U82 Preview 1 - Monster DR Rework

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vlyxnol

Active member
I wanted to throw my own voice into this one.

In premise, I am in favour of making DR significant again, I do look back fondly on the days of having several DR beaters in my bag and switching between them as necessary.

In reality however, the sentient weapon system just completely flies in the face of this concept in its entirety. The game just is not capable of supporting weapon swapping in this way in any reasonable fashion at this time. If you want to implement DR like this, you first need to divorce sentient jewels from weapons. Either phase them out entirely, or give sentient jewels their own equipment slots where they just automatically apply to whatever weapon you have equipped at the time. Do this and I will be in support of the change, without that, this is just not a reasonable design direction.

*edit* If you were to go ahead with this change as conceptualized, since weapon swapping is not a reasonable course of action at end game, you would be generating very obnoxious and unfun player behaviours such as having to frequently respec your EDs or enhancement trees based on what raid or quest you are about to run next to acquire your necessary DR from those sources independent of weapon swapping.
 

l_remmie

Well-known member
Because the players who need this info havent killed 10,000 demons or 35 unique varietions of a demons/plants/etc many of which dont exist until epics in order to actually see that information? If so then yes, it is funny.
Go have a look at dandonk's post record why it's so funn ;)
 

dogfacegrimlin

Mad Kobold Scientist
So for anyone that's played 5e, the cantrips and the DR bypass is probably heavily related to that playstyle they are introducing, so onto DR. This feeds the idea that the community might go into party community again and a rise in artificers that take in spells like the metalline and align coating weapons to support party composition when the need arises. Granted that the party probably have to research what monsters in each dungeon is DR to, or we can get implement to check inspect a creature for monster info (QoL). The major downside of course is DR bypass for slashing piercing and bludgeoning to be simultaneous, unless that will be something introduced into filligree's or an item enchantment.
 

Torm

Well-known member
This is an unnecessary and annoying change, I'm respeccing my main over the weekend now since you didn't consider how much farming is needed to compensate for appropriate weapons across all builds to mitigate this... I was actually enjoying playing my character when I had finished getting all my new past lives from Terror of Demogorgon. But again, that experience is completely ruined now since I'm now locked into races that use bastard swords again instead of dwarven axes because the itemization for DR breakers for dwarven axes is atrocious. And I'm not going to count on the "maybe weapons" that are Warhammer and Morningstar since those were both stated as "tentative" with "zero guarantees".
 

l_remmie

Well-known member
I actually believe this makes the game easier for new players since this is replacing the flat DR, not adding an extra penalty. High enough flat DR is effectively immunity, but 25% or 50% is never immunity.

Some newbie hitting for 30 damage on Dread Zombies in Delera's Tomb would see 15 of their damage be eaten by DR/Slashing.
With the proposed change said newbie would actually hit for 30*0.75 = 22.5 damage, a 50% increase compared to before change.
With 60 damage hit, you do the same damage whether it's flat 15 or 25% reduction.

Dread Zombies have higher DR than most, but also higher hp. They are just annoying meatbags regardless of if you bypass the DR or not.
Gargoyle DR (while healing up) going to percentage might even help advanced characters during leveling process.

---

The biggest problem here are all the monsters that have a TINY DR for something, and what constitutes TINY increases as quest levels increase.

Flat DR 5 is significant for a newbie in Korthos but once that same character on their first life is in legendary levels it's inconsequential, so if nothing else this will make things consistent. However I personally feel that loses some flavor though - those dread zombies won't be higher DR zombies anymore, only higher hp zombies. Iron Golems have as much DR as Steel Golems. Random Barbarian class pirate with DR 1/- now reduces damage as much as those others?

---

Made a new character just to test..
Heyton's Rest zombies and skeletons have a DR 5 and a 18str sword/board fighter has 1d8+5 damage, +1 fire damage (first AP from Grotto goes into Vanguard for +1 to hit/dam while wielding a shield). Flat 5 DR is going to be larger than a 25% reduction here, even if the fighter was using a 2h sword with 2d6+6+1 damage, and the quest was doable solo on elite with a few starter healing potions (for my run, I used 5, which is all the ones I found from boxes in Grotto).

Even for new players, the time where DR5 matters is infinitesimal. They would be annoyed for a quest or two and then get a hammer or a sword.
Even though it is not technically wrong, it simply is to tiny a case to factor in.
New players will be the ones struggling to get the right equipment and the right knowledge. And instead of doing roughly 10-20% less damage against their first devil, mind flayer or earth elemental, they would do 50% less.

Taking double the time to kill something isn't nearly as bad when you kill everything from 1 to 2 seconds but when you kill everything from 5 to 10 seconds it adds up really quick.
 

Jack Jarvis Esquire

Well-known member
And you are an extreme exception. Just because you don't get wet doesn't mean it's not raining.
I'm not sure I am though. Iirc THF was a main wep, then a crystal maul for oozes, and a metaline with good slotted for DR when needed. Just pretty basic stuff IMO.

Point is though if an eejit like me can do it, most anyone can. 🤣
 
We all will need more Inv Space, more quivers and stay longer in pot eating quests. That sounds, like they need desperatly money, but sry, your last adventure pack, was the first pack i didn´t bought, since 20( What an embaressing event, fck 50 years d&d, i paid u 20 years) years. As u can hear, it is not only update 82 that make me sad about ddo, but my abo end this year in december and no more money from me. By the way, it is cause US foreign policy too. No tax money for the orange *+#*&%$
 

Torm

Well-known member
I'm not sure I am though. Iirc THF was a main wep, then a crystal maul for oozes, and a metaline with good slotted for DR when needed. Just pretty basic stuff IMO.

Point is though if an eejit like me can do it, most anyone can. 🤣
Yes, all these are possible. But it is desirable or what a majority of what players want? I highly doubt it. Maxing out a sentient weapon costs money/time. Changing to a different set of weapons for a build costs money/time. Regearing an entire toon takes a *VERY* long time and is fraught with months/years of frustration, peril and acute distrust for when they drop changes like these.
 

Jack Jarvis Esquire

Well-known member
Well of course is not what most people want. 👍 Nobody likes nerfs after all. Doesn't mean it's not the right thing to do.

This isn't a democracy, if it were, self interest would mean pretty much no nerfs at all. 👍
 

Frieling Slyhand

Well-known member
To combat the DR, we will have to change weapons types, not just a case of making a different weapon type and fill it with sentience. One way to help, will be to get rid of heroic feats improved critical slashing\piercing\bludgening and replace it with improved critical(that applys to all) Otherwise we are giving up what well could be 25% damage, by losing the crit profile to these individual feats, just to beat DR for an extra 25% damage. Also as far as i know, there are alignment augments we can use, but no slashing\piercing\bludgening augments, these have to be added, or in essence, you are just adding 25% HP to mobs and raid bosses that already have 10 million+ hp. Dont add extra feats for these bypasses as certain classes are feat starved anyways
These are good suggestions:
1. More dr by pass augments for types that currently do not have them.
2. One crit feat rather than different crit feats for each unique damage type.
 
Last edited:

SandeebaRezYouriOfSarlona

Well-known member
That's not quite what they are doing. Under the hood they are taking an overly complex system, that can be handled by other systems that are already in the game and are simpler for new platyers to understand, and tweeking it so it works differently but becomes even more complex. I know people don't like HP inflation but reducing the damage you do to a monster by 50% is no different to doubling it's HP.

Edit: Two systems can work in the same way but one can still be easier for people to "get". TT D&D uses a d20+Bonus vs DC system because it means high rolls are good. Other systems use a roll under skill system. Both can be essentially numerically the same but people on avarage tend to find roll high systems easier to intuit.
I don't think you quite understand what DR used to be. It wasn't a system that had to be programed. It was a system that was emergent from chosen value ranges.

No programming required, just thoughtful choices of numbers to get a desired result. It's not like making it required a system to be built into the game. It was already there in the source material and no programming required to implement. Nor is any programming required to make it work again, this the idea of "systems already in place" is irrelevant as this is not asking for new systems to be developed and programmed.

As for "simpler for new players to understand," well I am sick and tired of that excuse for dumbing everything down to toddler level, and not just DnD, but many of the big company things being put out are dumbing things down.

3.0 was plenty easy to understand for new players, and if a person is so incredibly stupid they can't handle the basics of DDO at it's most complex mechanics relevant to level 1 characters, then maybe they shouldn't be playing this game at all. You cannot have a great game with significant depth if the whole thing is dumbed down to the point of being suitable for toddlers. I'm here for DnD, not Teletubbies. And there is nothing wrong with having complex games for adults. Not everything needs to be toddler accessible. But honestly, the scariest part of this is that anyone actually believes DDO ever needed to be simplified. It does not and never has. DDO is not a complex game, it has only moderate-light complexity.

Presentation updates for understanding, sure I can see that sometimes, but that doesn't require simplifying things.
 

The Being

Well-known member
I'm not sure I am though. Iirc THF was a main wep, then a crystal maul for oozes, and a metaline with good slotted for DR when needed. Just pretty basic stuff IMO.

Point is though if an eejit like me can do it, most anyone can. 🤣

I even recall putting an empty weapon set on my hotbars so I could punch slimes unarmed (and handwraps took damage for a short while!).
 

Zuldar

Well-known member
What if we approach this from a different angle. Keep the damage reduction and instead reduce some of the HP bloat for mobs with DR. If you're not breaking DR than it would feel roughly the same but if you do break it you get rewarded with an easier enemy
 

Tumideon

Founder
If 28 pages of replies and counting isn't enough reason to delay or rollback this crap, idk what is...

Prepare for Unforeseen Consequences, we already have PRR/MRR and AC bloat where on low-skulls at endgame without a very specific build you can end up grazing new content on 2-5, the 10-year old LGS debuffs haven't scaled (or been updated, still reused), and now DR is getting cranked up to ludicrous amounts atop of all that.

Not to mention how energy immunity, resistance, and absorption work - all of which is completely opaque to the end-user. I'm all for emergent design and modernization, but not like this.

And for what may be considered hot wind, I think 50% of the folks across reddit, YT, the forums, and the other boards are probably serious they're gonna dip out. All it'll take is a few bad quarters and DDO will go the way of other mid-2000s MMOs and be closed down, and no amount of pcaps will RE this thing.
 

Shear-buckler

Master of reactions
What if we approach this from a different angle. Keep the damage reduction and instead reduce some of the HP bloat for mobs with DR. If you're not breaking DR than it would feel roughly the same but if you do break it you get rewarded with an easier enemy
No. The game is already too easy and mobs die too fast. That the new DR system somewhat improves that is good, but the problem is that it will affect the wrong players most and create a hassle we already tried and moved away from.
 

Wizenmann

Member
I would love to see this change. Love that it would force us to collect weapons that are valuable for different situations. Love that it would make us switch to weapons without filigrees from time to time. Having a single weapon that is always the best one in every situation is anti-dnd from my perspective.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top