U82 Preview 3 - Summary of Changes since Preview 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dergex

Well-known member
I'm still really concerned and somewhat upset about how hard Great Crossbows have been hit and how non-viable Mechanic Rogues have become with these changes. With very few exceptions you're almost always better off going Ranger or Artificer when using a ranged weapon, Crossbows included.

I understand that balancing in the extreme end game is important, especially when you have people with an infinite number of past lives. I understand that people can create an absolute MONSTER of a character with the right combination of classes and items. But one thing I don't understand is why balancing has to sacrifice the low end of that spectrum for nonsense that happens at the highest end.

The last time I had a chance to check out these changes the Cantrips and spell changes felt absolutely amazing. It actually felt viable to play a caster through all of the levels, just like it does for a Warlock. Crossbow felt... rough on the other hand. The damage isn't high enough to warrant how slow they shoot and reload. Bows are just simply.. better in almost all circumstances.

Rogue Mechanic just feels.. bad. Their traps are clunky and expensive. Their progression is pretty flat. They are pretty much forced to dip into Inquisitive or Harper if they want to feel any sort of viability.

In comparison playing as a Deepwood Stalker felt pretty solid. Bows felt a bit smoother and the feat changes didn't hit as hard as I would have expected. Going into it as a Dark Hunter allowed me to completely ignore Rogue and Artificer while still being able to deal with traps fairly easily. I didn't mess around too much with Crossbow as a Deepwood Stalker as Bow just overall felt like a better weapon.

Artificer felt pretty fun to mess around with, having cantrips as an option made being a pure caster artificer much more attractive. Even without being a pure caster, being able to restore my own spell points to heal myself was really useful. Repeating Crossbows didn't feel TOO bad to use with Expanded Clip and all of the other changes, though the loss of Fusillade was definitely felt. Especially when dealing with groups of enemies.

If I had to offer any real feedback at the end of this it would be that Rogue needs some love. They've needed it for a while. Rogue Mechanic especially feels like it needs a lot just to become viable again.
 

Dergex

Well-known member
They are martials, why would they *rely on* mrr? And even that were so, defenses should have points.

MRR is increased as armor gets heavier and tanks are the kings of MRR. Those are martial characters.

This is increasing the cap, not increasing the base. It makes enough sense for them to have it.
 

SquireZed

Well-known member
SOME elitist people asked for it... At least make a real OFFICIAL POLL to get the players' opinions.

DDO is a PvE game, there is no need for a "difficult" endgame, especially for classic quests—and even more so considering that playing on R10 doesn't give any extra bonuses other than more Reaper XP, maybe some fun, and a greater waste of time. The higher the damage restriction, the less room there is for build diversity and FUN. Difficulty is what forces people to min-max and creates a "META" where everyone ends up running the exact same builds to keep up with that difficulty. If the difficulty were lower and a off-meta build could survive and perform well in R10, it would open the door to diversity, hybrid builds, more customization, utility builds, and so on.

Warframe, which is also a PvE game, understood that being overpowered and dominating the endgame isn't an issue—the whole point is to have FUN!!! Their team's primary goal is variety over perfect balance, operating on the belief that an item only becomes problematic when it renders every other option obsolete.

So my answer is: "NO, I didn't ask to do less damage in Reaper 10, and I'm pretty sure most players feel the exact same way." Awaiting an official DEV POLL. Thanks.
Polls would help, because people are a lot more likely to vote in a poll than to randomly chime in supporting something they assume is already set in stone.
 

Dergex

Well-known member
Polls would help, because people are a lot more likely to vote in a poll than to randomly chime in supporting something they assume is already set in stone.

Pretty sure a good compromise here would be for them to start working on things like Reaper 11+, with no additional bonuses but just additional challenge.
 

Monkey_Archer

Well-known member
Polls would help, because people are a lot more likely to vote in a poll than to randomly chime in supporting something they assume is already set in stone.
Polls don't help on issues such as these any more than forum comments... its still just going to be a slightly less small vocal minority that bother to vote as well.

Also, I don't think its elitist to ask for a difficulty setting to match the skill/challenge level that even a minority of higher skilled players are seeking. I think it would be more elitist to demand that only R10 caters to my personal preferences. R9 for the exact same game experience? what? do you think me a peasant?
 

Dergex

Well-known member
Polls don't help on issues such as these any more than forum comments... its still just going to be a slightly less small vocal minority that bother to vote as well.

Also, I don't think its elitist to ask for a difficulty setting to match the skill/challenge level that even a minority of higher skilled players are seeking. I think it would be more elitist to demand that only R10 caters to my personal preferences. R9 for the exact same game experience? what? do you think me a peasant?

More people respond to polls than forum posts. Especially when those polls are advertised in commonly visited locations.
 

Sorccadin

Well-known member
I mean... We lose of our current damage precisely 2.9% on r9 and 5.6% on r10 comparing it to right now.

Casters are actually getting hit way less here (actually gaining 0.1% on r9 and only losing 0.6% on r10), though some typing changes certainly reduce their numbers while new feats and abilities increase them in other ways. Honestly, as of now I haven't done the math, but it seems to me it's not really a bad thing for them.

As for asking for reaper to become harder - actually many many players want that. R10 in its current form poses very little threat to a party up to the task. I for one don't believe that the adjustments right now will really change that fact. However I'm also not asking for further reduction.

This actually just divides the player base further between those able to play the difficulty and those who aren't able to. Instead I think further reaper types across the difficulties can add far more interesting challenges - rather than increased difficulty by vertical changes (number tweaking) a more horizontal approach (broaden then potential challenges) just offers far more in the long term without a nessesary divide.

Ofc im not talking about raids here, that's just a whole different can of worms. Anyways, I like most changes and yet hope for some other improvements being made.

For me the master of feats and feat tax is a far more pressing matter than high reaper (as one can always somehow be resolved while the former actually makes building a character hard to impossible). The EPL change for me isn't anything I'm worried about for now - we also see a meaningful reduction in 34+ quests which is pretty much all of legendary. Also it opens up the potential for an AC rework in the future which to be fair would make a lot of sense.
 

Dergex

Well-known member
As for asking for reaper to become harder - actually many many players want that. R10 in its current form poses very little threat to a party up to the task. I for one don't believe that the adjustments right now will really change that fact. However I'm also not asking for further reduction.

Asking for harder content is completely acceptable. Asking for existing content difficulties to change is where the rub comes in I think. For situations like this, why not push for R11-15? Or possibly even more.

It doesn't even need to come with additional benefits, just additional challenge.

That sort of thing IMO is much more player friendly.
 

tiliabloom

Well-known member
There is evidence if you care to look. Even corroboration. I've cited both elements.🤣

None so blind as them who will not see. 😎👍
Really, you've cited that there was never an intention to further reduce damage at high reapers? And other than Torc's "your request for more difficulty has been heard", where is the corroboration? Torc didn't say who requested it, didn't link to other comments regarding the request for less damage, etc.

I'm here hat in hand, asking you for the citations and the evidence (not just "clearly this wasn't their intention" but the actual evidence that this wasn't their intention). I may be blind, but I'm asking to see. Can you show your citations and evidence?
 

tiliabloom

Well-known member
I mean... We lose of our current damage precisely 2.9% on r9 and 5.6% on r10 comparing it to right now.
That's not exactly true.

If your base damage is 1,000 then currently in R9, your damage that goes through is 179 (17.9% of 1,000) and after the change your damage that will go through is 150 (15.0% of 1,000). That's a reduction of 2.9% from your base damage, but you aren't doing base damage in reaper. The real impact is a reduction of 29 from 179 or a reduction of 16.2%. For R10, that drops from 156 to 100, or a reduction of 35.9%.

Reduced damage doesn't really change the difficulty for players that have been asking for more difficulty as they'll still be able to outlast the enemies (it'll just take longer); what has largely been asked to increase difficulty is new reapers, different mechanics, variability/randomness, etc.
 

Shear-buckler

Master of reactions
Reduced damage doesn't really change the difficulty for players that have been asking for more difficulty as they'll still be able to outlast the enemies (it'll just take longer); what has largely been asked to increase difficulty is new reapers, different mechanics, variability/randomness, etc.
Ofcourse it does. That is evident from the fact that the most significant factor in the trivialisation of content is the massive increases in AoE burst damage.

Monsters cant pose a threat if they are dead. Or if they are helpless the instant players enters the room.

The next step is to nerf cc. Make cc a tiered system. On the first application mobs are slowed and weakened. On the second application helplessness kicks in. Higher skulls could have another tier before helpless.

Finally healing has to be significantly toned down. It is barely affected by skull scaling, so player healing vs player health pool scales way out of line.
 
Last edited:

woq

Well-known member
Really, you've cited that there was never an intention to further reduce damage at high reapers? And other than Torc's "your request for more difficulty has been heard", where is the corroboration? Torc didn't say who requested it, didn't link to other comments regarding the request for less damage, etc.

I'm here hat in hand, asking you for the citations and the evidence (not just "clearly this wasn't their intention" but the actual evidence that this wasn't their intention). I may be blind, but I'm asking to see. Can you show your citations and evidence?
As one of the people who asked - all you have to do is open either of the preview threads specific to the reaper damage adjustment. Those of us who think we do too much damage were vocal in those.


Nobody else really was vocal there. I think most people who asked for durability increase asked for other types of changes and mechanical changes as well, but would take the durability in the meantime.

There's good arguments to be made to hold off on the durability increase from 13% => 10% (or any other number) until they take a larger pass at reaper also just to see how the patch ends up shaking up as there are a number of things that change player damage and monster durability in there - from dr, to repeater/inquis/dl/... nerfs to bug fixes.

I still think it'll make r10s more fun and why I advocated for it personally - I didn't think it was a controversial take that player damage vastly outstripped r10 quest monster durability - enough so that many veteran players have gone to personal insults towards players they don't know over the change. Shouldn't have come as a surprise though, I suppose.
 
Last edited:

Jack Jarvis Esquire

Well-known member
Really, you've cited that there was never an intention to further reduce damage at high reapers? And other than Torc's "your request for more difficulty has been heard", where is the corroboration? Torc didn't say who requested it, didn't link to other comments regarding the request for less damage, etc.

I'm here hat in hand, asking you for the citations and the evidence (not just "clearly this wasn't their intention" but the actual evidence that this wasn't their intention). I may be blind, but I'm asking to see. Can you show your citations and evidence?
Ok I'll spell it out one more time for the hard of thinking...

1. The Devs equalised damage in P1. Job done. They then, after P1, moved to increase the difficulty in P2 after feedback.

2. Corroberration: Tolero confirms feedback was heard when moving to P2.

Those are the facts.

You may not like those facts, but unless you can explain: 1. Why it took 2 iterations to get to current state if their intent was to do this from the off, and 2. What Tolero's comment was about if not that, then you may as well get the tinfoil hats out and start believing in fairies. 🤣

This shouldn't be difficult. Either you're too stupid to see what is patently obvious, or more likely, just too pissed off to accept the reality of what has happened. 👍

Either way stop wasting both our times with nonsense and suppositions. You're entitled to your own opinions, not your own facts. Leave that **** to POTUS and his minions. 😁👍
 

VinoeWhines

Well-known member
Per Torc Preview 1:

Reaper Damage Adjustment Overview: We are adjusting the rate reaper effects player outgoing damage in the following ways.
  • Caster Damage is going up to nearly where everyone else is in high skull reaper
  • Everyone else is coming down to equalize with casters to offset imbue buff halo and to help keep the top of reaper challenging for full parties
  • The player damage being increased across the board in high reaper in raids so the raw time it takes to complete a raid on high reaper is greatly reduced, and the build DPS meta is less extremely focused on the very top builds.



    Current Reaper Damage Mods:
SkullDamage Mod MeleeDamage Mod RangedDamage Mod Spell
1.77.77.77
2.67.67.67
3.56.56.55
4.45.45.45
5.37.37.37
6.30.30.30
7.25.25.23
8.20.20.19
9.17.17.15
10.15.15.10


New Quest Numbers

SkullPlayer Damage Mod ALL %
177%
267%
356%
445%
537%
630%
725%
820%
916%
1013%


New Raid Numbers



SkullPlayer Damage Mod ALL %
177%
268%
360%
455%
550%
645%
741%
836%
930%
1023%

Some people are saying that this isn't enough and there should be more damage nerfs.
I have always stated to go the opposite. Give players their full damage and just raise monster damage and everything else all higher.
Give Side Optional Chests hit high values.

Players need to be challenged with their real abilities. Not one hand tied behind their backs to see how tough they are.


Or make Reaper 10 the True Nerf:

The Dungeon Master wants to kill you Harderer​
  • ....the DM removes All your Past Lives and its abilities. You are a Mortal and have full use of All your abilities.
  • R1: Less nerf R10 Full Sponge
 

Sorccadin

Well-known member
That's not exactly true.

If your base damage is 1,000 then currently in R9, your damage that goes through is 179 (17.9% of 1,000) and after the change your damage that will go through is 150 (15.0% of 1,000). That's a reduction of 2.9% from your base damage, but you aren't doing base damage in reaper. The real impact is a reduction of 29 from 179 or a reduction of 16.2%. For R10, that drops from 156 to 100, or a reduction of 35.9%.

Reduced damage doesn't really change the difficulty for players that have been asking for more difficulty as they'll still be able to outlast the enemies (it'll just take longer); what has largely been asked to increase difficulty is new reapers, different mechanics, variability/randomness, etc.
This is true to an extend. Though I wasn't saying exactly that we lose 5%.

Should have clarified that's it's global %, though that also wasnt the main point. It would be most likely fine if it went through, esp with the amount of power high power characters have.

At no point did I completely agree with the change. I did say it divides the player base by vertical scaling (just numbers). I also asked for a better way like introducing mechanics (I.e. champions or reaper types; horizontal scaling) that make the experience actually more challenging in a fun way.

Yes, I do think that losing ×% of your damage is fine; after all right now it can be a not of a zerg. But since it appears the changes are being delayed we won't have to worry about it for now, do we?
 

tiliabloom

Well-known member
Ofcourse it does. That is evident from the fact that the most significant factor in the trivialisation of content is the massive increases in AoE burst damage.

Monsters cant pose a threat if they are dead. Or if they are helpless the instant players enters the room.

The next step is to nerf cc. Make cc a tiered system. On the first application mobs are slowed and weakened. On the second application helplessness kicks in. Higher skulls could have another tier before helpless.

Finally healing has to be significantly toned down. It is barely affected by skull scaling, so player healing vs player health pool scales way out of line.
First, CC is already nerfed (8% length on R10) and second, your solution (slowed on first application, helpless on second) is an example of a mechanic that could be implemented. Which is largely what the "make it more difficult" base is asking for, not just reduction in damage.

Also, self-healing is nerfed in combat and if your argument is that all healing should be nerfed (I'm not sure, your sentence is not clear) then all that does is push towards self-healing since it doesn't matter where the healing comes from and if your argument is that only self-healing should be nerfed - well, that's where were currently at.
 

tiliabloom

Well-known member
Ok I'll spell it out one more time for the hard of thinking...

1. The Devs equalised damage in P1. Job done. They then, after P1, moved to increase the difficulty in P2 after feedback.

2. Corroberration: Tolero confirms feedback was heard when moving to P2.

Those are the facts.

You may not like those facts, but unless you can explain: 1. Why it took 2 iterations to get to current state if their intent was to do this from the off, and 2. What Tolero's comment was about if not that, then you may as well get the tinfoil hats out and start believing in fairies. 🤣

This shouldn't be difficult. Either you're too stupid to see what is patently obvious, or more likely, just too pissed off to accept the reality of what has happened. 👍

Either way stop wasting both our times with nonsense and suppositions. You're entitled to your own opinions, not your own facts. Leave that **** to POTUS and his minions. 😁👍
I never claimed that their intention was to make the second change now - I asked you what the clear evidence was that they were never going to make the change to 15%/10% after preview 1. That was your claim: they made a change in P1 and a different change in P2 and because they made two changes it was never their intention to do the second change.

That's the fact: your claim that they clearly didn't intend to ever change it to 15%/10% was because they didn't make the change immediately, and your evidence that they were never going to make the second change is that they didn't make the change immediately.
 

Shear-buckler

Master of reactions
First, CC is already nerfed (8% length on R10) and second, your solution (slowed on first application, helpless on second) is an example of a mechanic that could be implemented. Which is largely what the "make it more difficult" base is asking for, not just reduction in damage.
CC is not nerfed enough. Most cc'able mobs are permanently ccd.
Regardless, my suggestion would still mean nothing if the player damage is not reduced. Dead monsters dont need to be ccd.

The alternative to a large damage penalty is massive nerfs all around, and that is not exactly popular either.

Also, self-healing is nerfed in combat and if your argument is that all healing should be nerfed (I'm not sure, your sentence is not clear) then all that does is push towards self-healing since it doesn't matter where the healing comes from and if your argument is that only self-healing should be nerfed - well, that's where were currently at.
I am not talking about self healing. Just regular healing should be reduced far more than it currently is. The damage penalty stems from player number having scaled up too high, and the same is true for healing. Healing numbers are far too high and efficient making it hard to challange players with damage other than "one-shots".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top