U82 Preview 3

Status
Not open for further replies.

Igognito

Well-known member
@Tonquin , I had a few questions that have not been answered related the DR changes.

1) some monsters have also PRR, how it interacts with DR?
2) how DR interacts with the forcefield that is a blanket 25% damage reduction?
3) how Stoneskin and other spells work on monsters now?
4) how stone guard champions damage absorb interacts with DR?

Thank you in advance.
 

Tonquin

of Lightning Hammer fame!
@Tonquin , I had a few questions that have not been answered related the DR changes.

1) some monsters have also PRR, how it interacts with DR?
DR is its own layer of multiplicative reduction, similar to how MRR and Fire Absorption are their own separate multiplicative layers. A monster having PRR doesn't affect their DR reduction amount, and vice versa, just as these layers don't interact right now.
2) how DR interacts with the forcefield that is a blanket 25% damage reduction?
That is an Absorption effect, which is its own layer of multiplicative damage prevention. So, just as PRR and DR are handled separately, Absorption is also handled separately. A really tough monster with DR Bludgeoning (25% reduction), 25% Slashing damage absorption, and 100 PRR will turn 100 Slashing damage into 100 * .75 * .75 * .5 = 28.125 damage. The reductions do not get added together (25% + 25% + 50% = 100% = invincible monster!!! argh!!) but are each handled in their own step of the combat damage flow.
3) how Stoneskin and other spells work on monsters now?
As Stoneskin is an Ablative DR, it continues to work as it does now. Here's some more info if you're curious:
Great question. The answer is no - Stoneskin is Ablative DR, and that is handled in a separate calculation. It does not count as 50% damage reduction, and it is removed when it has prevented enough damage as it currently is now.
4) how stone guard champions damage absorb interacts with DR?

Thank you in advance.
Stone Guard is a really big Stoneskin. So, as it's Ablative DR, it's handled in a separate calculation :)
 

Igognito

Well-known member
DR is its own layer of multiplicative reduction, similar to how MRR and Fire Absorption are their own separate multiplicative layers. A monster having PRR doesn't affect their DR reduction amount, and vice versa, just as these layers don't interact right now.

That is an Absorption effect, which is its own layer of multiplicative damage prevention. So, just as PRR and DR are handled separately, Absorption is also handled separately. A really tough monster with DR Bludgeoning (25% reduction), 25% Slashing damage absorption, and 100 PRR will turn 100 Slashing damage into 100 * .75 * .75 * .5 = 28.125 damage. The reductions do not get added together (25% + 25% + 50% = 100% = invincible monster!!! argh!!) but are each handled in their own step of the combat damage flow.

As Stoneskin is an Ablative DR, it continues to work as it does now. Here's some more info if you're curious:


Stone Guard is a really big Stoneskin. So, as it's Ablative DR, it's handled in a separate calculation :)
Thank you...
 

Chacka

Well-known member
DR is its own layer of multiplicative reduction, similar to how MRR and Fire Absorption are their own separate multiplicative layers. A monster having PRR doesn't affect their DR reduction amount, and vice versa, just as these layers don't interact right now.

That is an Absorption effect, which is its own layer of multiplicative damage prevention. So, just as PRR and DR are handled separately, Absorption is also handled separately. A really tough monster with DR Bludgeoning (25% reduction), 25% Slashing damage absorption, and 100 PRR will turn 100 Slashing damage into 100 * .75 * .75 * .5 = 28.125 damage. The reductions do not get added together (25% + 25% + 50% = 100% = invincible monster!!! argh!!) but are each handled in their own step of the combat damage flow.

As Stoneskin is an Ablative DR, it continues to work as it does now. Here's some more info if you're curious:


Stone Guard is a really big Stoneskin. So, as it's Ablative DR, it's handled in a separate calculation :)
I also wonder what happens if you use Flesh to Stone or similar spells on a monster and don't have an adamantine weapon. Currently the monster gets DR 15/adamantine, and I'd just assume it will get 50% until the spell wears off.
 

Wrensel

Well-known member
I also wonder what happens if you use Flesh to Stone or similar spells on a monster and don't have an adamantine weapon. Currently the monster gets DR 15/adamantine, and I'd just assume it will get 50% until the spell wears off.
It was mentioned near the bottom of one of these official DR thread starters:
Tonquin

Finally, to help prevent some unneeded clunkiness, spells or abilities that grant an enemy some kind of Damage Reduction, such as Freezing Ice, no longer apply that DR.
 

Rull

Well-known member
@Tonquin is sneak damage reduced as well?

I remember sneak and regular damage were closely related (when the sneak damage recieved a multiplier, that was actually added to the first number, making the total correct, but the regular / sneak damage numbers wrong).

So I'd assume they are typed the same, and therefore also reduced by not having a silver or a blunt weapon.
 

f1b041b3

Well-known member
Stone Guard is a really big Stoneskin. So, as it's Ablative DR, it's handled in a separate calculation :)
That "really big Stoneskin" needs to be tuned down because the amount of damage absorption it gives is already punitively high for anyone not using bludgeoning weapons, and adding another 25 or 50% dr on top of that is outrageous.
 

Igognito

Well-known member
That "really big Stoneskin" needs to be tuned down because the amount of damage absorption it gives is already punitively high for anyone not using bludgeoning weapons, and adding another 25 or 50% dr on top of that is outrageous.
I would suggest to be covered to DR so it won't stack. It could be B but if the creature is B by nature such as a skelie make it bane.
But let's see how people will react when they will actually get combos of these powers.
 

Wrensel

Well-known member
That "really big Stoneskin" needs to be tuned down because the amount of damage absorption it gives is already punitively high for anyone not using bludgeoning weapons, and adding another 25 or 50% dr on top of that is outrageous.
I don't believe the ablative damage reduction (Stoneskin, Ablative Armor, or probably Protection from Energy if that somehow is a factor for Energy Weapons) gets percentile Damage Reduction of 25%/50% on top. It just performs the flat reduction and removes that amount from the buff.
 

f1b041b3

Well-known member
I don't believe the ablative damage reduction (Stoneskin, Ablative Armor, or probably Protection from Energy if that somehow is a factor for Energy Weapons) gets percentile Damage Reduction of 25%/50% on top. It just performs the flat reduction and removes that amount from the buff.
It will for stone guard champs that have any amount of dr. If the stone guard effect was coded as dr instead of absorption then it wouldn't be a problem.
 

Richard

Well-known member
Can you please then take into consideration the DR breaker feats consolidate to bypass two DR instead of one, like Cold iron and silver, Adamantine and crystal, or good and evil, law and chaotic?
 

Phaedra

Well-known member
It will for stone guard champs that have any amount of dr. If the stone guard effect was coded as dr instead of absorption then it wouldn't be a problem.
In every other case, flat reductions are applied before percentile reductions, (which is why no one cares about energy resistances or flat DR in end game play) so Stoneguard mobs shouldn't be any more of a problem than they were before.
 

Synalon

Choose another soldier
Also, stone guard champs are meant to have high physical DR...? That's the whole point of the champ type
 

f1b041b3

Well-known member
In every other case, flat reductions are applied before percentile reductions, (which is why no one cares about energy resistances or flat DR in end game play) so Stoneguard mobs shouldn't be any more of a problem than they were before.
The effect is "Absorb Piercing and Slashing," which implies that it is percentage based. Even if it is coded as resistance, it dwarfs the 60-70 points that a pc can achieve. Adding another 25-50% dr-based absorption on top is insane.
Also, stone guard champs are meant to have high physical DR...? That's the whole point of the champ type
They already have more than they should.
 

Sarlona Raiding

Well-known member
Great job team!

I think overall U82 is a huge win. So much to like with this release:
- Hand and a half changes
- Archmage changes
- DR system much better with changes introduce after the first update
- So many good feat and enhancement changes
- Improved inspection is a great quality of life update
- The nerfs mostly seemed spot-on - crossbow builds and shuri throwers will be fine

There are just a few places where I think you may have steered a bit off-course
- Caster changes ended up just being some shuffling around and at the end of the day the only significant change aside from archmage is that casters are on equal footing with other builds in R10 which impacts a portion of the community - but I have no idea what % - certainly not 100%. However, archamge is a big buff which is nice.
- The martial past life feat change shouldn't have been slipped in misc. changes in update 2 and the stated reason for the change is heroic leveling. But I don't see any scenario where heroic leveling changes even a tiny amount. Ultimately it's just power creep for non-tanks giving a bonus to builds that probably didn't need it, while taking away a bonus from tanks that really don't need a nerf.

I didn't get enough loot chances to comment on the lucky loot system, but I didn't see anything I would use. It could be great for people that need gear if vets are willing to post some of the better items on the auction house. I will try to do that if I notice anything decent.

I run ddo on a low resolution so I don't think I the UI scaling is something I will use. I might play around with that at a later time, but it's something the community is excited about.

I don't know if this is a change not posted or something I missed in known issues somewhere, but dwarven axes and bastard swords do not get impacted by knight's training in this update on Lamannia.

The warhammer was updated and oddly it gets +1 range even with improved critical slashing. When I added improved critical bludgeoning I got the extra +1 range on my weapon along with a knight's training indicator.

I saw no such indicator and no change on my bastard sword or dwarven axe. Even though the knight's training feat indicated it should work.

If you are planning not to add those to Knight's training after all it would be great if you let the community know, because people are making respecs based on notes you released and not what actually exists on Lamannia. Curveballs on release day could be a major let down for people that thought they were preparing.

Once again, great job! I think this update will be a huge hit.
 

SquireZed

Well-known member
Great job team!

I think overall U82 is a huge win. So much to like with this release:
Agree, U82 should be, overall, a lot better. There are a handful of pain points but I'll wait and see if they're actually as painful as they could be
- The nerfs mostly seemed spot-on - crossbow builds and shuri throwers will be fine
But my NHB 2 second R10 clears! Nooooo! /s

Realistically almost all the nerfs are pretty well directed, even if I don't necessarily agree with, for example, the exact implementation of the DR changes or the adjustments to martial past lives (the logic for why they're doing it, though, checks out). The only change I am left really scratching my heads on is the metamagics nerf to maximize and intensify. But even though I might not agree with all the nerfs in the minutia, most of them make sense and are at least *mostly* narrow enough to primarily touch overperforming builds without nerfing them into the ground, while not impacting general playstyles too much (a problem with some past nerfs).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top