough chance while wielding a Warhammer." to the Dwarven Weapon Training's 'Pick and Hammer Training' line for both Dwarves and Duergar? It would make sense and match the Dwarven Axes version.
 

seph1roth5

Well-known member
main point of feedback I'd give here is with the cone being around Touch range it is really horrible using anything frontal only with touch range (try actually using the single target inflicts on a cleric)
Dragon's Roar with the reduced range would be entirely healthy if it were a circular aoe around the character rather than a cone.
It would have to be a better range still, instead of just hitting monsters literally touching you in a 360. Just give it the burst of...well bursts.
 

Ying

5000+ hours played
Deepwood Stalker (DWS) AP costs are too high:

To obtain DWS Tier 5 abilities and the capstone, it requires 42 AP rather than 41 for most other trees. Also, to obtain all the Tier 4 abilities requires 31 AP. That brings all Tier 4+5 abilities and the capstone cost to 43 AP.

DWS is also the most AP intensive bow/ranged tree at 66 AP. Compare to Horizon Walker at 56 AP and Ninja Spy at 55 AP (disregard the wiki, it has old T5 AP values).

With that in mind, I think it’s reasonable to trim the DWS T5 ability costs from 2 AP each to 1 AP each. Comparing DWS T5 abilities to other trees:

Improved Archer’s Focus (2 AP) compare to:
1 AP Ninja Spy Improved Archer’s Focus (also provides 10 RP like DWS)

Devastating Shot (2 AP) compare to:
1 AP Ninja Spy Touch of Death
1 AP Ninja Spy Shadow Double
1 AP Horizon Walker Power Shot

Strikes Like Lightning (2 AP) compare to:
1 AP Horizon Walker Misty Step

Heavy Draw (2 AP) compare to other Competence Critical Multi/Threat:
1 AP Horizon Walker Feywild Attunement
1 AP Ninja Spy Deadly Striker

Extra Favored Enemy (2 AP) compare to:
1 AP Falconry FE: Animal (Tier 1)
1 AP Vistani FE: Undead (Tier 1)

Implementing those reductions would bring the total tree AP cost to 61. A little bit more trimming to bring it inline with total AP compared to Ninja Spy and Horizon Walker:

Aimed Shot 2 AP -> 1 AP. Compare to Horizon Walker’s Hunter’s Focus passive every 6 sec for 1 AP.

Empathic Healing 2 AP per rank -> 1 AP per rank. Use is already gated by Wild Empathy charges.

Survivalist III 2 AP -> 1 AP. This also reduces the Tier 4 total AP cost from 31 to 30.

If all of these were implemented, it would bring the total AP cost to 57 vs Ninja Spy’s 55 and Horizon Walker’s 56.
 

Kitty2Meow

Well-known member
Harper Agent
  • T2 Heroic Companion is removed, and replaced with Multiselector: Harper Lore I: (2AP)
    • Harper Weapon Training: +1 to Attack and Damage while Single Weapon Fighting.
    • Harper Spell Training: +2% Spell Crit Damage with Force/Physical, Sonic, Light, and Good spells
  • T3 Highly Skilled is removed, and replaced with Multiselector: Harper Lore II: (2AP)
    • Harper Weapon Training: +1 to Attack and Damage while Single Weapon Fighting.
    • Harper Spell Training: +2% Spell Crit Damage with Force/Physical, Sonic, Light, and Good spells
  • T4 Throat Dagger’s cooldown changes to 18/15/12 seconds.
  • T4 Throat Dagger is now a multiselector with Silencing Strike: Melee Attack: 20/30/50% Damage: Damaged non-boss enemies cannot cast spells for 6 seconds. Cooldown: 18/15/12 seconds.
  • New T5: Multiselector:
    • The Resolute Blade: +1 Competence Bonus to Critical Threat Range while Single Weapon Fighting. Rank 2: +1 Competence Bonus to Critical Multiplier while Single Weapon Fighting.
    • The Harp’s Magic: +2% Spell Crit Damage with Force/Physical, Sonic, Light, and Good spells. Rank 2: An additional +2% Spell Crit Damage with Force/Physical, Sonic, Light, and Good spells
  • Notes: This gives Harper a little more identity, as well as more avenues for some builds to climb higher in the tree. T5 may not be the most powerful set of T5s, but shouldn’t just be strictly worse than class trees. This ought to give some strong options to SWF builds throughout the game.
@SteelStar

Suggestion: Since Core 6 gives +2 to all Ability Scores, might as well change Core 2, Core 4, Tier 3, and Tier 4 to a choice of all Ability Scores, if you want to give more incentives to melee and ranged to use this tree.
 
Last edited:

Kitty2Meow

Well-known member
Hello!

Here are a few changes planned for this Balance Pass. In looking at this new feat and changes to Enhancements, we are looking to boost some trees and styles that need some love while bringing down a few over-performing abilities.
@SteelStar

If Bard's Swashbuckler Tree ever be touched, please update the following,
Tier 3: Sword Dance (2AP/4AP/6AP) is too expensive and not too useful for nowadays game play.
Suggestion:
Sword Dance - Single Rank (2AP):
While Swashbuckling, when enemies miss you in combat, you deal 1d8 per character level (or 1d12 per caster level) of Sonic Damage. The Sonic damage scales with Spell Power.

Tier 5: Second Skin (1AP/2AP/3AP) is too expensive for today standard when comparing to other trees.
Suggestion:
Second Skin - Single Rank (2AP)
While Swashbuckling, +6 to your Reflex Saves and +6 to the Max Dex Bonus of your Armor. Rank 3: +20% Competence bonus to Hit Points.
 
Last edited:

Aklubra

Active member
Shield Combat II (Core 4) gains “While wielding a Shield, you gain a +1 Competence Bonus to Critical Multiplier”.
  • Fighter Vanguard players are frustrated that they must go mega deep into Kensei to get any Crit options with their weapons, and literally can’t get some at all if they go T5 Vanguard. This opens up options.
I am against giving another "+1 Competence Bonus to Critical Multiplier" to fighters. I don't see why someone wouldn't want to take both the cores from Kensei and the cores from Vanguard as an offensive fighter using a shield. And as we all know, those Competence Bonus don't stack. I hate having repeated Competence Bonuses in my build, it's ugly. Who in Khyber are those "frustraded Fighter Vanguard players"?!
 

Shear-buckler

Master of reactions
Dragon Lord:
  • Dragon's Roar now uses a significantly shorter cone.
  • Dragon's Roar no longer affects creatures who are unaffected by Greater Shout; this includes Undead, Elementals, Oozes, etc.
    • Notes: Players feel that Dragon's Roar has singlehandedly obsoleted some forms of casters; it needs to change. This allows it to still be a powerful tool for Dragon Lord Fighters, just at closer range and not quite as universal in all content.
I missed the first part... That is a big mistake. Making it not work on all enemies is enough. A small cone will make it feel very bad to use.
 

f1b041b3

Well-known member
The ones who want to play pure tank with SD and Vanguard. Probably also some multiclasses.
Yeah, it's the same reason they put it in the Mindcleaver tree despite the forced level of fighter. Not everyone wants to feel forced into dipping kensei.
 

Aklubra

Active member
New Feat:
  • Lock In
    • Included automatically with Improved Two Handed Fighting and Two Handed Specialty
    • Active: (Requires you to be using a Two Handed Weapon and not be in Animal form to activate. Hand and a Half does not count.) For 20 seconds, you cannot benefit from Strikethrough. For the duration, you gain Melee Power equal to 50% of your Strikethrough. This effect ends early if you switch to a style or weapons that do not meet the requirements. 60 second cooldown.
      • Notes: Two Handed Fighting builds are doing well against large packs of mobs, but they're significantly behind when dealing with Bosses and larger targets, to the point where we're hearing some THF builds are being excluded from Raids. This gives them significantly more ability to deal with single targets, while not at 100% uptime. Exact numbers of MP/Strikethrough ratio are a work in progress.
I have an idea:

Another New Feat to pair up with Lock In:
  • Focused Swings
    • Included automatically with Greater Two Handed Fighting and Two Handed Specialty
    • Active: (Requires you to be using a Hand and a Half Weapon or be in a Bear form to activate. Warhammers do not count.) For 20 seconds, Hand and a Half and Bear forms lose 75% of their strikethrough. For the duration, you gain Melee Power equal to 50% of your new total Strikethrough. This effect ends early if you switch to a style or weapons that do not meet the requirements. 60 second cooldown.
      • Notes: Unlike Lock In, Focused Swings don't make you unable to benefit from strikethrough, but reduced it a lot instead, and add a bonus to melee power based on the new quantity. Hand and a Half (and Bear builds using any two handed weapon) will gain 50% less melee power with this, as well as lose 3/4 of their strikethrough. It is a significantly weaker version of Lock In because Hand and a Half still get the benefit of using shields for defense. I added Focused Swings to Greater Two Handed Fighting to make it a bit less desirable than Lock in (and because single-target damage only matters in Epic and Legendary levels anyway. In case the bear is using a Two Handed Weapon they still get a lower bonus than the one from Lock In, but keep strikingthrough a bit to fit the "Bear theme". Warhammens will probably get too strong becoming Two Handed Weapons so I excluded them entirely from Focused Swings (It's probably hard to use a Warhammer to Strikethrough IRL anyway). Exact numbers of MP/Strikethrough/Melee Power ratio can be adjusted by the Devs (and if they figure out that Warhammens need more buffs/nerfs, maybe they can change the bonuses to Warhammers in Knight Training too).

Edit: I completely forgot Bear Builds don't use THF feats. *facepalm* OK, here is an updated version:

  • Focused Swings
    • Included automatically with Greater Two Handed Fighting, Two Handed Specialty and Natural Fighting.
    • Active: (Requires BAB(6) to activate. Requires you to be using a Hand and a Half Weapon or be in a Bear form to activate. Warhammers (and Morningstars?) do not count.) For 20 seconds, Hand and a Half and Bear forms lose 75% of their strikethrough. For the duration, you gain Melee Power equal to 50% of your new total Strikethrough. This effect ends early if you switch to a style or weapons that do not meet the requirements. 60 second cooldown.
      • Notes: Unlike Lock In, Focused Swings don't make you unable to benefit from strikethrough, but reduced it a lot instead, and add a bonus to melee power based on the new quantity. Hand and a Half (and Bear builds using any weapon) will gain 50% less melee power with this, as well as lose 3/4 of their strikethrough. It is a significantly weaker version of Lock In because Hand and a Half still get the benefit of using shields for defense. I added Focused Swings to Greater Two Handed Fighting to make it a bit less desirable than Lock in (and because single-target damage only matters in Epic and Legendary levels anyway. In case the bear is using a Two Handed Weapon they still get a lower bonus than the one from Lock In, but keep strikingthrough a bit to fit the "Bear theme". Warhammens (and Morningstars?) will probably get too strong becoming Two Handed Weapons so I excluded them entirely from Focused Swings (It's probably hard to use a Warhammer(/Morningstar?) to Strikethrough IRL anyway). Exact numbers of MP/Strikethrough/Melee Power ratio can be adjusted by the Devs (and if they figure out that Warhammens (and Morningstars?) need more buffs/nerfs, maybe they can change the bonuses to Warhammers (and Morningstars?) in Knight Training too). Also: if the Devs realize Wolf forms need some buff to go with that, I suggest we add a small attack speed buff while in a Wolf form somewhere somehow (specially for pure druids since people don't like Nature Warrior Core 6 because it's weaker than other options).
 
Last edited:

Arthol

Well-known member
So, Vanguard, when was I was playing as paladin like others I never took it to T5 but instead when T5 into KoTC. Need to find a medium ground between fighters concerns and things not stacking with Holy sword as others have said. The viability of bashing is really hampered by the 1 second cooldown.

Personally, the lack of insightful Sheild bashing in combination with Normal Sheild bashing on the evolved Oozing hunger shields was kind of a take back. when compared to its Defiled Azure counterpart. Ive always wondered why we didn’t get a Ruby augment allowing us to add Bashing to any shield we so desire or even a series of augments specifically for shields with choice of offensive or defensive options.
 

Taleisin

Well-known member
I missed the first part... That is a big mistake. Making it not work on all enemies is enough. A small cone will make it feel very bad to use.
I played my DL this past weekend and this is exactly what I thought. Reducing the range in addition to the types of monsters is too much. Reducing the monsters seems entirely sufficient. If the cone goes away then so does Dragonlord sadly. It is THE cool thing about the class that differentiates it from regular fighter.
 

Lotoc

Well-known member
I have an idea:

Another New Feat to pair up with Lock In:
  • Focused Swings
    • Included automatically with Greater Two Handed Fighting and Two Handed Specialty
    • Active: (Requires you to be using a Hand and a Half Weapon or be in a Bear form to activate. Warhammers do not count.) For 20 seconds, Hand and a Half and Bear forms lose 75% of their strikethrough. For the duration, you gain Melee Power equal to 50% of your new total Strikethrough. This effect ends early if you switch to a style or weapons that do not meet the requirements. 60 second cooldown.
      • Notes: Unlike Lock In, Focused Swings don't make you unable to benefit from strikethrough, but reduced it a lot instead, and add a bonus to melee power based on the new quantity. Hand and a Half (and Bear builds using any two handed weapon) will gain 50% less melee power with this, as well as lose 3/4 of their strikethrough. It is a significantly weaker version of Lock In because Hand and a Half still get the benefit of using shields for defense. I added Focused Swings to Greater Two Handed Fighting to make it a bit less desirable than Lock in (and because single-target damage only matters in Epic and Legendary levels anyway. In case the bear is using a Two Handed Weapon they still get a lower bonus than the one from Lock In, but keep strikingthrough a bit to fit the "Bear theme". Warhammens will probably get too strong becoming Two Handed Weapons so I excluded them entirely from Focused Swings (It's probably hard to use a Warhammer to Strikethrough IRL anyway). Exact numbers of MP/Strikethrough/Melee Power ratio can be adjusted by the Devs (and if they figure out that Warhammens need more buffs/nerfs, maybe they can change the bonuses to Warhammers in Knight Training too).

Edit: I completely forgot Bear Builds don't use THF feats. *facepalm* OK, here is an updated version:

  • Focused Swings
    • Included automatically with Greater Two Handed Fighting, Two Handed Specialty and Natural Fighting.
    • Active: (Requires BAB(6) to activate. Requires you to be using a Hand and a Half Weapon or be in a Bear form to activate. Warhammers (and Morningstars?) do not count.) For 20 seconds, Hand and a Half and Bear forms lose 75% of their strikethrough. For the duration, you gain Melee Power equal to 50% of your new total Strikethrough. This effect ends early if you switch to a style or weapons that do not meet the requirements. 60 second cooldown.
      • Notes: Unlike Lock In, Focused Swings don't make you unable to benefit from strikethrough, but reduced it a lot instead, and add a bonus to melee power based on the new quantity. Hand and a Half (and Bear builds using any weapon) will gain 50% less melee power with this, as well as lose 3/4 of their strikethrough. It is a significantly weaker version of Lock In because Hand and a Half still get the benefit of using shields for defense. I added Focused Swings to Greater Two Handed Fighting to make it a bit less desirable than Lock in (and because single-target damage only matters in Epic and Legendary levels anyway. In case the bear is using a Two Handed Weapon they still get a lower bonus than the one from Lock In, but keep strikingthrough a bit to fit the "Bear theme". Warhammens (and Morningstars?) will probably get too strong becoming Two Handed Weapons so I excluded them entirely from Focused Swings (It's probably hard to use a Warhammer(/Morningstar?) to Strikethrough IRL anyway). Exact numbers of MP/Strikethrough/Melee Power ratio can be adjusted by the Devs (and if they figure out that Warhammens (and Morningstars?) need more buffs/nerfs, maybe they can change the bonuses to Warhammers (and Morningstars?) in Knight Training too). Also: if the Devs realize Wolf forms need some buff to go with that, I suggest we add a small attack speed buff while in a Wolf form somewhere somehow (specially for pure druids since people don't like Nature Warrior Core 6 because it's weaker than other options).
Look I know you want the funny hand and a half swf builds to get something besides just having the best weapon type in the game added but the entire point of lock in's design was that thf is hot garbage compared to swf and twf in a game with actually powerful aoe active attacks and an extreme focus on single target dps because all the AoE is more than enough.

Giving it to swf in any form just undermines the attempt to address the problem.

Also I imagine a big reason it isn't going to natural fighting is because Wolf Form is effectively SWF with a twohander (doesn't get strikethough) and Bear Form is THF without the clunky animations (2h sunder is an abomination of animation time) and there's the question of whether you could activate Lock in in bear form and switch to wolf, because doing so doesn't take you out of natural fighting stance and just changes your bonuses.
 

Anyes_Eristan

Active member
We're not, it's just a different sound-based CC effect, which made it a useful comparison point for immunities specifically.
It really doesn't make any CC obsolete, as you say, it just helps when there isn't a CC caster around. Caster CC is very long range, they have stronger AOE, and instakill from a distance. This double nerf is rough. Maybe if the immunities are enacted but not the cone size, then it will provide balance, but as is, it will basically be a single-target CC because of the hard-target requirement, and only work on few mobs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top