U82 Preview 3 - Summary of Changes since Preview 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

mikarddo

Well-known member
In good game design, abilities that make the game stale, like mass-hold, dire charge, or drifting lotus have to be discouraged as optimal play. Training wheels have to come off at some point. So from the point of view of good game design, drifting lotus is well-balanced. It's a point of view thing.
However, currently OP dps is what is making DDO very one sided and stale.
 

Igognito

Well-known member
I think everyone is losing the breath at this point.
They will soon roll out a version and we will soon know the impact.
 

The Being

Well-known member
In good game design, abilities that make the game stale, like mass-hold, dire charge, or drifting lotus have to be discouraged as optimal play. Training wheels have to come off at some point. So from the point of view of good game design, drifting lotus is well-balanced. It's a point of view thing.
No matter how you design a game, there will be an optimal play. And then it needs to be nerfed as a consequence and a new optimal play emerges from the options not taken prior. Rinse and repeat from there?

Current optimal play is "have enough dps so that you don't need anything else". Even if other options exist to trivialise content, such DPS will still be faster.
 

Dergex

Well-known member
Honestly, at some point you really need to start looking into self-imposed challenges if what you're really aiming for is difficulty. Even games like Elden Ring and Dark Souls have people that do challenge modes of either speed runs, level 1 runs, or specific/no-equipment runs.

If it's really that big of a deal for you that you absolutely do not want additional difficulty steps above R10 or any additional difficulty toggles... and you view the current difficulty as too easy to beat.. Then your best option may be to do things like an undersized party, limiting CC in your group, or purposefully resetting your Reaper tree so you have less actual power.
 

Tilomere

Well-known member
However, currently OP dps is what is making DDO very one sided and stale.
I mean, they are addressing that. QQ is being cut in half, less for high doublestrike builds. So is ki bolt, but I never thought it was overpowered. Shouts are getting hit, more on Sorc than bard. NHB/EF are getting removed. Melee and casters are both facing higher R10 damage penalties. PUG raid bosses are going to get shredded though, but they can always do a raid difficulty damage % adjustment, so I think any issues arising will be easy to fix.
 

SongandTime

Well-known member
I can't speak for others but increasing the damage required for destroying monsters isn't making the difficulty harder, it just makes the questing longer. We want different things to reaper, more reapers, special effects (like on hardcore), etc.
No, we don't want more Reapers..........................takes the immersion away for me and Im sure others. For me this is DnD not Reapers Online
 

woq

Well-known member
No, we don't want more Reapers..........................takes the immersion away for me and Im sure others. For me this is DnD not Reapers Online
Would you be fine with champion modifiers that significantly changes the way a monster behaves instead - to mimic what a new reaper might do?
 

Smokewolf

Frequently banned member.
SOME elitist people asked for it... At least make a real OFFICIAL POLL to get the players' opinions.

DDO is a PvE game, there is no need for a "difficult" endgame, especially for classic quests—and even more so considering that playing on R10 doesn't give any extra bonuses other than more Reaper XP, maybe some fun, and a greater waste of time. The higher the damage restriction, the less room there is for build diversity and FUN. Difficulty is what forces people to min-max and creates a "META" where everyone ends up running the exact same builds to keep up with that difficulty. If the difficulty were lower and a off-meta build could survive and perform well in R10, it would open the door to diversity, hybrid builds, more customization, utility builds, and so on.

Warframe, which is also a PvE game, understood that being overpowered and dominating the endgame isn't an issue—the whole point is to have FUN!!! Their team's primary goal is variety over perfect balance, operating on the belief that an item only becomes problematic when it renders every other option obsolete.

So my answer is: "NO, I didn't ask to do less damage in Reaper 10, and I'm pretty sure most players feel the exact same way." Awaiting an official DEV POLL. Thanks.
Polls on forums don't matter, as all they do is inflame the situation and bring out the worst in people. Besides, its the Dev's who should be "ask" this, rather than relying on the player base to do their jobs for them.
 

Sand

Member
It's also a 10% increase in melee/ranged damage for everyone standing inside that consecration circle; which could allow for a 100% uptime without ever using the epic strike. If you want the perks of consecration between the corrected cooldown, can just use the epic strike ability.
Hi, I see your point, I almost agree what you say.
In my opinion there are some additional aspects to highlight (sorry for long post):
- to get +10% damage an Alt must spend other 2 Destiny points in the tree (Crusade), so it's not free, so it's very probable but not mandatory that all players using Consecration have this extra feature.
- I guess that the rationale beside this change is not the +10% damage 100% uptime, but the continuous stacking healing, but any comment from Devs behind this choise would be appreciated (if any, I missed it, sorry). If the problem was the extra damage, there would be something odd with all the other damage increasing present in last/new updates (weapons, feats, domains).
- spending 3 points in a Tier 3 power for no relevant differences with a Tier 1 power is not too effective. Alternatively, it could be more appropriate to replace Rank 3 extra benefits with something like +6% doublestrike or +2 smite evil charges. The saving of 15SP is negligible for any cleric/FvS.
- in my opinion the Divine Crusader Epic Strike (Consecration) is a quite defensive power. It's possible to move a little more toward offensive power by spending 4 more points in the Tree, to get 'Enemies take 1d6 damage split between Fire and Light damage per Character Level, with both damage types scaling with your Fire spell power+10% damage to melee and ranged attacks and +1 bonus Imbue Dice' (2 destiny points) and 'nearby enemies must make a Fortitude saving throw (DC: 20 + highest Ability Score mod + Sunder DCs) or become Cowered for 4 seconds' (2 destiny points). Anyway, the damages made by 1d6/lvl scale with R skulls, so they are quite low (~700/3sec scaling with R), and I've never seen an insane sequence of cowered enemies when Consecration activates (for sure it doesn't happen when my Alt uses it).
- the need of manually activating Consecration reduces a lot the capability to combine it with other Epic Strikes. Alts have access to 3 different Epic Destinies, and all shares the Epic Strikes cooldown time. Activating an Epic Strike from another Destiny restarts the Consecration cooldown timer (at least 20s), making very hard to use it in combination with other Epic Strikes after the initial time. That's the very useful power behind the automatic activation of Consecration, which is out of the Epic Strike cooldown. That's why I can agree in removing the stacking healing, but it would be very nerfing for that power setting a cooldown timer of 2 minutes.

As final comments, I've no evidences running several quests and raids during last 5-6 years that 'How Dare You Strike Me' rank 3 could have unbalanced or jeopardized the game mechanics, but other players can report different feeling and feedbacks. :)
 

woq

Well-known member
How Dare You Strike Me only made raid solo/shortman challenges easier, but didn't have many other balance impacts in my experience. It didn't significantly devalue healers in R1 raids for example (in my experience anyway - maybe others had a different one).

It allowed builds that otherwise wouldn't be able to do it solo stuff like Fire over Morgrave and Vision of Destruction, but other than that... Very minor impact imo. And those raids are both still soloable without it anyway - if not quite as easy.

To me it comes across as a fix for the sake of fixing a thing that isn't doing what it says on the description. Like Undying Call, the effect as designed and displayed on description is really bad and should be reworked if attention is given to fixing the thing.

Edit: oh, maybe multiboxing people were a bit too unfairly strongly utilizing this effect for healing and survival, now that I think about it.
 
Last edited:

Ryiah

Well-known member
TBH I don't mind when people are asking for more difficulty, but I do mind when they talk about changing the default difficulty that everyone else has to deal with. Sure, not a ton of people play R10 right now. But I'm sure of those people there are at least a number of them that prefer the current level of difficulty.

People want higher difficulty?

Add R11-R15
Okay, but why wouldn't the people who currently run R10 for reasons other than just pure difficulty not just start running R15 too? I think that's the only thing I have against simply introducing more difficulties. Once upon a time Elite was the highest difficulty and most people ran it, and now it's R10 and a significant number of people at end game are running it because of the rewards.

You would have to introduce higher difficulties with no rewards whatsoever, but then almost no one would run those difficulties.
 
Last edited:

KingZela

Member
Since this preview is mostly about UI scaling and Lucky Loot (surprise!) not much else is changing from preview 2. However, this post contains changes we'll be making based on preview 2 feedback, but all of them are still in process and are not in this build.

I REPEAT: NONE OF THESE CHANGES ARE IN THIS PREVIEW BUILD. THEY ARE COMING SOON.

Misc Cleanup Changes​

  • The Martial Epic Past Live Feat is changing to: +1% AC +1 MRR +1 MMR Cap per life (so full set 15% AC, +15 MRR, +15 MRR Cap)
  • The following raid bosses no longer randomize their HP roll and will always have the average of what that roll would have resulted in.

    • The Dracolich from threats old and new
    • The Five Fangs Hydra in Den of Vipers
    • Demogorgon in the Terror of the Demons
    • The Relentless Killer in Relentless
  • Fixed an issue where monsters were scaling their to hit bonuses by 20% more than they should've in level 34+ content.

Enhancements​

  • Artificer: Engine Strike now deals +100% damage (was 200% in preview 2)
  • Inquisitive's Mind like Iron now grants the specific no-fail save bonuses it mentions in its tooltip.
  • Divine Crusader: How Dare You Strike Me (Rank 3) now properly respects its cooldown.

Reaper Damage Changes​

  • Quest (not raid) Player damage going to 15%/10% for skulls 9/10: Your request for more difficulty has been answered.

Cantrips​

  • New Cantrip: Cut: 30 meter instant 1d6 slashing damage, scales with force, given to sorcs/wiz/trickster/arties.

Spell Pass/Masteries​

  • Carrion Swarm will now save for half damage per tick instead of canceling the effect on save.
  • Fixed the following bugs:
    • Drow Dark Fire not working with master of alignment
    • Creeping cold spells not using the right effect and displaying.
    • Divine Wrath not trigging Master of Fire and Light
    • SLA Reverberate's cooldown adjusted to 5 seconds
    • Various tool tips being incorrect on SLA abilities that we updated in the pass.
    • Disrupt Cantrip firing acid instead of neg for master of decay
    • Some Pale Master spells not working with Master of Decay
    • Fixed the flags for several Ki spells that were not triggering the appropriate Mastery feat
    • Incinerating Wave no longer behaves strangely and now just does its damage without any weirdness
  • Note: If you are a Sorcerer missing a spell slot from the cut bolt spells go talk to your trainer about swapping spells and you should have a free swap in. If that doesn't work relog, and try again, if that still doesn't work, let us know!
Okay good but im gonna ask again, warlocks should have immunity strip for every pact, just pact so can be atleast fun to play with others pacts or we gonna be playing with fey pact forever and fix warlock enhancement spells, weak and hard to hit, new feat to strip doesnt actually help, 2 feats to deal less damage than fey pact so PLEASE atleast let us having fun playing with warlock.. thx.
 

songswrath

Well-known member
Okay, but why wouldn't the people who currently run R10 for reasons other than just pure difficulty not just start running R15 too? I think that's the only thing I have against simply introducing more difficulties. Once upon a time Elite was the highest difficulty and most people ran it, and now it's R10 and a significant number of people at end game are running it because of the rewards.

You would have to introduce higher difficulties with no rewards whatsoever, but then almost no one would run those difficulties.
i like this better than all the dumb changes ppl keep talking about. call it suicide or death pact mode . 1 )you can't self raise ( cakes ) 2) no temp hp 3) scrolls/clickies casting is locked out , meaning raises have to be from class spell list along with out of class buffs you normally can't
access , scaling is same as r10
 

Igognito

Well-known member
i like this better than all the dumb changes ppl keep talking about. call it suicide or death pact mode . 1 )you can't self raise ( cakes ) 2) no temp hp 3) scrolls/clickies casting is locked out , meaning raises have to be from class spell list along with out of class buffs you normally can't
access , scaling is same as r10
I would like to see a new difficulty: Hard Core
1) no res shrines in dungeons unless the are part of the dungeon mechanic (e.g. shroud)
2) no cakes, no jibbers, perhaps no self raise powers.
3) no hires, (allow 1 specific hire to be used for switches and pressure panels)
4) no reaper tree.
5) all equipment must be btc all equipment found is btc
6) rewards are: cosmetics, DDO points, universal enhancement tree.
7) clearly for those who didn't guessed it toon starts from 0.
8) and the dungeon is at elite+
 

VinoeWhines

Well-known member
:::[ Dungeon Completions ]:::

[3 End Chests]

[3 Paths]​




Path 1: Pure DPS Onlsaught to the Exit with bonus chest for specific targets killed prior to end

Path 2: Complete Objective without being Detected by NPC with bonus chest for not spotted

Path 3: Find the missing item to return to NPC with bonus chest if able to bring optional items



------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
golden-axe-warrior-world-map-i-made-on-excel-v0-r0tzi9vsyg0d1.jpeg

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


WARNING!
Optionals are at your own Risk.
Some contain Great Treasures and others Great Perils....
 

songswrath

Well-known member
I would like to see a new difficulty: Hard Core
1) no res shrines in dungeons unless the are part of the dungeon mechanic (e.g. shroud)
2) no cakes, no jibbers, perhaps no self raise powers.
3) no hires, (allow 1 specific hire to be used for switches and pressure panels)
4) no reaper tree.
5) all equipment must be btc all equipment found is btc
6) rewards are: cosmetics, DDO points, universal enhancement tree.
7) clearly for those who didn't guessed it toon starts from 0.
8) and the dungeon is at elite+
how about no. hard core trash stop tryign to bring that crap back
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top